Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Bolsonaro leads Lula in Brazil's first round, forcing October 25 runoff

Flávio Bolsonaro defied polls to finish ahead of President Lula in Sunday's first round, setting up a three-week sprint that will determine whether Latin America's largest economy joins the region's rightward shift.

How does this story make you feel?

In Sunday's first-round presidential election, Brazilian Senator Flávio Bolsonaro outpaced incumbent President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, confounding most major polls and setting up an October 25 runoff — the stiffest test yet of whether Latin America's recent conservative wave can capture its biggest prize.

Brazil's Superior Electoral Court reported that, with 97 percent of ballots counted, Bolsonaro held 47.45 percent of valid votes against Lula's 44.66 percent, according to Newsweek. To win outright, either candidate needed to surpass 50 percent — a threshold neither reached.

Sunday's outcome recalled 2022, when Bolsonaro's father, former President Jair Bolsonaro, ran well ahead of what pre-election surveys had predicted. Nearly every major poll published before Sunday had projected Lula finishing first in the opening round, though generally short of a majority.

In the 2022 election, Jair Bolsonaro, Flávio's father, outperformed the polls, the surveys by almost 10 percent. So there could be a surprise on Sunday.— Christopher Sabatini, senior fellow for Latin America, Chatham House

Datafolha, Brazil's most closely watched pollster, had put Lula at 45 percent to Bolsonaro's 42 percent in the first round, and its final runoff numbers showed Lula ahead 47 percent to 46 percent — a margin that evaporated on election night, according to Newsweek. In 2022, Datafolha's final survey placed Jair Bolsonaro at 36 percent of valid votes in the first round, yet he wound up with roughly 43 percent.

Electoral strategist Roberto Reis, who analyzes aggregator data and works with candidates across multiple electoral tiers, had flagged the polling gap before the vote.

The problem with Datafolha, which is the largest polling institute in the country, is that it tends to underestimate the force and voting intention in candidates running against Lula or the Workers Party (PT). This has been consistent for at least over a decade, and it underestimated Jair Bolsonaro's number on the runoff of 2018 by 7%.— Roberto Reis, electoral strategist

Bolsonaro enters the runoff with momentum. Attention from analysts and both campaigns will now turn to supporters of eliminated candidates — including writer and psychiatrist Augusto Cury, former Goiás Governor Ronaldo Caiado and former Minas Gerais Governor Romeu Zema, all of whom finished in single digits. How their supporters break in the second round could decide the presidency, according to Newsweek.

According to Newsweek, recent Datafolha surveys showed that about 46 percent of voters rule out ever supporting Lula, with a nearly identical share saying the same of Bolsonaro — a deep divide that gives the endorsements of eliminated candidates unusual weight.

Brazil ranks as Latin America's largest nation and economy. Analysts described Sunday's vote as the most significant remaining test of the region's conservative shift, following Trump-endorsed or conservative wins in Honduras and Colombia. While other left-wing governments exist in the hemisphere — including Cuba, Mexico, Nicaragua and Uruguay — Brazil is by far the largest economy among them, ranking as the 11th largest in the world according to the IMF and 10th according to the World Bank, per Fox News.

The contest has been shaped heavily by the relationship between Flávio Bolsonaro and President Donald Trump. In May, Bolsonaro sat down with Trump at the White House, where their talks covered organized crime, tariffs and Brazil's rare earth and critical mineral reserves, according to Fox News. He has proposed a free-trade agreement between Brazil and the United States and has emphasized cooperation on critical minerals as Washington seeks to reduce dependence on China.

The Trump administration's moves against Lula's government have been pointed. In July, the United States levied new 25 percent tariffs on a broad range of Brazilian goods, hitting roughly $7 billion in exports, and separately restricted most new permanent visa applications from Brazil, according to Fox News. The State Department also designated Brazil's two largest criminal organizations — the First Capital Command (PCC) and Red Command — as terrorist groups on May 28, effective in June, after Bolsonaro requested the designations. The move incensed Lula and his allies, who viewed it as direct interference in domestic affairs.

Lula has defended strong ties with Beijing. Brazil counts China as its foremost trading partner, and in 2025 Brazilian agricultural exports to China exceeded $55 billion, according to Reuters as cited by Fox News. A Lula victory in the runoff would mean continuity in a foreign policy that prioritizes commercial ties with China while maintaining what Lula describes as strategic autonomy from Washington.

Elections are always local affairs.— Patricio Navia, clinical professor of liberal studies, New York University

Navia added that voters who think Brazil is headed in the wrong direction will punish Lula, while those who approve of his government will reelect him — and that Trump's influence on the outcome is limited: "I know President Trump thinks that he is on the ballot in Brazil, but he is not," he told Newsweek.

Security is the dominant issue for Brazilian voters. Gimena Sánchez, director for the Andes at the Washington Office on Latin America, told Newsweek, "In Brazil, the number one issue for voters is security." "There is a perception that security has worsened, but this is not the case." Sánchez expressed skepticism about the hardline crackdowns gaining popularity across the region, arguing that inequality and lack of access to land, markets and opportunity must also be addressed.

Flávio's father and former president, Jair Bolsonaro, is barred from seeking office and is currently serving a 27-year prison sentence for plotting a coup following his 2022 defeat to Lula, according to Newsweek. Whoever prevails on October 25 will be sworn in on January 5, 2027 — a date established by a 2021 constitutional amendment that shifted the inauguration away from January 1.

Why it matters — Brazil is Latin America's largest economy, and a Bolsonaro win on October 25 would complete the region's most significant political realignment in a generation while reshaping U.S.-Brazil trade, security and China policy.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Bolsonaro leads Lula 45% to 44% in runoff polling according to aggregator data from MRT News and Polling Data
  • The Amazon has become a hub for criminal groups pushed deeper into the region

Sources differ on Pre-election first-round polling averages: Datafolha: Lula 45%, Bolsonaro 42% (newsweek.com) vs Quaest: Lula 46%, Bolsonaro 45% (newsweek.com) vs AtlasIntel/Bloomberg: Lula 47%, Bolsonaro 44.1% (newsweek.com) vs CNT/MDA: Lula 47.8%, Bolsonaro 42.1% (newsweek.com) vs Aggregator data (MRT News/Polling Data): Lula 42%, Bolsonaro 39% (foxnews.com)

Reported by foxnews.com, aljazeera.com, newsweek.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email