Manchester City Found Guilty on 114 of 115 Premier League Financial Charges
An independent commission ruled City ran a £900m-plus disguised funding scheme through 'sham' contracts over nine seasons — the biggest regulatory verdict in Premier League history. The club will appeal.
Manchester City have been found guilty on 114 of 115 charges of breaching Premier League financial rules, with an independent commission concluding the club ran a disguised funding scheme that artificially inflated revenues and reduced costs by more than £900m over nine seasons — the largest regulatory verdict in the competition's history.
A redacted 40-page document referred to as the 'core decision' was released by the Premier League, setting out the commission's conclusions. Investigators determined that City had structured 'sham' commercial arrangements with sponsors between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons, in which those sponsors covered only part of the advertised fee while Abu Dhabi United Group Investment & Development Ltd (ADUG) — the entity holding the club on behalf of Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al-Nahyan — secretly made up the difference.
The core decision establishes the facts of what happened at Manchester City during this period. It details how the club systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade. It also vindicates the Premier League's decision to pursue this case against Manchester City.— Richard Masters, Premier League Chief Executive
The commission found City operated a 'disguised funding scheme' worth £830.6m over those nine seasons and hid costs by a further £70m. Players and then-manager Roberto Mancini were also party to 'sham' image rights agreements that artificially boosted their officially recorded earnings. As a result, the commission determined, City submitted inaccurate financial accounts and kept its auditors and football regulators in the dark about the club's true financial position.
The commission's report details how, beginning in 2010, City put in place an arrangement under which sponsors would contribute a 'base sum' and ADUG would supply a 'tagged sum,' with the combined total recorded as the sponsorship fee — despite only the base sum constituting genuine revenue. Lawyers for City contended that the tagged sum amounted to a loan from the Abu Dhabi government against sponsorship fee liabilities; that argument was dismissed by the commission.
The commission's findings went beyond the financial schemes themselves. The commission was highly critical of the testimony offered by City's own witnesses, noting that 'evidence given by a number of important factual witnesses called to give evidence on behalf of the club was false in a number of key respects' and that some witnesses had given evidence 'they knew to be untrue and so had been dishonest.' The commission also concluded City had made concerted efforts to stop and frustrate the investigation.
City have said they will appeal the verdict before the deadline, describing the commission's opinion as containing 'clear material errors, of law, principle and fact' and calling it 'unsafe.' Club chief executive Ferran Soriano, in a video sent to employees, described the decision as based on a 'Premier League conspiracy theory.'
Nothing has changed. Our confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence is just as strong as when this began.— Khaldoon Al Mubarak, Manchester City Chairman
Convening an appeal will require a fresh three-person panel to be assembled, with its members chosen by Murray Rosen KC, who chairs the league's judicial panel. Any sanctions would be placed on ice while the appeal is heard — meaning City continue to compete in the Premier League without immediate punishment.
Sanctions have not yet been set and will be determined through a separate hearing expected to run in parallel with the appeal, with the Premier League keen to bring matters to a close as soon as possible. The scale of the offences makes the eventual punishment difficult to calibrate. When Everton was found to have exceeded profitability and sustainability rules by £19.5m in a single period, the club received a 10-point deduction calculated on a tariff of six points for the initial breach and one additional point per £5m overspent. The scope of City's violations is far greater, and Premier League chief executive Richard Masters called it 'the most significant in Premier League history,' with a points deduction severe enough to condemn City to relegation now seeming probable.
The charges date back 17 years, a period during which City won 20 major trophies. The matter was set in motion in November 2018 when the German publication Der Spiegel released internal emails it said revealed efforts by the club to disguise the true origins of income so as to satisfy Financial Fair Play requirements. City did not dispute the authenticity of the emails but declined to comment, saying they came from hackers. A Premier League investigation followed, and in February 2023 the league formally referred City to an independent commission on more than 100 charges. At that time, City expressed being 'surprised' by the allegations and asserted there was a 'comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence' to counter them.
A separate UEFA process ran in parallel. In February 2020, UEFA banned City from the Champions League for two seasons for 'serious breaches' of spending rules and fined the club 30 million euros. City appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, which overturned the ban in July 2020 but imposed a 10 million-euro fine for lack of cooperation with investigators. Even though the commission has now established that City violated UEFA's spending limits, the prospect of UEFA reopening its case is remote, given that a five-year statute of limitations applies to its disciplinary proceedings.
The verdict has sent what has been described as 'shock waves throughout the world of football,' with Hull owner Acun Ilicali characterising City's conduct as 'financial doping.' Former City chairman David Bernstein, who led the club from 1998 to 2003, warned that if the guilty verdict survives appeal, 'my beloved club is going to face a very severe penalty.'
UK officials had expressed concern that City's continuing legal proceedings could strain relations with the UAE, whose vice president, Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, is the club's owner. With the appeal now under way, the competition presses on in what has been described as 'an even more sharply contrasted version of the limbo in which it has existed since the Premier League first brought its charges in February 2023' — with every result for the side carrying an asterisk until the process concludes.
Why it matters — The verdict — covering £900m in artificially inflated finances over nine seasons — raises fundamental questions about the legitimacy of City's two decades of trophies and could result in an unprecedented punishment, including possible relegation, that would reshape English football.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The appeal is expected to run alongside a sanctions hearing presided over by the independent commission.
- UK officials were concerned that City's ongoing legal case would damage relations with the UAE.
- A points deduction severe enough to condemn City to relegation now seems probable.
- exact release date September 29, 2026
- exact appeal deadline October 2, 2026
- misattribution of Bloomberg report to CBS Sports
Sources differ on Whether the commission's verdict is final or contains errors: The verdict is sound and vindicates the Premier League's decision to pursue the case. (theguardian.com (quoting Richard Masters)) vs The opinion contains 'clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe'; the process reflects a 'Premier League conspiracy theory'. (theguardian.com (quoting City CEO Ferran Soriano and club statement))
Reported by yahoo.com, cbssports.com, foxnews.com, nytimes.com, theguardian.com
- Roberto ManciniItalian association football player and manager
- Mansour bin Zayed Al NahyanVice President of the United Arab Emirates
- Khaldoon Al MubarakEmirati politician and businessman