Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Environmental groups sue EPA over repeal of power plant climate rules

A coalition of health and environmental organizations filed suit in federal court days after the Trump EPA finalized the elimination of Biden-era carbon limits for coal and gas plants — and proposed wiping out all remaining greenhouse gas rules for the sector.

How does this story make you feel?

A legal challenge was lodged Thursday in the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit by six environmental and public health organizations, taking aim at the Trump EPA's final rule that eliminates greenhouse gas emission limits for power plants. Filing the petition were the Natural Resources Defense Council, American Lung Association, American Public Health Association, Clean Air Council, Clean Wisconsin, and the Environmental Defense Fund, setting in motion what observers expect will be a lengthy court battle over the administration's broadest climate deregulation action to date.

The lawsuit follows a Monday announcement by EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin at a G20 energy meeting in Houston, where he declared the repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards — Biden-era rules that required coal and new natural gas-fired power plants to cut or capture 90% of their carbon emissions. The agency simultaneously proposed eliminating every remaining greenhouse gas standard for the power sector, a move that, if finalized, would also seek to strip future administrations of the legal authority to reimpose such limits.

For over 15 years, the Obama and Biden administrations implemented a war on coal to destroy reliable and affordable energy. The Trump Administration has come in to protect American energy and to make sure you can afford to keep the lights on.— Lee Zeldin, EPA Administrator

The EPA framed the repeal as the largest power sector deregulatory action in US history, projecting it will save $310 billion by ending requirements for carbon capture technology the agency says was never adequately demonstrated. A concurrent proposal to rescind all remaining greenhouse gas rules for power plants would save an additional $370 million in direct compliance costs, according to the agency. The agency further contended that emissions from power plants have "no material impact on global climate change" and that eliminating all carbon dioxide from the sector would produce "no meaningful climate impact."

That claim sits at the center of the legal and scientific dispute. Power plants are the second-largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in the US, accounting for nearly 25% of the nation's total climate pollution, according to CNN. US power plants alone contribute 3% of global climate pollution. According to the original EPA regulatory impact analysis, the Biden-era standards that the agency has now repealed were on track to cut carbon pollution from the power sector by 75% relative to its 2005 peak, avert 1,200 premature deaths in 2035 alone, and generate $120 billion in health benefits through 2047.

The Trump administration is now kicking the legs out from under the entire legal framework for regulating climate pollution by arguing that climate pollution does not harm human health or welfare.— Zealan Hoover, former senior advisor to the EPA during the Biden administration

The legal architecture the administration is dismantling was built over nearly two decades. A 2007 Supreme Court ruling determined that greenhouse gases fall within the Clean Air Act's definition of air pollutants. That required the EPA to act if it found those gases endangered public health — which it did in its 2009 'endangerment finding.' In February, the Trump EPA overturned that finding, removing the legal underpinning for regulating climate pollution from vehicles. The current repeal targets power plants. And the new proposal, if finalized, would attempt to prevent any future administration from using the Clean Air Act to regulate power plant emissions on climate grounds.

Part one was repealing the endangerment finding. Now that that's done, they're working on part two, rolling back different regulations that relied on the endangerment finding, and part three, which would prevent future efforts to regulate climate pollution.— Zealan Hoover, former senior advisor to the EPA during the Biden administration

Hoover described the approach as not merely repealing rules but 'burning them to the ground' to make it extremely difficult for a future administration to restore them — a contrast, he said, with the first Trump term, when the Biden administration was able to reinstate many rolled-back protections.

Without these standards, dirty coal and fossil fueled power plants can spew as much carbon pollution into the atmosphere as they please.— Meredith Hankins, federal climate legal director, Natural Resources Defense Council

Environmental groups are skeptical the EPA's legal arguments will survive court scrutiny. Maggie Coulter, senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity's Climate Law Institute, said the agency's stance "goes against really well-established science" and expressed doubt that it would withstand judicial review. Carrie Jenks, executive director of the environmental and energy law program at Harvard Law School, said the near-certainty of litigation leaves power companies facing real uncertainty, noting they "are going to have to think through different scenarios."

This uncertainty creates a lot of havoc for them, and they're going to have to think through different scenarios.— Carrie Jenks, executive director, environmental and energy law program, Harvard Law School

The repeal leaves in place certain rules limiting conventional air pollutants such as mercury and lead, though CNN reports those standards have already been weakened. It does not affect the separate regulatory fight over vehicle emissions, where a federal judge has temporarily blocked the EPA's earlier move to revoke California's Clean Air Act waivers.

The administration argues the rollback is necessary to ensure grid reliability as electricity demand surges from data centers, industrial growth, and electrification, and that it will lower electricity prices. A number of experts take issue with that assertion, contending that coal-fired power tends to cost more than natural gas and renewables. In 2025, US greenhouse gas emissions increased — reversing a prior downward trend — driven in part by power plants burning more coal, according to CNN.

The Trump administration is once again intent on putting the interests of fossil fuel polluters above the health and wellbeing of the American people.— Rachel Cleetus, senior policy director, Climate and Energy Program, Union of Concerned Scientists

Why it matters — The repeal and the accompanying legal challenge will determine whether the federal government retains any authority under current law to limit greenhouse gas emissions from the second-largest source of US climate pollution — and whether that authority can ever be restored by a future administration.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Coal demand in the US is expected to fall by 7% in 2026, reversing a temporary increase in 2025
  • In 2025, US greenhouse gas emissions increased, driven in part by power plants burning more coal

Sources differ on Effect of repeal on electricity prices: EPA and administration say repeal will decrease electricity prices for American families (epa.gov) vs Some experts argue coal-fired power is often more expensive than natural gas and renewables, and the rollback could raise prices (cnn.com)

Sources differ on Impact of power plant GHG emissions on climate: EPA says power plant emissions have 'no material impact on global climate change' and eliminating all CO2 from the sector would have no meaningful climate impact (epa.gov) vs Scientists and environmental groups say this contradicts well-established science; power plants account for ~25% of US climate pollution (arstechnica.com)

Reported by thehill.com, arstechnica.com, epa.gov, politico.com, bloomberg.com, news.bloomberglaw.com, cnn.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email