Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
U.S.

Five dead in LA's worst news helicopter crash in 25 years, NTSB investigation underway

A deadly chain of events in Chatsworth — a drugged driver, a bus full of commuters, and a news helicopter falling from the sky live on air — left five people dead and a city questioning the cost of 'the eye in the sky.'

How does this story make you feel?

At 6:57 p.m. on a Tuesday evening in Chatsworth, a suburban Los Angeles neighborhood, someone in a crowd already gathered around the wreckage of a bus collision shouted: 'The helicopter just crashed!' Los Angeles County Fire Capt. Brandon Silverman turned to find a large plume of black smoke rising from a parking lot one block east. His team, which had just spent hours cutting passengers free from crushed metal and glass, turned toward another disaster.

By the time the night was over, five people were dead — two bus passengers killed when an allegedly impaired driver plowed into a Metro bus around 5 p.m., and then, two hours later, aerial photojournalist-reporter Eliana Moreno, pilot George Marciniw, and a bystander on the ground, Edy Fernando Gutiérrez Mejía, when the NBC4 news helicopter covering the bus crash fell from the sky and burst into flames.

The National Transportation Safety Board and the Federal Aviation Administration are now investigating what brought the helicopter down, with investigators pointing to a video of the aircraft's final descent as a critical piece of evidence. A cause has not been determined, though some experts have said they believe mechanical failure may be responsible.

According to the Los Angeles Times, no incident involving a Los Angeles news helicopter has been as serious as this one since a Fox 11 helicopter covering the Academy Awards went down in flames at Van Nuys Airport in 2000. Nationally, NTSB data show 16 people have died in eight fatal news helicopter crashes in the United States since 2000.

Moreno and Marciniw worked for Angel City Air, providing aerial coverage for NBC4 and Telemundo 52. Moreno, known on air as 'Eli in the Heli,' had been a helicopter journalist since 2010, when she graduated from Chapman University. Engaged to be married and a recent marathon finisher, she was a bilingual reporter in her 30s. Her family said she had nurtured a dream of becoming a news reporter from the age of 11, and that her path in journalism "was made possible by all of you who welcomed her into your homes and onto your screens."

She was damn good at what she did.— Jonathan Gonzalez, Weekend News Anchor and Reporter, NBC Los Angeles

Marciniw, a veteran of more than 30 years in the air, had been eyeing retirement when the crash happened, according to fellow pilot Esteban Jimenez.

I knew him since the '90s. He was my instructor at one time; he was my eyes and ears here in LA.— Esteban Jimenez, Fellow Pilot

The third victim on the ground, Gutiérrez Mejía, was described by CNN as a young Guatemalan tourist who had recently arrived in Los Angeles.

The sequence that preceded the helicopter crash began around 5 p.m., when Bailee Lynn Rios, driving a Ford Expedition, ran a red light, entered opposing traffic, and at full speed struck a Metro bus carrying passengers home from work, according to the Los Angeles Police Department and Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman. Authorities allege Rios was under the influence of drugs and that narcotics were found inside the SUV. Gage Weida, 31, and Daniel Castillo, 46, both bus passengers, were pronounced dead at the scene. Four others suffered non-life-threatening injuries.

People on that bus at about 5 p.m. were either going to work or maybe coming from work. They might be going to get a bite to eat, to see family or friends. What they did not expect is what was about to happen.— Nathan Hochman, Los Angeles County District Attorney

According to Hochman, Rios has been charged with second-degree murder, driving under the influence, and reckless driving, and could face a maximum sentence of life in prison. CNN reported it has reached out to her attorney for comment.

Moreno was reporting live from the helicopter above the bus crash scene — 'This is a horrific crash here in Chatsworth,' she said on air — when the aircraft went down approximately two hours after the bus collision. NBC Los Angeles confirmed the deaths on air that evening.

