New Jersey Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell resigns after ethics probe finds sexual harassment and ethics violations
Gov. Mikie Sherrill accepted Caldwell's resignation Friday, one day after giving him a deadline to quit following a 61-page investigation that substantiated sexual harassment and two ethics breaches.
Uncertain / Wikimedia Commons
New Jersey Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell resigned Friday afternoon, less than a year into office, after Gov. Mikie Sherrill gave him 24 hours to quit or face the consequences of a damning independent investigation that found he sexually harassed a female staffer and committed two separate ethics violations.
He submitted his resignation to me this afternoon, which I accepted.— Mikie Sherrill, Governor of New Jersey
The resignation ends a standoff that had shadowed Sherrill's young administration for months. Caldwell, 66, is the first lieutenant governor to resign since New Jersey created the position in 2009. He had shown no early signs of leaving willingly — under state law, a governor cannot fire a lieutenant governor, meaning impeachment by the legislature would have been the only other path to removal.
The 61-page report, produced by a law firm hired by the governor's office and initiated by the state's chief ethics officer, found credible evidence of three violations. Investigators concluded that Caldwell made a romantic advance toward a female staffer's friend and, after being rebuffed, told the staffer: "You young women are looking for young sperm." Investigators said Caldwell's denial that he made the comment was not credible, and the staffer said she subsequently tried to avoid traveling with him.
The investigation found that the Lieutenant Governor engaged in serious, repeated violations of state policy and failed to uphold the responsibilities of his office.— Mikie Sherrill, Governor of New Jersey
Beyond the harassment finding, investigators found that Caldwell repeatedly brought personal guests to ticketed events — including the opera — without paying or obtaining ethics clearance, and that he continued doing so even after formal warnings. Notably, he brought an unpaid guest to an event on May 23, one day after being formally notified the investigation had begun. Four days after that notification, he used his state email to recommend a state employee he was romantically involved with for a leadership position in another executive branch department, referring to her as "my friend" and not disclosing the relationship.
Sherrill, a former federal prosecutor and fellow Democrat, had defended allowing Caldwell to serve as acting governor on several occasions even after the investigation began, saying she wanted to ensure he received a fair hearing. Once she received the report's findings, she said, she acted immediately.
Once I saw those complaints, once I saw the findings of that investigation, I acted quickly and asked for the resignation of the lieutenant governor.— Mikie Sherrill, Governor of New Jersey
In a statement Friday, Caldwell said his decision to resign was intended to prevent the controversy from interfering with Sherrill's work, but he was explicit that stepping down was not an admission of guilt.
My decision to resign should not be interpreted as an acceptance of the report's findings.— Dale Caldwell, resigning Lt. Governor of New Jersey
His attorney, Thomas Calcagni, called the investigation "unnecessarily protracted and one-sided" and said it lacked "the requisite due process that should be afforded every citizen of this state." Calcagni said they were exploring legal options to challenge the report's findings.
Dr. Caldwell's resignation, submitted to put an end to the targeted campaign to discredit his character, does not in any way diminish our outrage concerning the investigative process and its specious findings.— Thomas R. Calcagni, attorney for Dale Caldwell
Sherrill pushed back on the due-process criticism, noting that Caldwell's own statements were included in the report and that the investigation was conducted by a former state attorney general.
The resignation carries immediate practical consequences. Caldwell also held the role of New Jersey secretary of state, which oversees elections — and his departure comes roughly five weeks before midterm elections that will determine control of Congress. Sherrill announced that acting state comptroller Shirley Emehelu, a veteran of the U.S. Department of Justice and the New Jersey Attorney General's Office, would step in as acting secretary of state.
She has the judgment to run these elections and the strength to stand up to Trump's attacks on voting.— Mikie Sherrill, Governor of New Jersey
Under New Jersey law, the lieutenant governor position must be filled within 45 days. Until a permanent appointment is made, state Senate President Nicholas Scutari would serve as acting governor if Sherrill is absent. Sherrill said she would make a permanent appointment within the legal window but does not plan to name an acting lieutenant governor in the interim.
Sherrill framed the episode as part of a broader effort to dismantle what she described as a deeply entrenched culture of silence in state government.
There has been a culture in Trenton, probably since the birth of our nation, to sweep this under the rug. That is not the kind of government I'm running.— Mikie Sherrill, Governor of New Jersey
State Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin, a Democrat, praised Sherrill's handling of the matter. U.S. Sen. Andy Kim also called the report's findings "unacceptable" and said New Jerseyans deserve public servants who work to earn their trust. Republican state Sen. Kristin Corrado, however, questioned Sherrill's judgment for allowing Caldwell to serve as acting governor while under investigation, saying residents deserved "leadership, transparency, and answers."
Caldwell, a Methodist pastor and former president of Centenary University, was Sherrill's chosen running mate. They took office in January. Within four months, an anonymous complaint had been filed with the state's chief ethics officer alleging he hit on women at official functions using taxpayer money and handed out his state business cards to ask women on dates. The probe that followed produced the 61-page report released Wednesday.
Caldwell is the fourth person to hold the lieutenant governor position since it was created in 2009, and the first to resign. In a letter included in the report, he said he believed his relationships with women were being subjected to extra scrutiny because he was a single Black man, according to CNN.
Why it matters — The resignation of New Jersey's lieutenant governor — who also oversaw elections as secretary of state — five weeks before midterms creates immediate questions about election administration and sets a test case for how governors handle misconduct within their own administrations.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Caldwell suspected his relationships with women were being subjected to extra scrutiny because he was a single Black man
- Political science professor Matt Hale said the resignation probably won't move the needle much in New Jersey's midterms but gives Republicans fresh ammunition against Sherrill
- Cornell government professor Richard Bensel said the resignation 'might hurt her with some Black Democratic men' but would likely be more than compensated by approval from Black Democratic women
Sources differ on Whether the investigation afforded Caldwell adequate due process: The process was 'unnecessarily protracted and one-sided' and lacked requisite due process; Caldwell was not given a meaningful opportunity to address anonymous allegations (theguardian.com (Calcagni statement)) vs The investigation was thorough and impartial; Caldwell's own statements were included in the report and he was fully involved (nbcnews.com (Sherrill statement))
Sources differ on Whether Caldwell made the 'young sperm' comment: Caldwell categorically denies making the statement (cnn.com) vs Investigators found Caldwell's denial not credible and concluded he made the remark (foxnews.com)
Reported by theguardian.com, thehill.com, foxnews.com, pbs.org, nbcnews.com, abcnews.com, cnn.com, nj.gov, subscriber.politicopro.com
- Mikie SherrillAmerican politician, naval aviator, and prosecutor (born 1972)
- Andy KimAmerican politician and diplomat (born 1982)