Appeals court backs Missouri's GOP map, but Supreme Court has blocked it twice and will decide
A federal appeals panel ordered Missouri to use its Republican-drawn 7-1 congressional map in November, setting up a third Supreme Court showdown as absentee ballots are already in voters' hands.
A federal appeals court ruled Monday that Missouri must use its new Republican-drawn congressional map in November's general election — a decision that carries no immediate force, because the US Supreme Court has already blocked that very map twice and is all but certain to have the final word before ballots are counted.
The three-judge panel of the St. Louis-based 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals — comprised entirely of Republican-appointed judges, including two chosen by President Donald Trump — put its own ruling on hold for one week to give opponents time to seek emergency Supreme Court intervention, again.
This Court holds that Missouri's current plan to use the 2022 map in the November 2026 general election violates the Constitution. Only use of the 2025 map complies with the Constitution and federal law.— 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals, unsigned ruling
The ruling upheld a decision by Missouri-based US District Judge Stephen Clark, who had ordered the new map used — a position the Missouri Supreme Court had rejected and the US Supreme Court had twice declined to revive. The high court first paused Clark's ruling on September 10, in a move that appeared to settle the dispute, leaving Missouri set to run November's election on the same 6-2 map used in 2022 and 2024.
The new map, drawn by the Republican-controlled legislature in 2025, targets the 5th Congressional District held by Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver by breaking up its Kansas City base and stretching it into rural, Republican-leaning parts of the state — a design that would create a 7-1 Republican advantage in Missouri's eight-seat House delegation, up from the current 6-2 split.
The appeals court leaned on estimates from a conservative group in the case to argue that reverting to the older map after the August primary — which was conducted under the new districts — would disenfranchise voters. It concluded that more than 1.4 million Missourians could not vote for the congressional district nominees who will appear on their November ballot, and that more than a quarter-million who voted in the August primary cast a vote for a candidate who now cannot represent them, according to CNN.
The practical obstacles to implementing the ruling are steep. Local election officials have already sent absentee ballots to overseas citizens and military voters using the older districts, and state law requires absentee ballots to be available to all other voters by Tuesday, according to The Guardian. The People Not Politicians group, which launched the referendum campaign against the GOP map, was blunt about the situation on the ground.
Ballots have been printed, and Missourians have already voted. Thousands more will vote before this order seeks to take effect. Officials should stop wasting taxpayers' money on pointless legal action and instead focus on administering our elections.— Richard von Glahn, executive director, People Not Politicians
The legal fight traces back to opponents of the new map gathering enough signatures to trigger a voter referendum on the redistricting plan under state law. Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins, a Republican, delayed a decision on whether to place the measure on the ballot before ultimately rejecting it, arguing redistricting plans are not subject to voter approval. The Missouri Supreme Court then held Hoskins in contempt for failing to comply with its ruling that the 2025 map be put on hold while the referendum process played out. Hoskins subsequently ordered election officials to use the 2022 map, following the Missouri Supreme Court's direction and the US Supreme Court's refusal to intervene on the GOP's behalf.
With the appeals court's one-week stay set to expire soon, opponents are expected to file another emergency application with the Supreme Court. Given the high court's two prior interventions against the map, the ruling from the 8th Circuit faces long odds of being implemented before November's election.
Why it matters — The outcome will determine whether Missouri sends six or seven Republicans to the House next year — a difference that could matter in a closely divided Congress — and will test how far courts can go to override state election administration already underway.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Opponents of the map will file an emergency appeal to the Supreme Court before the one-week stay expires.
- specific expiration date 'around September 28'
Reported by theguardian.com, thehill.com, nbcnews.com, pbs.org, politico.com, courthousenews.com, cnn.com
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- Emanuel CleaverU.S. Representative from Missouri