Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
World

Iran's Hormuz toll: Gulf states may be paying millions per ship to move their oil

Middle East crude exports have clawed back to pre-war levels, but a senior analyst suspects the price includes secret payments to Iran worth up to a fifth of each cargo's value.

How does this story make you feel?

Middle East oil exports have recovered to pre-war levels for the first time since the US-Israel war on Iran began in February — but a senior analyst at maritime tracking firm Kpler suspects the recovery is partly being bought with secret payments to Tehran, potentially worth 10 to 20 percent of each cargo's value.

Provisional Kpler data show that on four days in the final week of September, crude exports from the region came in between 19.5 and 22.5 million barrels per day, topping the pre-war average of roughly 18 million bpd. The figures include oil moved through alternative routes — pipelines across Saudi Arabia and the UAE, ship-to-ship transfers in the Gulf of Oman, and supplies through the Red Sea — not just traffic through the strait itself.

I suspect there is a toll that's being paid, which is giving these ships safe passage.— Michelle Brohard, Head of Policy and Geopolitical Risk, Kpler
I also suspect that these countries know that this is unsustainable from a perspective of [the] US escorting [ships], and also unsustainable from them paying Iran 10 percent of their cargo, or 20 percent of their cargo. So you're starting to see like what I would call like a race to get out as much as possible, as quickly as possible before the war restarts.— Michelle Brohard, Head of Policy and Geopolitical Risk, Kpler

Brohard presented the claim as speculation rather than a finding backed by evidence, and it has not been independently verified. But as early as March, the shipping journal Lloyd's List had reported that Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps was already running what it called a 'toll booth' system to control vessel traffic through the strait, according to Al Jazeera.

According to straits.live, Iran has imposed charges for passage through the strait, often reported in the millions per vessel and scaled by size and cargo. Some operators are reported to receive different terms, though no single public confirmation of a fully systematic, universally applied toll exists.

Iran frames any charges as 'fees for services' rather than tolls — a legally significant distinction. Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, tolls on transit passage through an international strait are prohibited, though charges tied to specific services actually rendered — such as traffic management or pilotage — are allowed. Both the US and Gulf states are opposed to charges in either form.

Normal commercial traffic through the Strait of Hormuz has been effectively shut down since February 28, 2026. Before the war, it carried roughly one-fifth of the world's oil and natural gas exports, with about 125 large commercial vessels transiting daily. A June 17 framework — the Islamabad Memorandum, brokered by Pakistan — temporarily suspended the per-vessel toll regime for 60 days alongside a ceasefire, but the deal collapsed within days. Iran re-declared the strait closed, and fighting resumed.

The violence has continued into October. Straits.live reports that the Kuwaiti supertanker Al Funtas was struck by a projectile on September 28, followed by three more ships hit on September 29, the Kuwaiti supertanker Kazimah III set ablaze on October 1, two additional tankers reported struck on October 2, and the product tanker Lipsi disabled by a hit to its engine room on October 4, leaving it adrift. A seafarer lost their life on September 23 after projectiles struck the bulk carrier Cape Dao off the coast of Oman. The Guard-linked Fars news agency reported on October 3 that the Revolutionary Guard's navy had struck seven tankers it described as 'violating' over the course of five days. A tanker north of Khasab, Oman, received a warning from Guard forces on October 5 that it faced targeting if it did not reverse course — and it turned back, according to UKMTO.

Iran disputes that it has lost control of the waterway. According to Al Jazeera, senior IRGC commander Ali Fadavi said on Sunday that only three to four million bpd were travelling along a US-supervised route, calling that volume 'negligible' compared with pre-war traffic. September flows through the strait itself stood at 6.02 million barrels a day, according to Kpler data cited by The National — fewer than one in three barrels of February's level.

The export recovery that does exist leans heavily on workarounds. Kpler says about 40 percent of crude left the Gulf in September without crossing the strait at all, flowing instead through Saudi and Emirati pipelines. Much of the crude that does cross the strait changes tankers offshore to reduce the risk of being targeted. The figures also exclude any vessels that crossed with their automatic identification system transponders switched off to avoid detection.

