Trump removes 760,000 from Obamacare, citing fraud — critics warn of collateral damage
The administration canceled roughly 315,000 ACA enrollments covering 760,000 people and froze new broker registrations for six months, in what officials call a $2.2bn fraud crackdown.
Officials announced Tuesday that the Trump administration has scrapped approximately 315,000 Affordable Care Act marketplace enrollments, affecting around 760,000 people. The move, framed as a drive to eliminate phantom enrollees and ineligible recipients, is projected to save $2.2 billion in taxpayer-funded subsidies. At the same time, the government is investigating around 420,000 additional enrollees and has imposed a six-month moratorium on new insurance agents and brokers selling ACA policies — the most sweeping purge of Obamacare enrollees since the administration began targeting alleged fraud in federal health programs.
We're actually making sure that the people receiving Obamacare subsidies are actually entitled to receive them.— JD Vance, Vice President
Vance, who leads the White House task force on fraud, and Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz announced the action at a press conference. Oz described the removed enrollees as a mixture of 'phantoms' and 'ghosts' as well as people who do not meet ACA eligibility requirements, and said officials used AI tools to identify them. The three criteria used: the person was enrolled by a broker or agent, had their entire ACA premium covered by a tax credit, and had not supplied a Social Security number or immigration documents. Insurers were then asked to contact those individuals; anyone who did not respond within 30 days had their coverage canceled.
These are not real people.— Mehmet Oz, CMS Administrator
Health policy experts say the process raises serious questions about accuracy. Because no details were released about how many enrollees were fictional, how many were enrolled by fraudulent brokers without their own knowledge, and how many were removed simply for failing to respond to a 30-day notice, outside analysts say there is no way to assess how many legitimate enrollees lost coverage.
It is entirely possible that many of these people were enrolled without their knowledge or were so-called phantom enrollees. It is also entirely possible that many of these people were legitimately enrolled and simply did not respond in time.— Cynthia Cox, Senior Vice President and Director of the Program on the ACA, KFF
There's no transparency about who these people are and why they're being disenrolled, but I think it's a reasonable concern that some number are being disenrolled inappropriately.— Edwin Park, Research Professor, Center for Children and Families, Georgetown University's McCourt School of Public Policy
Vance acknowledged at the briefing that some people enrolled by fraudulent brokers 'were probably legitimate,' but offered no detail on how they would be reinstated. Officials said enrollees can appeal and be reinstated by proving their identities — a process Park described as an additional administrative hurdle that, in practice, causes eligible people to lose coverage. Park warned that piling on bureaucratic requirements tends to push out people who are legitimately entitled to coverage: "We know that when you add a lot of red tape, increase the amount of complexity and the requirements for paperwork," he said, "that leads to eligible people being disenrolled."
The administration's fraud case rests partly on an enrollment surge during the Covid-19 pandemic. Pointing to ACA marketplace enrollment climbing from around 10 million people before the pandemic to roughly 22 million afterward, Oz contended that loosened safeguards and insufficient enforcement fueled improper sign-ups. According to a June report from the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, close to half of the "unprecedented enrollment growth from 2021 to 2024" was "suspected to be improper, phantom, or fraudulent," with improper enrollment defined as individuals misstating their income to obtain free plans. That growth was driven in part by the American Rescue Plan, a 2021 Covid relief law that enhanced available subsidies; those broader credits later expired at the end of 2025, causing premiums to rise sharply.
Oz also argued that roughly 35% of people currently in the Obamacare system have never used a prescription or seen a doctor, calling that figure implausible and evidence of fraud. Park pushed back, noting that in any insurance risk pool it is normal for many enrollees — particularly healthy ones — to use little or no care in a given year. Removing those lower-risk people, he warned, could raise premiums for everyone remaining or push insurers to exit markets entirely.
You can expect in any insurance risk pool that there's going to be a lot of people who don't use much healthcare or use healthcare at all.— Edwin Park, Research Professor, Center for Children and Families, Georgetown University's McCourt School of Public Policy
Some of those removed appear to have been cut not for fraud but for income. The ACA was designed to include a Medicaid expansion for people below the poverty line, but a Supreme Court ruling made that expansion optional for states. In states that declined to expand Medicaid, a gap exists for people earning roughly $16,000 to $22,000 per year — too much for Medicaid, not enough for ACA eligibility. Officials confirmed they are enforcing income thresholds, which experts say will push some of the lowest-income Americans out of any coverage at all.
The broker crackdown has bipartisan roots: the Biden administration finalized rules against shady brokers and decertified about 200 of them. The Trump administration recertified those brokers last year, then moved Tuesday to suspend 569 agents and freeze new broker applications for six months. Vance accused the Biden administration of building a system in which brokers were paid to enroll patients while the government did not verify eligibility — conditions he said made 'rampant fraud' inevitable.
You have a system where, on the one hand, brokers are paid money to feed patients into the system, while on the other hand, the government isn't even checking whether the people enrolled are actually eligible for the program. What do you have? Of course, rampant, rampant fraud.— JD Vance, Vice President
The disenrollments are part of a broader pattern. In a separate action, the fraud task force held back $2.2 billion in Medicaid payments owed to California and Minnesota, citing alleged fraud concentrated in home health aide programs that disability advocates say are essential to the people who rely on them. According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, ACA marketplace enrollment fell by nearly 3 million people between February 2025 and February 2026 — a count that does not yet include the effect of Tuesday's action. As of February 2026, about 19.2 million Americans remained enrolled in ACA marketplace plans — a 13% annual decline, driven in part by the expiration of enhanced pandemic-era subsidies.
A lot of these actions are intended to sharply undercut the success of and the long-term viability of the ACA's coverage expansions, which have been an incredible success in terms of reducing the number of people without health insurance.— Edwin Park, Research Professor, Center for Children and Families, Georgetown University's McCourt School of Public Policy
Trump has opposed the ACA since his 2016 campaign, when he repeatedly promised to repeal and replace it. His first-term repeal effort collapsed in July 2017 when Republican Sen. John McCain cast a deciding 'no' vote. The Supreme Court has since rejected multiple legal challenges to the law, including a ruling that preserved free preventive health services for about 150 million people.
Why it matters — The cancellations — and the opaque process behind them — could strip coverage from hundreds of thousands of low-income Americans who were legitimately enrolled, while a broker freeze and rising premiums threaten to make the ACA marketplace harder to access for millions more.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Nearly half of ACA enrollment growth from 2021 to 2024 was suspected to be improper, phantom, or fraudulent.
- About 35% of current ACA enrollees have never used a prescription or seen a doctor.
Sources differ on Whether the 30-day non-response cancellations removed legitimate enrollees: Non-responders were fraudulent or ineligible; the process was appropriate (cnbc.com) vs Many non-responders were likely legitimately enrolled and simply did not respond in time (theguardian.com)
Sources differ on Whether a 35% non-utilization rate proves fraud: A 35% non-use rate is implausible and indicates fraud, per Oz (theguardian.com) vs It is normal for many healthy enrollees in any insurance pool to use little or no care in a year, per Park (theguardian.com)
Reported by theguardian.com, nytimes.com, independent.co.uk, reuters.com, cnbc.com, fiercehealthcare.com
- John McCainAmerican politician (1936–2018)
- JD VanceVice President of the United States since 2025
- Mehmet ÖzTurkish-American surgeon, TV host, and government official (born 1960)