Aaron Judge expected to miss Yankees' Wild Card series with moderate calf strain
Manager Aaron Boone said Tuesday the Yankees are 'not planning' on Judge for the AL Wild Card round, though he stopped short of ruling it out entirely — leaving the team's best player in a race against the calendar.
Aaron Judge will almost certainly begin the Yankees' postseason on the injured list. Manager Aaron Boone confirmed Tuesday that New York is not counting on its captain for the AL Wild Card series — a best-of-three round expected to begin later this month at Yankee Stadium, likely against the Boston Red Sox — after Judge strained his right calf last Wednesday, just eight days after rushing back from a rib fracture.
We're not planning on him being a part of that.— Aaron Boone, Yankees Manager
Boone did leave a narrow door open, telling reporters before a doubleheader against Tampa Bay: 'I'm not expecting it. But I'm not ruling it out either.' The reason for that hedge became clear when Boone revealed for the first time that the strain is moderate — a classification that carries real weight.
A moderate calf strain is typically graded Grade 2 and carries a three-to-six week recovery timetable, according to Dr. Daniel Kaplan, an orthopedic surgeon and sports medicine specialist with NYU Langone Health, who has not examined Judge. On Monday, Judge received a platelet-poor plasma injection in the calf — likely leukocyte-poor, Kaplan told the New York Post, meaning a lower concentration of white blood cells designed to reduce inflammation and potentially accelerate healing.
If Judge heals at the earliest end of that spectrum — three weeks from the injury — he would return around October 7, which would correspond to Game 3 of the American League Division Series, according to the New York Post. The Yankees would, of course, need to get past the Wild Card round first.
There is also a meaningful question about what Judge would look like if and when he does return. His comeback from the rib fracture — which cost him more than three months starting in early June — was rocky: he went 4-for-23 with one home run and 13 strikeouts in seven games before the calf gave out. He skipped a rehab assignment before that return, and his timing visibly lagged.
Doctors also note a broader risk with calf injuries: the potential for a more serious Achilles rupture. Kaplan told the Post that baseball's demands differ from football and basketball, and that Judge could potentially return sooner if used strictly as a designated hitter, avoiding the stress of playing the outfield.
Without Judge, the Yankees' outfield picture is thin. Cody Bellinger is the only certain playoff outfielder. Three players are competing for two remaining starting spots: right-handed Heliot Ramos and left-handed options Spencer Jones and Trent Grisham, the latter of whom is dealing with a hamstring strain but ran the bases Tuesday and is working toward a possible postseason return. Additional production will be needed from Bellinger, Ben Rice, Luis García Jr., George Lombard Jr., and Paul Goldschmidt — particularly against Boston's lefty-heavy rotation.
Obviously, having Judge on our team helps us tremendously. So we just got to continue coming out and winning games, playing for each other, and continue leaning on each other and continue playing good baseball.— Cody Bellinger, Yankees Outfielder
Boone acknowledged the loss but framed it as familiar territory — the Yankees went 45-39 in the 99 days Judge missed with the rib injury.
Obviously you always want your best player in the mix, but we understand we've got a job to do and an expectation to win and I think that expectation doesn't change. With or without him, we're expecting to go into the series and know we can beat anyone when we play our game.— Aaron Boone, Yankees Manager
The Yankees are projected as the No. 4 seed in the AL playoff bracket, with the Tampa Bay Rays on the verge of winning the AL East. According to Sporting News, Jazz Chisholm Jr. is returning, and the Yankees are expected to have likely Cy Young contender Cam Schlittler available on the mound — giving the pitching staff a credible foundation even as the lineup absorbs the absence of its best hitter.
Why it matters — Judge is the Yankees' best hitter and his absence — compounded by a rocky return from his previous injury — forces New York to open the playoffs shorthanded against a Red Sox team with a lefty-heavy rotation, making the Wild Card round a genuine test of how far this roster can go without him.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Judge told reporters on September 23 that he intends to be ready for Game 1 of the Wild Card, saying 'That's what the plan is.'
- The Yankees are projected as the No. 4 seed in the AL playoff bracket.
- specific date September 29 for Wild Card start
- specific date September 16 for injury
- definitive matchup vs. Red Sox (now 'likely')
Reported by yahoo.com, nytimes.com, nypost.com, sportingnews.com
- Aaron JudgeAmerican professional baseball player (born 1992)