Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
World

NAZA directors on their Gaza AI-targeting documentary: '24 insiders, more than 100 hours of testimony'

Israeli film-makers Rachel Szor and Yuval Abraham explain how they persuaded military and intelligence officers to describe — on camera, in the dark — a system that assigned numeric values to civilian deaths.

How does this story make you feel?

On rooftops across Tel Aviv, filmed in darkness between 2023 and 2025, 24 Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers described to camera how an AI system assigned numeric values to the expected civilian dead before each airstrike in Gaza — and how approvals were granted for strikes expected to kill up to 500 civilians in exchange for one Hamas target. The documentary built from those interviews, NAZA, premiered at the Venice Film Festival on 10 September 2026, received a 25-minute standing ovation — the longest in the festival's history, according to Wikipedia — and won the Special Jury Prize.

The film is directed by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, the Israeli film-making pair who won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature for their 2024 film No Other Land. NAZA is produced by The Guardian and British producer James Wilson's JW Films, and executive produced by Jonathan Glazer, director of The Zone of Interest. At Venice, Abraham and Szor explained how they assembled the film's testimony and why they believe its sources spoke at all.

The title is drawn from the Hebrew military acronym Nezek Agavi — collateral damage. In the targeting software described by interviewees, every potential Hamas target is assigned a NAZA value: the number of civilians expected to die in an airstrike. Targets with values below 20 required no special authorisation, according to one soldier interviewed. Approvals were granted for values as high as 500. One interviewee states that the combined NAZA values assigned to all potential Hamas fighters exceeded the total population of Gaza.

The interviewees are shown only as dark silhouettes with distorted voices. Their accounts, according to the film, describe a system in which the most reliable targets were not Hamas fighters themselves but their homes — identified through AI-assisted surveillance of mobile phones across Gaza. The intelligence service, interviewees say, had access to cameras and microphones on those phones, including those belonging to children. One interviewee calls it a 'factory of targets'.

You hack her phone, and then you kill her.— Anonymous interviewee, NAZA

The practice of listening to a child's hacked phone to determine when their father would be home — so that the whole family could be killed in a single strike — was given an internal name: 'Where's Daddy?' One interviewee recounts watching, via a Palestinian father's phone, as the man's daughter burned to death in real time. 'You feel like God,' one source says, 'because you hear everything they say'.

Several interviewees describe the mass killing of civilians as not merely accepted but regarded as a duty, reflecting what they characterise as a widespread post-October 7 belief that there were 'no innocents in Gaza.' One says killing Palestinians 'felt good' and that no one in his unit had used the psychological support available. Another states plainly: 'We kill these children deliberately.' When asked directly whether he had been involved in a genocide, one interviewee answers 'yes' without hesitation.

The Gaza health ministry has reported more than 73,000 deaths in three years of Israeli bombardment, the vast majority civilian, according to The Guardian's reporting on the film.

At Venice, Abraham was asked why these men — who risked their careers and potentially their liberty — agreed to speak. His answer was more complicated than guilt alone.

It depends which one. There are many motivations for an individual to speak. Some people talk because they feel the opposite of shame. They feel pride in their accomplishment and expertise. Remember that these people serve in sensitive units. They are not often asked what they do. So there is an attraction to [our] curiosity that drives them to speak up.— Yuval Abraham, director, NAZA

Hollywood Reporter notes that the film rests on more than 100 hours of interview material, with claims corroborated across multiple sources, though the 24 on-camera contributors are the core group consistently cited by both directors and press coverage.

Abraham also pushed back on the idea that remote, screen-mediated killing creates psychological distance that explains the behaviour documented in the film.

Sure, it's easier to kill people when you're doing it on a screen. There is some truth in that, I guess. But equally it should be said that intelligence officers know the most. They listen to the cellphones. They know the house they are bombing is full of children. They can hear babies crying. They still order another strike.— Yuval Abraham, director, NAZA

The film's backdrop is deliberately chosen: placid, daytime Tel Aviv, 44 miles from Gaza, where rush-hour traffic moves normally and a cinematheque runs a Claude Lanzmann retrospective. Glazer, Szor told The Guardian, supported the structural approach that fosters the sense of 'a home that sits next door to hell.' Abraham drew an explicit parallel at Venice: while stating that events in Gaza are not the same as the Holocaust, he said the film aims to show a common pattern — dehumanisation — and that one elite-unit interviewee reflected, with reference to the Holocaust, on how it is possible to destroy an entire building full of people 'and yet for life to simply carry on as normal.'

Making the film has carried personal costs. After No Other Land premiered at the 2024 Berlin film festival, Abraham's family home was targeted by a right-wing mob. Szor says some of her family were 'very ashamed, very angry' after the Oscar win. The Wikipedia entry on NAZA notes that the film has already prompted threats against both directors in Israel, where they are citizens. Abraham contextualises the risk deliberately.

We're taking risks in a system that privileges us, that has Jewish-Israeli supremacy as its founding characteristic. So yeah, it was scary for my mum. But she went and slept at my sister's and her house is still there. For so many Palestinians, it's not a rightwing mob that's coming to their home: it's US-funded bulldozers and weapons. Imagine if a Palestinian journalist in Gaza tried to do what we did and called up senior Israeli officials. There is no comparison. They would most likely be murdered.— Yuval Abraham, director, NAZA

NAZA was the only documentary selected for Venice's main competition, and was added to the programme as late as 24 August — following consideration of safety concerns about its screening, according to Wikipedia. It has since been announced as a late addition to the San Sebastián International Film Festival's Perlak sidebar, and its North American premiere is set for the 2026 New York Film Festival.

Why it matters — NAZA puts named film-makers and sourced insider testimony behind specific claims about AI-assisted targeting and civilian kill quotas in Gaza — moving the debate from allegation to documented account at a moment when the conflict's death toll exceeds 73,000.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Film-makers spoke to 'more than 100 sources' about Israeli actions in Gaza.
  • Some of the 24 interviewees may still be actively overseeing airstrikes at the time of the film's release.

Reported by theguardian.com, en.wikipedia.org, hollywoodreporter.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email