Double Dare turns 40: How a messy kids' game show built the Nickelodeon empire
On October 6, 1986, Marc Summers asked a trivia question and changed children's television forever — and the slime has never really stopped flowing.
Forty years ago, a receptionist's fondness for the board game Mouse Trap, a last-minute defection by a future Saturday Night Live cast member, and a rejected pitch from a cookie company all collided to produce one of the most influential children's television programs ever made. On October 6, 1986, Marc Summers stepped in front of a camera at a Philadelphia PBS studio and kicked off Nickelodeon's Double Dare — a show that would become cable television's highest-rated program and transform a struggling educational channel into a cultural force.
The 40th anniversary is being marked with a sold-out reunion at City Winery in Philadelphia on October 4, where Summers, Robin Russo (formerly Marella), and announcer Harvey will return to reminisce and put attendees through Physical Challenges for prizes. For those who couldn't get tickets, the full event will be available for pay-per-view streaming on eventive.org on October 30, according to the Museum of Play.
The show's origins were anything but tidy — fitting, given what it became. By one account, the whole thing started with Nabisco. The company approached Nickelodeon about producing a cookie-themed game show. Nickelodeon passed, but the pitch planted a seed: the channel had never made a game show. Gerry Laybourne, Nickelodeon's president at the time, called a meeting open to everyone at the channel, and Double Dare was essentially built by committee.
Producer Geoffrey Darby argued the game needed what he called a 'jeopardy' — some element of risk. That thinking led the room toward the children's game of Truth or Dare, with trivia replacing 'truth.' The dare, the group decided, should lead somewhere messy. National Archives of Game Show History co-founder Howard Blumenthal, who was in early meetings with Laybourne and Darby, recalls that the phrase 'double dare' was coined when he and several others blurted it out simultaneously while workshopping ideas. According to the Museum of Play, Blumenthal's work on the development process also involved Michael Yudin and a handful of other contributors.
One of the show's defining features — the Physical Challenge — solved two problems at once. Staff worried that children might feel embarrassed about not knowing answers to harder questions, so they created an alternative: a physical stunt the team could attempt instead. Darby also recognized that messy stunts would be the most compelling part of the show, and he didn't want viewers to tune in late and miss them. By making Physical Challenges available at any point in the game, the format ensured that a viewer could never safely look away.
The Obstacle Course — the show's signature finale of slime-filled bathtubs and themed physical gauntlets — grew out of a discussion about the board game Mouse Trap. According to one account cited by the Museum of Play, Dee LaDuke, the receptionist at Nickelodeon, mentioned her love of the game and imagined a human being navigating a life-sized version. Howard Blumenthal remembers it being raised more as a general scenic vision. Either way, it became the image most associated with the show.
Over 1,200 candidates auditioned for the hosting role. The job was first offered to pie-throwing comedian Soupy Sales, who was passed over for being too old. Then Dana Carvey was reportedly hired — until he received an invitation to join the cast of Saturday Night Live on the same day and withdrew. Marc Summers ultimately landed the position; in his own words, he had 'one foot out the door' of show business after a decade of frustrations, and had spent a surprisingly successful year selling salmon wholesale.
I treat kids like shorter adults. This is like 'Scrabble' or any other game show — our contestants just happen to be in the seventh grade.— Marc Summers, Host
Philadelphia disc jockey John Harvey — known on the show simply as Harvey — came aboard as announcer. The show taped at the studios of the city's local PBS station as a cost-cutting measure. Robin Marella and Dave Shikiar served as assistants, setting up equipment for each Physical Challenge.
The show's success was not immediately obvious to the industry. As the Los Angeles Times reported in late 1987, not many people noticed when Double Dare launched — except kids, who watched and told friends, who told other friends. By 1987 it had become Nickelodeon's most-watched program and ranked among the top-rated strips on basic cable. That's when the money followed.
I would come home from work and hear my kids talking about this show, so I decided to take a look. I thought, this is truly a game show for kids — an honest show.— Derk Zimmerman, President, Fox Television Stations Inc.
Under a deal among Fox Television, Viacom Enterprises, and Nickelodeon, Double Dare changed hands: Fox acquired broadcast rights across its seven stations — among them KTTV Channel 11 in Los Angeles — while Viacom took syndication rights and Nickelodeon retained the cable rights. The show moved into a late-afternoon weekday slot on Fox and most other broadcast outlets beginning in February, according to the Los Angeles Times. It was one of the rare instances of a cable show crossing over to broadcast television.
I think you're going to see six clones in the next six weeks. Everyone is going to have their version of this.— Derk Zimmerman, President, Fox Television Stations Inc.
Zimmerman's prediction proved accurate. NBC added the sibling-secrets show I'm Telling to its Saturday morning lineup; Lorimar began developing Fun House for syndication; and a production company was developing a syndicated series called Scavenger Hunt. Nickelodeon itself tried to replicate the formula with Finders Keepers. The genre Double Dare created had become a market.
Darby, who co-created the show, was cautious about the rush of imitators. Speaking to the Los Angeles Times, he cautioned that adults and children are drawn to different things and that it takes a while to learn how to work for kids on their level and to lose the arrogance of thinking you know what they want.
Before Double Dare, Nickelodeon had spent seven largely unremarkable years as an educational channel for children. The Canadian import You Can't Do That on Television had caught audiences off guard with its success and nudged the channel toward an entertainment focus in the early 1980s, yet it was Double Dare that transformed Nickelodeon into a true brand — one that grew to include a Fox prime-time version, a syndicated version, a live touring production, and a merchandise line, according to the Museum of Play.
Marc Summers recited the show's rules — explaining how a team could dare opponents to answer for double the dollars, and how a double dare forced a choice between answering or taking the Physical Challenge — more than 500 times over the course of the original run. Millions of children had the words memorized. The original series ended in 1993, and the show returned for runs in 2000 and again across two seasons in 2018 and 2019.
Why it matters — Double Dare didn't just entertain a generation of children — it created the template for interactive, personality-driven kids' TV and turned Nickelodeon from a niche cable channel into a dominant cultural brand whose influence is still visible in children's programming today.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Dana Carvey was hired to host Double Dare before withdrawing to join Saturday Night Live.
- The Obstacle Course concept originated with receptionist Dee LaDuke's fondness for the board game Mouse Trap.
- verbatim quotation marks around Darby caution on working with kids (paraphrased for accuracy)
Reported by museumofplay.org, broadwayworld.com, latimes.com, people.com
- Dana CarveyAmerican comedian