We are coming on the air with heavy hearts tonight because we lost valued friends and colleagues. We are going to take a couple of minutes to think about that, to process, and to regroup.— Colleen Williams, Anchor, NBC Los Angeles
To have two incidents of that significance in that short amount of time within a few blocks of each other is definitely a unique situation for any department.— Brandon Silverman, Captain, Los Angeles County Fire Department

Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass spoke at a vigil Thursday.

My heart is with the families whose lives changed forever Tuesday night. Simply going to work, coming from work to come back to your family, you expect to see them. And they never arrive.— Karen Bass, Mayor of Los Angeles

The crash has forced a reckoning with the risks embedded in a journalism tradition that Los Angeles invented. The world's first 'Telecopter' debuted in the city in 1958, after KTLA-TV chief engineer John Silva retrofitted a helicopter with ultra-light camera equipment capable of transmitting footage live from the air. A radar operator during the Second World War before his television career, Silva explained his thinking in a 2002 interview for the Archive of American Television: "If we could build a news mobile unit in a helicopter we could get over it all, get there first, avoid the traffic and get to all the stories before anybody in the competition."

That competitive instinct has never left the skies above Los Angeles. Pilots who spoke to the Los Angeles Times described a high-stakes race to reach breaking news first, with airspace that can quickly become crowded — not only with rival news helicopters but with air traffic serving three regional airports and smaller local airstrips. Kurt Deetz, a former pilot who retired five years ago, was direct: "If you can be the first on the scene, you're a hero. I think about that now and think, that is so dumb."

Despite the competition, pilots describe a parallel culture of coordination. Unspoken rules govern everything from positioning during police chases — where the first helicopter on scene takes the front-left position and others slot in around the fleeing vehicle — to the requirement that all helicopters stop and hover in place if a pursuit enters a tight residential area, because the turns required to follow could cause a collision. 'You never move unless you say something,' said Tim Lynn, a now-retired pilot who flew for 16 years for KTLA-TV. 'It's a well-coordinated operation.'

The practice that draws the most concern from safety experts is low-altitude hovering — precisely what news helicopters do when they park above a breaking news scene for extended coverage. Jack Cress, a former Marine Corps helicopter pilot and helicopter accident investigation instructor at USC's Aviation Safety and Security Program, said that hovering at low altitude 'is a dangerous place to be.' The problem is physics: if an engine fails at low altitude with little forward momentum, a pilot has minimal time and distance to perform an 'autorotation' — a procedure that uses altitude and rotor momentum to slow a descent. Deetz said he made a point during his career of refusing to hover low for extended periods unless he could see a landing spot below. 'Those cameras are so powerful,' he said. Being that low, he added, simply is not necessary.

The dangers are not new. Cameraman George Spears and pilot Francis Gary Powers — the same U-2 spy plane pilot who had survived being shot down over the Soviet Union — died in 1977 when a KNBC helicopter ran out of fuel and crashed while covering a Santa Barbara wildfire. After a 2007 crash in Phoenix, all news stations in that city agreed to share a single helicopter. But former helicopter reporter Thanh Tan, writing in a Seattle Times op-ed after a 2014 local crash, raised a question that has returned with force: 'Newsrooms should not send crews into the skies just because they can or to vie for viewership.'

Why it matters — The deaths of five people in a single evening — and the live, on-air nature of the helicopter crash — have forced a direct public reckoning with the safety calculus behind a journalism practice that Los Angeles pioneered and that broadcasters across the country still rely on daily.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Mechanical failure is the suspected cause of the helicopter crash.
  • The helicopter involved was an Airbus AS350 B2 that suddenly lost altitude and triggered an alarm before impact.
  • A full NTSB report can take up to 18 months.

Reported by theguardian.com, latimes.com, cnn.com

People in this story
  • O. J. Simpson
    American football player and actor (1947–2024)
  • Francis Gary Powers
    American pilot shot down flying a U-2 spy plane over the Soviet Union (1929-1977)
  • Karen Bass
    American politician and 43rd Mayor of Los Angeles

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email