More than half of young LDS women have left the church — and researchers now know why
New survey data puts Gen Z female retention at just 37.5% for 18-year-olds, and a forthcoming book points to three converging forces driving them out.
Source: sltrib.com
For decades, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints prided itself on keeping its members. In the 1980s, roughly 8 in 10 people raised in the faith stayed. Today, that number has fallen below half — and among young women, it has fallen further still.
Ryan Burge's 2025 Spiritual Seismology Survey, which included more than 1,100 adults raised as Latter-day Saints, found that only about 4 in 10 Generation Z women who grew up in the church still identify with it. For 18-year-old women specifically, the retention rate was 37.5%, according to the Salt Lake Tribune. Pew Research's 2023–24 Religious Landscape Study tells a similar story: two-thirds of LDS women over 50 have remained members, compared to just under half of younger women — a 17-point generational gap.
Those numbers are the backdrop for a column published this week by Jana Riess — a longtime Latter-day Saint, scholar, and Religion News Service columnist whose previous book, 'The Next Mormons,' helped define public understanding of LDS generational change. Her new piece draws on forthcoming research she conducted with political scientist Benjamin Knoll for an Oxford University Press book titled 'Leaving Mormonism: Who Is Exiting The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints — and Why.' The diagnosis she offers is built around three forces she calls 'the three P's': politics, purity culture, and powerlessness.
The politics piece tracks a well-documented national shift. Gallup data cited by Riess shows that 20 years ago, the gap between young women and young men who leaned politically left was just 3 percentage points. It has since widened to 15 points, with 40% of young women now identifying as liberal compared to 25% of young men. PRRI and Change Research have similarly identified Gen Z women as one of the most liberal demographic groups in the country, according to the Salt Lake Tribune. That matters for religious retention because, as Riess notes, political identity and religious identity have become increasingly entangled in America over the past half-century — and it can be isolating to hold liberal views inside a conservative institution.
The specific policy collisions are pointed. Gen Z women lead all demographic groups in supporting full legal equality for LGBTQ+ people; the church mounted a major political effort against same-sex marriage when many of these women were children. The church publicly opposed the Equal Rights Amendment not only in the 1970s but as recently as 2019–2020. And while the church permits abortion only in limited circumstances, young women broadly support legal access to it, according to the Salt Lake Tribune.
The second force — purity culture — is more intimate. Research tracking the church's official magazines found that through the 1990s, modest dress was taught to teens and adults of both genders roughly equally. In the early 2000s, that changed sharply: warnings about immodest dress directed specifically at teenage girls appeared about six times as often as comparable warnings to boys, according to the Salt Lake Tribune. Then-apostle Dallin Oaks, now the church's president, warned girls in 2005 that dressing immodestly meant they were, in his framing, 'becoming pornography' to men.
Riess interviewed women who came of age under that messaging. One, identified as Nicole, a 23-year-old, told her she 'learned how to avoid feeling sexual' as a teenager — and that two years after leaving the church, she was still working through the damage. Riess writes that Nicole 'is not alone in this,' according to the Salt Lake Tribune.
The third force is structural. Women in the LDS Church cannot hold the priesthood, perform baptisms, bless or pass the sacrament, or set institutional policy. In earlier generations, Riess argues, that exclusion mirrored broader society — gender inequality was widespread enough that the church wasn't an outlier. For a generation raised on the promise that they could do anything, the gap between what they experience everywhere else and what they're offered at church feels different.
The church has made some adjustments. In 2025, it allowed women to begin serving full-time missions at age 18, the same age as men, and introduced sleeveless temple garments, according to the Salt Lake Tribune. Whether those changes register with the demographic already walking out the door remains an open question.
The broader retention collapse is documented in a recent BYU Studies article, which traced the numbers back through decades of General Social Survey data. In the 1980s, 82% of those raised Latter-day Saint still identified as such as adults. That fell to 76% in the 1990s, 58% in the 2000s, and to just under half — 46% — by the 2010s and beyond, according to BYU Studies. The current Pew and Spiritual Seismology Survey data put the overall adult retention rate at just over 50%. The same BYU Studies article noted that active members who remain are, by several measures, thriving: they pray more, attend services more, and report higher happiness than most other Americans.
That contrast — a committed core growing more devout while a large cohort exits entirely — is increasingly the shape of American religious life. What makes the LDS case notable is the speed of the shift and the gender inversion at its center. For most of the church's modern history, women were more likely than men to stay. That is no longer true.
Why it matters — The LDS Church is losing young women faster than any other demographic at a moment when it can least afford it — and the reasons point to tensions between institutional tradition and the lived expectations of a generation that grew up being told gender equality was a given.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The church's 2025 policy allowing women to serve missions at age 18 is described as new; prior policy set the age at 19 for women.
Reported by sltrib.com, religionnews.com, exponentii.org, newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org, byustudies.byu.edu
- Dallin H. OaksPresident of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints