Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Both Parties Are Flooding Courts With Election Lawsuits Before the Midterms

With the November midterms less than 70 days away, Republicans and Democrats are filing at a pace that experts say is unprecedented for a non-presidential election year — and the Supreme Court is already deep in the middle of it.

How does this story make you feel?

Republicans and Democrats are both pursuing aggressive election-related litigation across multiple states. The Supreme Court has already intervened multiple times — on redistricting maps, mail-in ballot deadlines, and TV ad rates — and is still sitting on cases that could rewrite the rules of voting weeks before Election Day. By any measure, the legal war over the midterms is unlike anything seen in a non-presidential year.

Legal experts say the sheer volume of high-stakes election cases now hitting the nation's courts is above historical norms for a midterm election, and the uncertainty it creates — with rules still in flux less than two months out — risks undermining public confidence in the results before a single ballot is cast.

So much of our confidence in our elections depends on it being kind of boring and predictable. When it looks like the rules are constantly changing, that isn't good for anyone … or at least anyone who wants to bolster rather than undercut confidence in our elections.— Lori Ringhand, election law professor, University of Georgia

Three forces have sharply accelerated the litigation this cycle, according to Yahoo News: a Supreme Court decision in April weakening the 1965 Voting Rights Act, which prompted Southern states to quickly draw new and sometimes contested electoral maps; pressure from President Donald Trump on Republican-led states to redraw their own maps, with Democrats responding in kind; and Trump's aggressive push to introduce new federal voting rules.

The Voting Rights Act ruling triggered immediate aftershocks in Louisiana and Alabama. The Supreme Court intervened in follow-up cases in both states through its emergency docket — in Louisiana, thousands of voters had already cast absentee ballots when the court stepped in. The justices also allowed Texas to redraw its maps to benefit Republicans and California to do the same for Democrats, and in March sided with a New York Republican in a separate redistricting fight.

Most consequential among the pending cases, experts say, is Trump's proposal to impose sweeping restrictions on mail-in voting. Under the plan, states would be required to provide voter data to the U.S. Postal Service, which would then deliver only ballots meeting certain criteria — ostensibly to prevent noncitizens from voting. The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on it.

I've never seen anything like the mail-in ballot litigation, where there is a threat to make such a drastic change to an election in the middle of an election. That's an order of magnitude different than anything else that is out there now or that we have seen.— Rick Hasen, professor of law, UCLA

Also before the justices: the legality of the Trump administration's use of Social Security data to help state officials identify noncitizens on voter rolls, according to Yahoo News.

The Justice Department has separately filed lawsuits against 30 states and Washington, D.C., after they refused to hand over voter registration databases — including names, dates of birth, residential addresses, driver's license numbers, and the last four digits of Social Security numbers — under what the DOJ calls a 'confidential memorandum of understanding.' The department says it is acting under a March 2025 executive order requiring the attorney general to ensure compliance with voter registration laws. States run their own elections, and there is no national voter database; the federal government does not oversee U.S. elections.

The DOJ's requests have produced a patchwork of outcomes. Seventeen states — including Texas, Florida, Ohio, and Louisiana — voluntarily provided voter data. Ongoing litigation continues in Delaware, Hawaii, Idaho, and Utah. Twenty-one states have had dismissals appealed, while Michigan's dismissal was affirmed by an appeals court. Georgia, Vermont, and Washington had their cases dismissed. Oklahoma and North Carolina reached settlements with the DOJ, according to NBC News. Notably, several Republican-leaning states refused to turn over their data.

The litigation landscape also spans narrower disputes: ballot envelope rules in North Carolina, changes to overseas voting forms, and, earlier this month, a Supreme Court ruling that political parties are entitled to favorable rates on TV ads from broadcasters. In June, the court ruled that states could count mail-in ballots received up to five days after Election Day.

Last Thursday, the Supreme Court blocked Missouri from using a new congressional map drawn to help Republicans pick up a seat — but the ruling forces the state to use a different map for the general election than it used in its August primary, a situation legal observers describe as extraordinary.

The escalation has deep roots. Before the Supreme Court's 2000 decision in Bush v. Gore — in which a 5-4 conservative majority halted a Florida recount, cementing George W. Bush's narrow lead over Democrat Al Gore — the yearly average of election-related cases was 94, according to research by UCLA's Rick Hasen. After that ruling, the average jumped to 283. The 2020 presidential election set the all-time record, with a separate University of Wisconsin Law School study counting 543 cases tied to that election, the majority filed by Trump and his supporters alleging fraud — virtually all of which they lost.

This is what we've seen since Bush v. Gore, which is an escalating number of court cases with each election. Since the 2000 election, because it was razor-thin, the battle over the rules has become a natural part of the election itself.— Nate Persily, professor, Stanford Law School

Trump, who continues to falsely claim the 2020 election was stolen — members of his own administration have said there was no evidence to support those claims — said as recently as last Thursday that 'the election was rigged,' according to the Denver Gazette. He has also continued to press for measures he says are aimed at preventing noncitizens from voting illegally.

One reason we're seeing more litigation is that political actors are increasingly pushing the envelope and pursuing actions ahead of elections that could be highly disruptive.— Robert Yablon, legal scholar
The legal fights over election procedures and last-minute challenges have got to be unsettling for voters and potentially damaging for officials carrying out elections.— Rick Hasen, professor of law, UCLA

Both parties are expanding their legal operations in anticipation that disputes will not end on Election Day. Democrats have focused their challenges on measures they argue could suppress votes or enable intimidation, including changes to overseas voting forms and the potential deployment of federal agents at polling places, according to the multi-source summary. With November approaching and several Supreme Court decisions still outstanding, the legal picture is unlikely to settle before voters go to the polls.

Why it matters — With multiple Supreme Court rulings still pending on mail-in voting and voter roll data — and both parties building legal armies for post-election fights — the rules governing how Americans vote in November may not be settled before they actually vote.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Democrats have filed suits against the Defense Department and are seeking to block potential deployment of federal agents at polling places.
  • North Dakota was in discussions with the DOJ over a potential information-sharing agreement as of last summer, with no lawsuit filed.
  • RNC 179 active cases across 37 states
  • Democrats suing the Defense Department
  • specific November 3 date
  • incomplete list of six Republican-leaning states refusing data

Reported by nytimes.com, electionlawblog.org, washingtonpost.com, democracydocket.com, nbcnews.com, newsweek.com, denvergazette.com, law.com, yahoo.com

People in this story
  • Donald Trump
    President of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
  • Al Gore
    Vice President of the United States from 1993 to 2001 (born 1948)

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email