Becerra and Hilton clash over taxes, immigration and AI in California's only governor debate
With mail ballots days away, Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton spent an hour on CNN trading blows over Trump, affordability and who has actually been showing up for voters.
Xavier Becerra and Steve Hilton met on a CNN debate stage in Burbank on Wednesday in what is likely the only televised face-off before California voters choose their next governor on November 3 — and from the opening minute, the real subject was Donald Trump.
Becerra, the Democratic former health and human services secretary who leads in polls by roughly 25 points, mentioned the president more than a dozen times in the hourlong exchange, according to CalMatters, tying Hilton to Trump's positions on immigration, taxes, housing, the environment and Big Tech at nearly every turn. Hilton, the Republican former Fox News host endorsed by Trump, spent much of the night trying to redirect attention to what he called years of Democratic misgovernance in Sacramento — while carefully avoiding any full embrace of the president whose support he cannot afford to lose but whose approval rating among California likely voters sits below 25 percent.
Thank you to CNN for bringing Xavier out of hiding.— Steve Hilton, Republican gubernatorial candidate
The line landed Hilton's sharpest early punch. Since advancing out of the June primary, Becerra has maintained a low public profile while Hilton has crisscrossed the state. Hilton pressed the point throughout the night, calling Becerra a 'career politician' and a product of the 'machine in Sacramento' who was 'not even supposed to be the candidate' — a reference to Becerra's unexpected rise after then-frontrunner Rep. Eric Swalwell dropped out of the primary amid sexual misconduct allegations Swalwell denied.
There aren't training wheels in the governor's office. You have to know how to do the job, and that's why I'm asking California voters to vote for me for governor of state of California.— Xavier Becerra, Democratic gubernatorial candidate
Affordability was the first and most sustained battleground. Housing and energy costs in California rank among the steepest in the country, and a UC Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies poll co-sponsored by the Los Angeles Times identified the issue as the top concern among likely voters. Hilton's central economic pitch — a plan he calls 'Califordable' — would eliminate state income taxes on earnings up to $150,000 and slash regulations on housing and business. Arguing that the "quickest way to get more money in people's pockets is for the government to take less out," he said he would help build "10 new cities" in the state to expand housing supply.
The math doesn't add up to what he's talking about. He's going to have to take it out of somewhere. It will come out of our schools.— Xavier Becerra, Democratic gubernatorial candidate
Becerra argued that Hilton's income-tax proposal would also deliver a large cut to the state's wealthiest earners and compared it to federal tax cuts enacted under Trump. He blamed rising costs primarily on Trump's tariffs and the ongoing war with Iran, which has choked a major oil trade route and pushed the national average gas price to $4.48 per gallon this month, according to the Los Angeles Times.
The exchange over artificial intelligence illustrated the same dynamic. Hilton said California may not need tougher AI regulation and that he would wait to make that assessment. Becerra said communities that object to AI data centers should be able to block them, and he then used the contrast to invoke Trump again.
If you listen closely, you can hear Donald Trump in that response.— Xavier Becerra, Democratic gubernatorial candidate
Hilton noted that Becerra's campaign has received donations from Anthropic and OpenAI, the largest AI companies, according to CalMatters. Both candidates said they support some regulation of data centers.
The debate's most personal moment came on immigration. Becerra, the son of Mexican immigrants, accused Hilton — who grew up in England and worked as an adviser to former UK Prime Minister David Cameron — of supporting measures that would "welcome immigrants who look like you" while wanting to "deport immigrants who look like me." Hilton, who had accused Becerra of handing migrant children over to sex and labor traffickers during his time as HHS secretary, called the remark "disgraceful."
What a disgraceful remark that was.— Steve Hilton, Republican gubernatorial candidate
On two ballot measures, the candidates found rare common ground — and one sharp split. Both oppose a November measure that would levy a one-time 5 percent tax on Californians worth more than $1 billion, putting Becerra at odds with progressives including Sen. Bernie Sanders, who is scheduled to campaign in California this weekend on the measure's behalf. Becerra, however, is against Proposition 39, a measure that would require in-person voters to present a government-issued ID; he described it as an initiative "backed by Donald Trump" that would erect barriers to voting for Californians. Hilton said he supports the measure, while adding he has confidence in the state's voting system — a notable distance from Trump's unsubstantiated fraud claims.
I've got confidence in what we saw in the primary and in this process.— Steve Hilton, Republican gubernatorial candidate
Hilton's broader challenge is structural. Registered Democrats outnumber Republicans in California by nearly 2 to 1, according to the Los Angeles Times, and the state has not elected a Republican governor in two decades. His campaign last week released a poll claiming he was 'unscathed from Republican collapse,' an acknowledgment that opposition to Trump is weighing on his party's candidates statewide. Without fully breaking with Trump, Hilton offered a softer formulation of his independence.
My whole aim here would be to lower the temperature.— Steve Hilton, Republican gubernatorial candidate
CNN anchors Jake Tapper and Dana Bash served as moderators for the debate. Mail ballots begin arriving in California households within days, and the general election is November 3.
Why it matters — With mail ballots arriving imminently and no further debates scheduled, Wednesday's exchange is the last major public test of both candidates before millions of Californians lock in their votes for a governor who will oversee the world's fifth-largest economy and serve as a frontline check — or ally — to the Trump administration.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Hilton's campaign released a poll last week claiming he was 'unscathed from Republican collapse.'
- Hilton accused Becerra of handing migrant children over to sex and labor traffickers during his time as HHS secretary.
Sources differ on Whether Becerra's income-tax proposal math 'adds up': Hilton says eliminating income taxes on earnings up to $150,000 is the fastest way to put money in people's pockets and can be achieved through deregulation and cutting fraud. (latimes.com) vs Becerra says the math doesn't add up and the cuts would have to come out of schools and other services, and would also benefit billionaires and millionaires. (latimes.com)
Reported by theguardian.com, thehill.com, latimes.com, cnn.com, nytimes.com, calmatters.org
- Xavier BecerraGovernor-elect of California (born 1958)
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- David CameronPrime Minister of the United Kingdom from 2010 to 2016
- Bernie SandersUnited States Senator from Vermont
- Gavin Newsom40th governor of California since 2019
- Eric SwalwellAmerican lawyer and politician (born 1980)