Vikings trade J.J. McCarthy to Giants for fifth-round pick after Jaxson Dart's season-ending injury
The 23-year-old former top-10 pick gets a fresh start in New York, where he'll back up Jameis Winston and wait behind Dart's eventual return.
The Minnesota Vikings have traded J.J. McCarthy — the No. 10 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft — to the New York Giants in exchange for a 2027 fifth-round pick, the Vikings announced Monday. The deal is pending McCarthy passing a physical.
The trade closes a turbulent chapter in Minnesota. McCarthy missed his entire rookie season with a preseason knee injury, then started 10 games in 2025, going 6-4 but completing just 57.6 percent of his passes for 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. Injuries — a high ankle sprain, a concussion, a broken hand — repeatedly interrupted his development. This offseason, the Vikings signed Kyler Murray and re-signed Carson Wentz, and officially named Murray the starter on Aug. 11. McCarthy never seriously challenged for the job and was relegated to emergency third-string duty to open 2026, according to NFL.com.
The Giants' need was urgent. Starting quarterback Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending left knee injury in Week 2 and had surgery shortly after. Jameis Winston stepped in and led New York to a 12-7 win over the Tennessee Titans in Week 3, though the offense managed just 238 yards and no touchdowns. Giants head coach John Harbaugh confirmed Monday that Winston remains the starter.
Jameis is starting. You guys asked me that [Sunday] night. He's our starting quarterback and that's how we're rolling. We'll be ready to play this next game and going forward. Excited about Jameis ... I'm looking forward to seeing where we go and as we go we'll get a chance to build around Jameis's strengths.— John Harbaugh, Giants Head Coach
On the Cardinals matchup ahead, Harbaugh was equally direct about the pecking order.
All the other conversation isn't going to help us beat the Cardinals. So it's irrelevant. Jameis will be the starter for as long as I can see into the future.— John Harbaugh, Giants Head Coach
McCarthy's path to the field in New York is narrow, at least for now. The Giants also signed Jake Haener — who has one career start with New Orleans — from the practice squad to the active roster ahead of the Titans game, according to NFL.com. McCarthy's role will depend on how quickly he absorbs the new offense.
There is, however, a notable personal thread running through the deal. McCarthy won a national championship at Michigan under Jim Harbaugh, who is John Harbaugh's brother and now coaches the Los Angeles Chargers. John Harbaugh said Monday he watched McCarthy closely during those college years.
[Jim] always had good things to say about JJ. I mean, I kind of watched it. I was following Michigan when Jim was coaching there. I don't follow him as much anymore, but when Jim was there that was a team I watched closely. So I've watched JJ play a lot.— John Harbaugh, Giants Head Coach
At Michigan, McCarthy went 27-1 as a starter, according to The Guardian. But he arrived in Minnesota with limited experience as a pro-style passer after playing in Jim Harbaugh's run-heavy college system. The energy and competitiveness that defined his college career translated unevenly to the NFL, with recklessness and inaccuracy undermining his debut season. Vikings coach Kevin O'Connell had been seen as an ideal mentor — he once said 'organizations fail young quarterbacks before young quarterbacks fail organizations' — but the combination of injuries and inconsistency proved too much for Minnesota to absorb.
The trade clears roughly $4.5 million from the Vikings' salary cap, according to NFL.com — modest by quarterback standards, but meaningful as Minnesota, now 3-0, commits to Murray. For the Giants, now 2-1, McCarthy represents a low-cost bet on upside: a 23-year-old former first-rounder who cost only a late-round pick to acquire.
On CBS Sports' 'Set Hut,' former Giants quarterback Russell Wilson called the trade 'interesting' and said it could be a 'great' situation for McCarthy. Former Pro Bowler Kyle Long said the messaging inside the building needs to be clear: Winston starts now, and when Dart returns from injury, the job goes back to him.
Look, they need him, and he needs them, so I think it's a good situation for him.— Kyle Long, CBS Sports analyst
I like it for coach [John] Harbaugh, too. He's got a guy that he knows is a competitor, a high draft pick as a backup just in case.— Russell Wilson, CBS Sports analyst
Why it matters — A former top-10 pick changes hands for a late-round pick, illustrating how quickly NFL franchises can move on from young quarterbacks — and how quickly injuries can reshape a team's entire season.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- McCarthy described feeling 'shock' over the trade
- McCarthy's precise timeline for getting up to speed in the Giants' offense and when he might see the field
Reported by yahoo.com, theguardian.com, cbssports.com, vikings.com, nfl.com, startribune.com
- Russell WilsonAmerican football player (born 1988)