Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Sports

BYU Fall Camp Opens With One Glaring Question: Who Catches the Ball?

Bear Bachmeier's starting job is secure, but the Cougars enter 2026 camp with a wide receiver room that has yet to produce a proven go-to target — and a College Football Playoff ceiling that depends on it.

How does this story make you feel?

Source: si.com

BYU football officially opened fall camp Tuesday with players reporting for meetings and equipment fittings, practices set to begin Wednesday — and for the first time in two years, the quarterback question is not the one keeping coaches up at night.

Sophomore Bear Bachmeier walks into camp as the unquestioned starter after defeating 12 of BYU's 14 opponents as a true freshman in 2025, according to Deseret News. The drama this August has migrated to a different position group entirely.

Former BYU linebacker and BYUtv football analyst David Nixon said on the 'Y's Guys' livestream this week that the focus is on the wide receivers, noting the need for a go-to receiver and that no one has clearly emerged as that player yet.

Nixon's assessment captures the central tension of BYU's 2026 camp: a program with legitimate College Football Playoff aspirations, a 23-4 record over two seasons, and a roster that analysts describe as sound at every position — except the one that has to get open.

JoJo Phillips, Oregon transfer Kyler Kasper, and freshman Legend Glasker are expected to lead the receiver group, according to Deseret News, with new tight ends Roger Saleapaga II (Oregon) and Walker Lyons (USC) adding depth at a position that could absorb some of the target load. But none of them have yet established themselves as the kind of reliable playmaker — a Puka Nacua or Chase Roberts type — that BYU's offense has leaned on in recent seasons.

That void matters more because of what Bachmeier still needs to fix. According to SI.com, he ranked 103rd in turnover-worthy play rate among qualified quarterbacks last season per PFF data — a common freshman ailment, but one that must improve. More pressing for a team eyeing the playoff: he ranked 107th in yards per attempt on deep throws. His mid-range work was genuinely elite — 16th nationally in yards per attempt on throws between 10 and 20 yards, 19th in accuracy rate on those same throws — but against Texas Tech, when BYU needed him to stretch the field vertically, he couldn't do it.

The chicken-and-egg problem is real: a quarterback develops his deep ball by throwing to receivers he trusts, and receivers earn that trust by winning in camp. BYU has roughly a month before its September 5 opener against Utah Tech at LaVell Edwards Stadium to answer both questions simultaneously.

Nixon, for his part, sees the receiver room as the program's only genuine vulnerability heading into its fourth Big 12 season.

Nixon said he sees no other problems with the roster and cannot recall a time when he felt good about every position group except wide receiver.

The defensive line is the other unit drawing serious attention from analysts, and for more optimistic reasons. According to SI.com, BYU spent three years building talent at the position and finally has a group with both ability and experience. Sophomores Nusi Taumoepeau and Hunter Clegg are projected as the top pass-rush threats, with Tausili Akana and veteran Bodie Schoonover also in the rotation. A consistent pass rush from the defensive front would represent a meaningful step for a program that has been good — but not dominant — on that side of the ball.

The coaching staff has also shifted. Kelly Poppinga takes over as defensive coordinator, Sione Po'uha adds associate head coaching duties, and three new faces join the defensive staff: safeties coach DeMario Warren, linebackers coach Chad Kauha'aha'a, and cornerbacks coach Lewis Walker, according to BYUCougars.com. The offensive staff is unchanged. Head coach Kalani Sitake enters his 11th season at BYU with an 84-45 record, per the school's official release.

Nixon's prescription for accelerating the receiver competition is pointed: he's calling on BYU's defensive backs and linebackers to push the receivers hard in practice — not to beat them up, but to force the kind of competitive reps that reveal who can be counted on when the game is on the line.

Nixon said defensive backs and linebackers should do everything possible to make sure receivers go 100% and give receivers coach Fesi Sitake and the offensive staff a good look at who the dependable players are in crunch time.

The Cougars open the season September 5 against Utah Tech at LaVell Edwards Stadium, with single-game tickets already on sale. The month between now and kickoff is when the receiver room either answers the question — or leaves it open heading into Big 12 play.

Why it matters — Whether BYU's unproven receiver corps can step up alongside a maturing Bachmeier will largely determine if the Cougars can break through to their first College Football Playoff appearance.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Depth at nickel is a concern amid injury questions heading into camp.
  • minor non-verbatim phrasing in first Nixon quote
  • second Nixon quote paraphrased for exactness

Reported by si.com, sports.ksl.com, byucougars.com, deseret.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email