Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Local Gov

Orthodox Christianity's top leader: Ukraine's sovereignty is non-negotiable, not a bargaining chip

On the eve of the third anniversary of Russia's invasion, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew celebrated Mass in Istanbul with families of missing Ukrainian soldiers — and delivered a pointed rebuke to Moscow.

How does this story make you feel?

Source: en.wikipedia.org

The most senior figure in Eastern Orthodox Christianity used a Mass in Istanbul on Sunday to draw a clear line: Ukraine's sovereignty, he said, cannot be traded away at any negotiating table — not even one dressed up as diplomacy.

Ukraine’s sovereignty is not up for debate, nor can it be negotiated under the guise of diplomacy.— Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, Patriarch of Constantinople

Bartholomew, whose Constantinople-based seat makes him 'first among equals' in Eastern Orthodoxy, delivered the sermon as relatives and friends of Ukrainian soldiers missing or believed held in Russian captivity sat in the pews, according to AP News. The service drew tears. The timing — the eve of the third anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion — was not incidental.

Among those present was Tetiana Tantsiura, whose husband Oleg Naradko, a soldier in Ukraine's 115th Mechanized Brigade, vanished in July 2022.

It’s hard to talk about. He disappeared July 2022. Until this time, the current year, I don’t know anything. I only hope that he is alive, and he will return in Ukraine.— Tetiana Tantsiura, wife of missing Ukrainian soldier

Bartholomew also praised Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for his 'tireless effort' to defend the country's independence, and said any future peace deal 'must include Ukraine as an equal participant,' according to AP News.

No force can extinguish the spirit of the people who refuse to be broken. No nation has the right to force its will upon another, and no power can erase a people’s history.— Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, Patriarch of Constantinople

Bartholomew's words carry particular weight in the context of the war because the conflict has a deep Orthodox dimension. In 2019, he recognized the Orthodox Church of Ukraine — based in Kyiv — as independent from the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) and its Moscow Patriarchate. That decision prompted Russian Patriarch Kirill to sever contact with Constantinople, a rupture that has not healed. The ROC, which claims around 110 million members and jurisdiction over Orthodox Christians across most of the former Soviet Union, has remained aligned with the Kremlin throughout the war.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has repeatedly framed the invasion partly as a defense of Russian Orthodox communities in Ukraine — a justification that leaders of both Ukrainian Orthodox factions, as well as Ukraine's significant Catholic minority, have strongly condemned, according to AP News. The ROC and the Moscow Patriarchate are not synonymous with all Orthodox Christians in Ukraine: the country remains split between the Kyiv-based independent church and a smaller church still aligned with Moscow.

Ukraine's consul general to Istanbul, Nedilskyi Roman, thanked the patriarch directly at the service.

Your prayers have given us the strength to stand and fight the insidious enemy for 3 years. Thank you for your personal and spiritual support to millions of Ukrainians around the world who were forced to leave their homes to save the lives of their children.— Nedilskyi Roman, Ukraine's Consul General to Istanbul

The rift between Constantinople and Moscow is the sharpest fracture in global Orthodoxy in decades. The ROC is by far the largest Orthodox church — its roots trace to the 988 baptism of Vladimir the Great and the Christianization of Kievan Rus', a history both Russia and Ukraine claim as their own. That contested heritage sits at the heart of why the religious dimension of this war is so charged: Moscow has long argued that Kyiv is the spiritual cradle of Russian Orthodox civilization, a claim Ukrainian Orthodox leaders flatly reject.

Why it matters — The head of global Orthodoxy publicly rejecting any peace deal that sidelines Ukraine — just as ceasefire talks gain momentum — signals that the war's religious fault line remains wide open and that Moscow cannot claim Orthodox Christianity's moral authority as cover for its territorial ambitions.

Sources differ on Spiritual and historical ownership of Kievan Rus' Orthodox heritage: Moscow Patriarchate claims Kyiv as the cradle of Russian Orthodox civilization and asserts jurisdiction over Orthodox Christians across former Soviet republics excluding Georgia. (wikipedia.org) vs The Orthodox Church of Ukraine, recognized by Constantinople in 2019, asserts its own independent ecclesiastical identity rooted in the same Kievan Rus' history. (apnews.com)

Reported by wikipedia.org, reuters.com, apnews.com, churchtimes.co.uk

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email