The bypass routes suffered a further setback on September 11, when drone strikes launched from Iraq forced Saudi Arabia's East-West pipeline — the largest detour around the strait — offline. After restarting at a reduced rate on September 22, flow on September 28 was near 2.65 million barrels a day, roughly half the pre-attack rate, according to Reuters as carried by Baird Maritime. Saudi Aramco has not confirmed a figure.

Diplomatic efforts to resolve the charging question have repeatedly stalled. A seven-day proposal put forward by Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi on September 25 called for the US to release frozen assets, lift oil sanctions, and end its naval blockade, after which fighting would cease and Iran would reopen the strait on the final day. President Trump publicly rejected it on September 26. Iran said on September 30 it had received a US response, but its terms have not been published. On October 4, parliament speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf stated that the strait would remain closed until Iran's conditions — which he said are grounded in the June Islamabad Memorandum — are satisfied.

Washington itself briefly floated a 20 percent Hormuz transit fee in mid-July, only to set the idea aside in favor of Gulf investment deals, according to straits.live. The Trump administration has stated publicly that Iran will not be permitted to charge a toll under any potential agreement with Washington. One unnamed US official has also said that any deal to end the war would include no fees or tolls for passage, though that account rests on a single unnamed source.

Oman proposed a parallel framework — joint regional management of the strait funded by voluntary user contributions, modeled on the Strait of Malacca, and drafted with UN IMO involvement — that would leave Iran without sole control. Iran rejected it in late July. Iran then put forward its own schedule of service fees in late August, covering ships it authorizes, and compiled a blacklist of tankers it accused of violating its transit rules; straits.live reported that list had reached 77 vessels by September 14.

Al Jazeera quoted academic Abdul Khalique as saying that while Brohard's speculation about a transit-fee arrangement may be 'plausible,' it is more accurately characterized as an 'informal security mechanism rather than a formal maritime levy.'

Oil prices remain well above pre-war levels despite the partial export recovery. On Monday, Brent crude stood at around $101.59 a barrel and US West Texas Intermediate at around $90.05, with both benchmarks pushed higher in part by insurance costs tied to fears of Iranian attacks and by markets factoring in the possibility of renewed full-scale conflict. The G7 last week announced a release of 100 million barrels from emergency reserves.

Despite exports from the region resurging, much will depend, longer-term, on the security of energy supplies. The Strait of Hormuz remains a major flashpoint, with the attack on another tanker on Sunday keeping worries bubbling about the potential for further disruption to supplies, particularly if shipping companies become increasingly reluctant to risk sending vessels through the crucial chokepoint.— Susannah Streeter, Chief Investment Strategist, Wealth Club

Why it matters — If Gulf states are quietly paying Iran a share of their oil revenues to move cargo, Tehran is effectively taxing a fifth of the world's energy supply — reshaping who profits from the war and how long any ceasefire can hold.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Gulf states are paying Iran 10–20% of cargo value for safe passage through the Strait of Hormuz
  • Per-vessel transit fees of $1–2 million are being charged, sometimes paid in cryptocurrency or yuan
  • Iran established a body called the Persian Gulf Strait Authority to issue transit permits and collect payments
  • Any deal ending the war would carry no fees or tolls for passage
  • East-West pipeline flow near 2.65 million bpd on September 28
  • Some operators linked to India, Pakistan, or China receive exemptions or different terms on transit fees

Sources differ on Volume of oil moving through the Strait of Hormuz: Only 3–4 million bpd on the US-supervised route, described as 'negligible' (aljazeera.com (citing IRGC commander Ali Fadavi)) vs 6.02 million bpd through the strait in September (straits.live (citing Kpler via The National)) vs Total Middle East exports (including all routes) exceeded 18 million bpd on four days in late September (aljazeera.com, straits.live (citing Kpler))

Sources differ on Whether Iran's charges constitute illegal tolls or permissible service fees: Iran frames charges as 'fees for services' permitted under UNCLOS (straits.live) vs US and Gulf states oppose charges in either form (straits.live) vs Academic describes arrangement as 'informal security mechanism rather than a formal maritime levy' (aljazeera.com)

Reported by aljazeera.com, straits.live

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email