Great Lakes gas prices surge toward $5 as refinery outage and war compound supply crunch
A power failure at ExxonMobil's Chicago-area refinery, a labor dispute at Indiana's BP Whiting plant, and the ongoing war with Iran are pushing fuel costs to record levels across five Midwest states.
Drivers across Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin, and Ohio are facing a fresh wave of gas and diesel price increases, with analysts warning that the worst may not yet have arrived at the pump. Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, flagged all five Great Lakes states as being 'at risk of gas price increases' on Friday, with Ohio carrying the highest probability of the largest single-day jump.
If you're in the Great Lakes - MI, IN, WI, IL, OH - you remain at risk of gas price increases today.— Patrick De Haan, Head of Petroleum Analysis, GasBuddy
By Friday morning, Michigan drivers were paying an average of $4.89 per gallon for regular unleaded — up 14 cents overnight and closing in on the state's all-time record of $5.22, set in June 2022, according to AAA. Illinois averaged $4.85, Indiana $4.00, Wisconsin $4.41, and Ohio $4.53, all significantly above year-ago levels. The national average stood at $4.47, up 3 cents overnight.
Diesel is telling an even starker story. Michigan set a new record of $6.67 per gallon on Friday, the latest in a daily string of broken records, according to AAA data reported by CBS News. Some Bay County, Michigan stations were already posting diesel at $6.79. The national diesel average also hit a new record of $6.44 on Friday. De Haan said diesel prices in the Great Lakes region could approach $7 per gallon at some stations within days.
Diesel is going to go up to $6.99, I have no doubt about that. That could happen very quickly in Michigan.— Patrick De Haan, Head of Petroleum Analysis, GasBuddy
The immediate trigger for the regional spike is a power failure at ExxonMobil's Joliet refinery in Illinois, southwest of Chicago, which knocked the facility offline on Sunday. The refinery has a capacity of 275,000 barrels per day and produces approximately 11 million gallons of gasoline and diesel daily — making it a critical fuel source for the Midwest. ExxonMobil identified the source of the outage as problems on ComEd's primary and secondary power lines feeding the facility, and said power had been fully restored, according to Reuters. But the refinery's safety flare was triggered again on Wednesday, and a full restart was expected to take several more days.
According to ComEd, which is the refinery's electric utility, both feed lines apparently went dead on Sunday afternoon. There's very little information on the particulars on why that happened, but the utility is saying that it lost power to that refinery. So this was not some conspiracy. The refinery doesn't want to lose power because now as a result of this, it's losing tens of millions of dollars. The spikes we've seen in the last two weeks are probably two-thirds refining issues locally, and probably one-third geopolitical tensions.— Patrick De Haan, Head of Petroleum Analysis, GasBuddy
The Joliet outage is not the only refinery pressure point. In Ohio, Canadian company Cenovus has planned major maintenance at its Lima refinery — capacity 185,000 barrels per day — running from September through mid-October, which energy markets analyst Brandon Noe Rivera Barron wrote on LinkedIn could 'reduce regional supplies of gasoline' at a time when 'U.S. distillate inventories remain historically tight.' In Indiana, BP's Whiting refinery, one of the largest in the country at roughly 440,000 barrels per day according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, is in the middle of a labor dispute with United Steelworkers Local 7-1. BP said the dispute is not currently impacting operations, but an outage there would have an outsized impact on Midwest supply.
Underlying all of it is the war with Iran, now in its sixth month, which has disrupted global oil supply and effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz. A Houthi attack on Saudi Arabia last week led to the closure of a key oil pipeline, adding further upward pressure. Since the war began on February 28, the national average gas price has risen from $2.98 to $4.47, according to AAA. Americans have collectively spent more than $100 billion more on gasoline and diesel since March 1 compared to the same period a year ago, according to De Haan.
