Bill Withers' publisher sues UMG and Capitol, claiming Olivia Dean track copies 'Just the Two of Us'
Mattie Music Group filed suit in federal court in Los Angeles on October 1, alleging Dean's closing track on her Grammy-winning album 'I've Seen It' repeatedly copies the melody of Withers' 1981 hit — and that the labels kept selling it after being warned.
The publisher of Bill Withers' catalog has sued Capitol Records, Universal Music Group, Sony Publishing, and Kobalt Music Publishing in federal court in Los Angeles, claiming the closing track on Olivia Dean's Grammy-winning album 'The Art of Loving' copies the melody of Withers' 1981 hit 'Just the Two of Us' — and that the labels continued exploiting the song for weeks after receiving a written warning.
Mattie Music Group, which does business as Bleunig Music and controls Withers' catalog, filed the seven-page complaint on October 1, 2026, in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. The suit alleges that Dean's 'I've Seen It' copies the Withers track 'in large and significant part,' including what it calls 'repeated copying of the distinctively protectable melody.' Dean and her two co-writers — Bastian Langebaek and Max Wolfgang — are not named as defendants.
In early August, 2026, upon listening several times to I've Seen It, representatives of Plaintiff came to what they considered to be the obvious and inescapable conclusion that I've Seen It copied in large and significant part the Original Work, including without limitation repeated copying of the distinctively protectable melody, and clearly infringed Plaintiff's copyrights in and to the Original Work.— Mattie Music Group complaint
To support that conclusion, Mattie Music Group hired musicologist Alexander Stewart, who conducted what the complaint describes as a preliminary comparison and a search for similar prior art. According to the filing, Stewart's analysis identified "substantial similarities in protectable musical expression, including repeated copying of the distinctively protectable melody."
On or about August 17, 2026, the publisher notified each defendant in writing, pointing to its copyright registration for 'Just the Two of Us,' the accused composition, and the particular musical similarities at issue. A registration certificate dating to 1981 was attached to the complaint as its own exhibit. The labels did not pull the song.
Despite receiving notice, defendants continued reproducing, distributing, licensing, publicly performing, and commercially exploiting the Infringing Work.— Mattie Music Group complaint
That continued distribution after notice is central to the publisher's claim that the infringement was — and remains — willful, which matters enormously for damages. Under copyright law, willful infringement can expose defendants to statutory damages of up to $150,000 per work. Mattie Music Group is also seeking its actual losses plus the defendants' profits from the alleged infringement, a permanent injunction barring further use of the Withers song, and an order authorizing seizure or destruction of infringing copies, according to the complaint.
'Just the Two of Us' was co-written by Withers with Ralph MacDonald and William Salter and performed by jazz saxophonist Grover Washington Jr. with Withers on lead vocals. Released to radio stations in 1981, it reached No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and earned a Grammy for best R&B song. Withers died in 2020. According to Music Business Worldwide, Mattie Music Group is one of three publishers credited on the composition — alongside Antisia Music and BMG Ruby Songs — and neither of the other two has joined the lawsuit.
The lawsuit argues that the song's commercial reach — Billboard success, Grammy recognition, decades of radio play, widespread streaming, and numerous cover versions — means Dean and her co-writers had a reasonable opportunity to have heard it before writing 'I've Seen It.' The complaint goes further, arguing that even without that exposure evidence, the overlap between the two songs is so striking that coincidence or independent creation can be ruled out.
Independently of the widespread-dissemination evidence, the number, character, and arrangement of the shared musical features are so striking that they support an inference that the similarities did not result from coincidence, independent creation, or reliance on common musical elements.— Mattie Music Group complaint
Dean's second album, 'The Art of Loving,' closes with 'I've Seen It'; Capitol put it out on or about September 26, 2025, according to the complaint. At the Grammy Awards in February, Dean took home the best new artist prize for that record. None of the named defendants — Capitol, UMG, Sony, or Kobalt — had responded to requests for comment at the time of reporting. NBC News said it also reached out to the Withers estate and to Dean directly.
Why it matters — The case tests whether the melody of one of the most-played R&B songs of the past four decades is protectable against a current chart hit, and the willfulness allegation — triggered by the labels' decision to keep selling the song after a written warning — could make the financial stakes far higher than a typical copyright dispute.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Dean and her co-writers actually heard 'Just the Two of Us' before writing 'I've Seen It'
- Grammy-winning album closer (reframed as closing track on Grammy-winning album)
Reported by nbcnews.com, musicbusinessworldwide.com, hollywoodreporter.com
- Bill WithersAmerican musician (1938–2020)
- Olivia DeanBritish singer
- Grover Washington Jr.American jazz saxophonist (1943–1999)