Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
World

Israeli documentary NAZA opens in US, putting AI targeting and civilian deaths at center of debate

Directed by Israeli filmmakers and produced by The Guardian, NAZA features 24 anonymous soldiers describing how AI systems calculated acceptable civilian deaths — and has drawn threats of citizenship revocation from Israel's prime minister.

How does this story make you feel?

A documentary in which Israeli soldiers describe, in their own words, how artificial intelligence was used to select targets in Gaza — and how many civilian deaths were deemed acceptable before a strike — opened in U.S. theaters this week, arriving without a traditional distributor but carrying a Venice Film Festival jury prize, a record-breaking standing ovation, and a threat from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to strip its directors of their citizenship.

NAZA — named for the Hebrew military acronym nezek agavi, meaning collateral damage — is an 80-minute film directed by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor and produced by The Guardian. It features testimony from 24 Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers, filmed anonymously at night on Tel Aviv rooftops, their faces obscured and voices distorted. The subjects describe AI-powered surveillance systems used to identify targets in Gaza, a database of tens of thousands of people flagged as having Hamas connections, and a framework in which each potential target was assigned a "NAZA" value — the expected number of civilian deaths from an airstrike. One interviewee said that strikes with values below 20 needed no special authorization, while approvals could be granted for values reaching as high as 500.

The film is now playing at New York's IFC Center and expands on October 9 to Austin, Chicago, Los Angeles, and Seattle. Viewers will be able to watch it at no cost on The Guardian's website beginning in late November. It is set for release in cinemas across more than 50 territories.

These soldiers are talking about what has been done with the taxpayer money of the people sitting here.— Yuval Abraham, co-director

Abraham made the remark at the film's North American premiere at the New York Film Festival, where he and Szor addressed an audience a day after Netanyahu delivered a speech to the UN General Assembly defending Israel's conduct in Gaza. The timing was not incidental: the U.S. provides $3.8 billion in annual military assistance to Israel, a figure the filmmakers cited directly to the New York crowd.

The film's specific allegations are stark. Interviewees describe an AI tool that processed surveillance data across Gaza and suggested targets with Hamas connections, creating a database of tens of thousands of people. A second AI tool recommended buildings and structures to strike. The subjects say the systems made mistakes. One describes approval being granted for an operation targeting a single Hamas militant that anticipated 500 civilian deaths. Another recalls Israeli snipers firing on people approaching a food distribution point, illustrating the incident with a stick-figure drawing. According to one interviewee, intelligence officers hacked a child's phone to track when her father would be at home, so the family could be killed together in an airstrike. The practice is referred to in the film as "Where's Daddy?".

Several interviewees say the mass killing of civilians was not only accepted but viewed as a duty, reflecting a post-October 7 belief that there were "no innocents in Gaza." One member of an elite unit, asked whether he had participated in a genocide, answers "yes" without hesitation, adding: "We kill these children deliberately."

In a categorical denial of the filmmakers' findings, the Israeli military stated that its orders "explicitly, comprehensively and clearly distinguish" between militants and civilians, that target selection is carried out by intelligence officers and strike decisions by operational commanders, and that many of the anonymous interviewees did not appear to be aware of the larger targeting process. It specifically denied the claim that a strike was approved knowing it could kill 500 civilians, calling it one of several "substantial factual errors" in the film.

Our country is doing so much to hide these systems. It's not a world that is open even to the Israeli public.— Rachel Szor, co-director

The political response in Israel has been severe. Netanyahu called the film antisemitic and said he would seek legislation to revoke the citizenship of Abraham and Szor. Miki Zohar, the culture minister, charged that the two had committed "treason against the state." IDF Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir said the military would use "every tool at our disposal" against the film and would not allow soldiers to be "made targets through lies and blood libels." Protests have turned personal: dozens of right-wing activists gathered outside Szor's parents' home in central Israel, with one among them demanding the "death penalty for traitors." Abraham has said he fears he will not be able to return home.

So, to all those spreading these lies about my country and about our brave soldiers, whether they sit in this hall or in the office of the antisemitic mayor of New York, I say this: shame on you!— Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli Prime Minister

More than 1,500 Israeli film professionals, 43 Israeli human rights organizations, directors of major international festivals, and numerous press freedom organizations have defended Abraham and Szor, according to The Guardian.