State officials are responding. Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer issued an energy emergency executive order allowing gas stations in eight Metro Detroit counties — Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, Washtenaw, Livingston, Monroe, St. Clair, and Lenawee — to keep selling higher-vapor-pressure gasoline blends that are typically 10 to 20 cents cheaper than the low-vapor-pressure summer blend normally required from June 1 through September 15. The order covers roughly 5 million residents, about half the state's population, and runs until the emergency ends or July 1 at the latest. The U.S. EPA separately announced a nationwide temporary waiver of its federal vapor pressure requirements starting May 1.
As governor, I can't end a war overseas or undo bad policies at the federal level that led to higher gas prices, but I will do what I can to try to give families a break.— Gov. Gretchen Whitmer
In Illinois, Governor JB Pritzker sent letters to the chief executives of the nation's largest oil companies demanding answers about why Illinois families are paying elevated prices while the companies report record profits. Since the war began, the price of regular gasoline in Illinois has risen by more than $1.30 per gallon, costing Illinois residents an additional $2 billion, according to Pritzker's office. He requested detailed responses from the CEOs by August 21, 2026.
At a moment when Illinois working families continue to feel the burden of higher costs, these oil companies face a clear choice — help ease the burden for families or exploit the conflict to generate windfall profits.— Gov. JB Pritzker
Proposals to suspend state or federal fuel taxes have circulated but gone nowhere. Michigan's state gas tax is 52.4 cents per gallon; the federal gas tax is 18.3 cents for gasoline and 24.3 cents for diesel. A Congressional report noted that even a full federal gas tax suspension would still leave prices more than $1.30 per gallon above pre-war levels. Michigan lawmakers have not moved seriously on a state tax suspension; a similar attempt during the 2022 price spike was vetoed by Whitmer.
De Haan offered a cautious near-term outlook: once the Joliet refinery is back online, prices in Michigan could ease into the $4.70–$4.80 range by mid-to-late the following week — but he noted conditions remain fluid. For now, he said, Michigan and Illinois station owners appear to be resisting crossing the $5 threshold by accepting lower margins, a dynamic he observed during the spring price spike as well.
When we saw the possibility that stations could go to $5, they resisted it significantly. They took less margin, but gas prices in lower-priced states went up a little bit more than they may have otherwise. So that's why I think Michigan and Illinois are at lower risk because they're already right at that $4.99 price.— Patrick De Haan, Head of Petroleum Analysis, GasBuddy
California remains the most expensive state for gas at $6.11 per gallon. Five other states — Washington ($5.57), Hawaii ($5.49), Nevada ($5.22), Oregon ($5.11), and Alaska ($5.06) — are already above $5. The cheapest gas is in Texas at $3.95 per gallon, which displaced Indiana from that position after Indiana's overnight 8-cent jump.
Why it matters — Midwest drivers are caught between a crippled regional refinery, a looming labor dispute at one of the country's largest fuel plants, and a war-driven global oil shock — a combination that analysts say could push diesel past $7 and regular gas past $5 before prices stabilize.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- De Haan projected Michigan and Illinois gas prices could ease to the $4.70–$4.80 range by mid-to-late the following week once Joliet restarts
- Diesel prices in Great Lakes states could approach $7/gallon at some stations within a week or so
- The pump problem at Joliet on Wednesday may or may not be connected to the original power outage
Sources differ on BP Whiting refinery maintenance and labor dispute impact on capacity: Planned maintenance reports have been misstated and are not contributing to reduced capacity; labor dispute not impacting operations (advantagenews.com (citing BP and De Haan)) vs Labor dispute with United Steelworkers Local 7-1 threatens future disruptions or a full shutdown (newsweek.com)
Reported by newsweek.com, cbsnews.com, jsonline.com, wnem.com, advantagenews.com, detroitnews.com, gov-pritzker-newsroom.prezly.com
- Gretchen WhitmerAmerican politician and attorney (born 1971)
- JB PritzkerAmerican businessman and politician (born 1965)