Randolph County Commissioners Dissolve Library Board Amid Book Controversy
A 3-2 vote by county commissioners to dissolve the Randolph County Public Library board of trustees, following a decision to keep a book about a transgender boy in the children's section, has ignited debate over governance, parental rights, and community standards.
Source: x.com
Randolph County Commissioners have voted to dissolve the public library's board of trustees, a move that comes two months after the board decided to retain a book about a transgender boy in the children's section. The 3-2 decision, made after nearly two hours of public comment from approximately 200 attendees, removed all existing trustees and dissolved their governing bylaws.
The book in question, "Call Me Max," is recommended for ages 5-9 and has been described as teaching children that their parents may be wrong about their gender. Commissioners who voted in favor of dissolving the board, including Darrell Frye, Kenny Kidd, and Lester Rivenbark, stated their intention was to rebuild the board in a manner that better reflects community standards and parental concerns. Rivenbark emphasized that the vote was to dissolve the board, not to ban or remove any specific book from the library's shelves.
We voted to dissolve the entire board — not to remove a book. We will be adopting new bylaws, appointing a new nine-person library board, and we will not be voting on books. That authority will reside with the new board.— Lester Rivenbark
Commissioner Hope Haywood, who voted against the dismissal, expressed concern that plans for appointing new members and establishing new rules were not in place before the board was dissolved. She noted that three commissioners favored abolishing the board first and then addressing the subsequent steps.
David Allen, who has held the District 3 seat since 2014 and voted against the dismissal, highlighted the importance of institutional knowledge on the board and warned that the removal could set a poor precedent. Allen is running for re-election against Republican Carrie Slatosky, a soil and water district supervisor. Slatosky, who supports the commission's decision, has stated she does not support government book bans but believes "Call Me Max" should have been relocated from the children's section.
Slatosky has also addressed allegations stemming from past court records, including a dismissed simple assault charge from 2011 and a dismissed food nutrition fraud charge from 2013 for which she paid over $4,000 in restitution. She maintains she has never been convicted of a crime and stated she was a victim of domestic violence in the 2011 incident.
Proponents of the commissioners' decision argue that dissolving the board is a matter of governance, not censorship, and that county commissioners have the statutory authority to reconstitute appointed boards. They contend that the action addresses parental concerns that were previously dismissed and that public libraries, as publicly funded entities, have the right to curate collections without violating First Amendment protections. Opponents, however, have framed the action as an attack on the First Amendment.
Why it matters — The dissolution of the library board raises questions about local governance, the role of elected officials in library policy, and the balance between parental concerns and intellectual freedom.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The 3-2 decision, made after nearly two hours of public comment from approximately 200 attendees
- The book in question, "Call Me Max," is recommended for ages 5-9 and has been described as teaching children that their parents may be wrong about their gender.
- She noted that three commissioners favored abolishing the board first and then addressing the subsequent steps.
- David Allen, who has held the District 3 seat since 2014 and voted against the dismissal
- Slatosky has also addressed allegations stemming from past court records, including a dismissed simple assault charge from 2011 and a dismissed food nutrition fraud charge from 2013 for which she paid over $4,000 in restitution.
- She maintains she has never been convicted of a crime and stated she was a victim of domestic violence in the 2011 incident.
Reported by x.com, wfdd.org, wfmynews2.com, whqr.org, carolinajournal.com
- David AllenAmerican productivity consultant and author