Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Life & Culture

Viral 'J.Lo mugshot' has a catch: New York Post's image was AI-manipulated, fact-checkers say

A Minnesota woman's real booking photo did go viral for its resemblance to Jennifer Lopez — but the image the New York Post spread on X was AI-generated, not the actual mugshot.

How does this story make you feel?

When a Minnesota woman's shoplifting mugshot went viral for its supposed resemblance to Jennifer Lopez, millions saw a photo that wasn't real. The image the New York Post shared on X — the one that drove the 'glitch in the matrix' jokes and the 'Jenny from D-Block' puns — was AI-generated and manipulated to look more like Lopez, according to a fact-check by Lead Stories. The real booking photo, obtained directly from the Wright County Sheriff's Office, shows a different image: one that includes lip and nose piercings absent from the doctored version.

The woman at the center of it all is Cyrena Anne Quast, 35, of St. Cloud, Minnesota. She was arrested on August 30 in Monticello after allegedly stealing two double packs of power tool batteries worth approximately $580 from a store, according to a criminal complaint obtained by The Watch MN. A store employee recognized Quast from an alleged theft at the same location two days earlier, supplied police with a description of her vehicle and its license plate, and Quast admitted to taking the batteries after she was located. She was booked into the Wright County Jail on a gross misdemeanor theft charge and released the following day.

The real mugshot — not the AI version — did circulate widely and drew genuine comparisons to Lopez online. Multiple outlets, including the New York Daily News, reported on the resemblance based on the authentic booking photo. But it was the Post's manipulated image on X that supercharged the viral moment, according to Lead Stories, which used the Hive Moderation AI-detection tool on the Post's shared image and received an aggregated score of 97.7%, indicating it is very likely AI-generated.

Notably, the New York Post did not use the AI-generated image within its actual article — the real mugshot appeared there — but the doctored version was what the outlet posted to its X account, where it reached a far larger and faster-moving audience.

The internet's reaction to whichever image they saw was swift and creative. Commenters leaned heavily on Lopez's 2002 hit 'Jenny from the Block.'

In prison she's known as Jenny from D-Block.— Anonymous social media user
There's a glitch in the matrix.— Anonymous social media user
If it was J.Lo, she should have been charged with stealing vocals.— Anonymous social media user

Not everyone was convinced by the comparison. 'She looks absolutely nothing like her,' one user said, according to Fox News. Others suggested Quast looked like Lopez if the singer 'had a really rough week,' or floated the idea of Quast as Lopez's stunt double.

Online arrest records show Quast's August 30 booking was not her first. Prior arrests on record include drug possession, DWI, fleeing police, and providing false identification, along with several traffic violations, according to Dexerto and the New York Post.

Lopez has not publicly responded to the comparison, according to Dexerto. The episode joins a pattern of celebrity lookalike moments going viral — Dexerto noted that in 2023, a Taylor Swift doppelgänger drew widespread attention after going out in public dressed as the singer and surrounded by bodyguards.

The incident highlights a growing problem in viral news cycles: AI-manipulated images can be introduced early in a story's spread and become the version most people see, even when the authentic image is used in the original reporting. In this case, the gap between the Post's article (which used the real photo) and its X post (which used the AI version) meant the doctored image reached social media audiences first and at scale.

Why it matters — The episode is a concrete example of how an AI-doctored image can hijack a real news story on social media, reaching millions before a fact-check can catch up — even when the authentic image was used in the original article.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Quast is a Saint Cloud native.

Sources differ on Whether the viral mugshot image resembles Jennifer Lopez: Multiple social media users and outlets said the resemblance was striking. (foxnews.com, dexerto.com, web.archive.org) vs Other social media users said she looks 'absolutely nothing' like Lopez. (foxnews.com) vs The most widely shared image was AI-manipulated to enhance the likeness, making comparisons based on it unreliable. (leadstories.com)

Reported by foxnews.com, dexerto.com, web.archive.org, leadstories.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email