At the New York premiere, a few dozen protesters gathered outside carrying images from Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack. At least one truck with LED screens circled the theater, calling the film "propaganda dressed up as a documentary." Abraham acknowledged the attack directly: "It's in the film and it's completely unjustified," he said of the massacre. "But it also cannot justify what you've seen in the film … the slaughter of so many civilians in Gaza, the massacres at food sites."

The film's reporting draws on interviews with more than 100 confidential sources conducted between 2023 and 2025, in collaboration with The Guardian's investigation desk. The bulk of the underlying reporting appeared earlier in +972 Magazine, the Hebrew-language outlet Local Call, and The Guardian. The Associated Press separately investigated Israel's battlefield use of AI models built by U.S. tech companies in Gaza, a body of work that earned the Pulitzer Prize in International Reporting; Microsoft subsequently reduced the Israeli military's access to its products.

NAZA is a British production, co-produced by The Guardian and producer James Wilson's JW Films, and executive produced by Jonathan Glazer, whose film The Zone of Interest — about the life of an Auschwitz commandant — won the Academy Award for Best International Feature. No Other Land, the previous film Abraham and Szor made together, took the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature in 2025 and examined Israeli settler violence against Palestinian communities in the West Bank. Like NAZA, it reached American audiences through self-distribution.

Newsweek, in a critical assessment of the film, argued that while the allegations deserve serious examination, NAZA's presentation sometimes works against its own case — using atmospheric visuals of Tel Aviv domestic life to do "argumentative work" and giving insufficient weight to October 7, Hamas's use of civilian areas, and Israeli measures intended to reduce civilian casualties. The IDF's detailed rebuttal, the outlet noted, means the film's most important claims remain genuinely contested. "Serious allegations demand serious scrutiny," Newsweek wrote, adding that threatening or silencing the filmmakers "may prove to be self-defeating."

The film opens in the U.S. as Israel prepares for its own elections at the end of this month, and as the Gaza war — now in its third year — continues to divide American politics. Gaza's Health Ministry reports that more than 74,000 Palestinians have been killed in Israel's offensive, with over 1,400 of those deaths occurring since a fragile ceasefire took hold a year ago. The ministry's tallies make no distinction between militants and civilians, though they show women and children account for roughly half of all fatalities. Hamas-led militants killed approximately 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 others in the October 7 attack.

After you watch the film, it becomes much harder to doubt that these are real people. It's all truthful, it's all vetted and we feel very, very confident about it.— Yuval Abraham, co-director

Why it matters — The film puts specific, sourced allegations about AI-assisted civilian targeting at the center of the U.S. debate over its $3.8 billion annual military support for Israel, arriving as both countries head toward elections.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • One interviewee says approval was given for an operation targeting one Hamas militant that anticipated 500 civilian deaths
  • The combined NAZA values of potential Hamas fighters exceeded Gaza's total population
  • Intelligence personnel could access the cameras and microphones of phones across Gaza, including those of children
  • 55 countries (changed to more than 50 territories to match source)

Sources differ on Whether the film's allegations reflect actual IDF policy and targeting decisions: Filmmakers say testimony from 24 soldiers and 100+ sources, vetted and corroborated with documents and prior reporting, accurately describes systemic practices (theguardian.com) vs IDF says the film contains 'substantial factual errors,' strips decisions of context, and that interviewees did not appear aware of the full targeting process (newsweek.com)

Sources differ on Whether the film constitutes journalism or antisemitic propaganda: Abraham and Szor describe it as investigative journalism requiring anonymous sources to expose hidden state systems; over 1,500 Israeli film professionals and 43 human rights organizations have defended them (theguardian.com) vs Netanyahu called the film antisemitic; Culture Minister Miki Zohar accused the directors of treason; protesters called it 'propaganda dressed up as a documentary' (theguardian.com)

Reported by religionnews.com, hollywoodreporter.com, bostonglobe.com, en.wikipedia.org, theguardian.com, newsweek.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email