Toxicology shows same three banned substances in both Ole Miss students who died in September
Court documents reveal Aidan Hamilton and Robert Strang had identical synthetic kratom compounds in their systems — and a defense attorney disclosed starkly different causes of death for each.
A federal court hearing on Friday produced the clearest picture yet of what killed two University of Mississippi students found dead on the same September day: toxicology reports show both Aidan Hamilton, 18, and Robert Strang, 20, had the same three substances in their bloodstreams — Mitragynine, MGM-15, and MGPI — all ingredients in a synthetic kratom product called Smax Mango Breeze. But a defense attorney disclosed in court that the two young men died in markedly different ways.
According to Action News 5, one defense attorney said Hamilton died from a combined use of various substances, including cough syrup, while Strang died from inhalation asphyxiation. Federal prosecutors, for their part, told the court that both deaths were 'consistent with overdoses' and that 'evidence supports' the case against the two men charged with selling the pills.
The three substances detected — Mitragynine, MGM-15, and MGPI — are all listed as ingredients in Smax Mango Breeze MGM-15 pills, according to court documents reviewed by Fox News Digital. MGM-15 and MGPI are Schedule 1 controlled substances; the DEA temporarily placed Mitragynine Pseudoindoxyl and MGM-15 on the Schedule 1 list on August 26, 2026, according to Atlanta News First. Court documents state there is 'probable cause to believe these drugs caused two overdose deaths in Oxford, Mississippi.'
Hamilton and Strang were found dead in separate locations on September 21 — Hamilton in his on-campus dorm room at Stewart Hall, Strang in his off-campus home on Van Buren Avenue. Investigators found opened Smax packaging near each. The full toxicology reports have not been publicly released, and autopsies remain pending, according to Atlanta News First.
The investigation traced the pills to specific purchases. Bank records provided by Hamilton's family showed he visited Puffs Vape, Tobacco and Beer Store in Oxford on September 9, September 14, and September 20 — the day before his death — spending $87.18 on his final visit, according to testimony from Lafayette County Metro Narcotics agent Caleb Easter. Strang's bank records show he spent $43.59 at Puffs on September 20 as well. However, investigators say Strang's Smax pills were actually purchased at a different store: Express Mart #7 on Highway 315 and Highway 7 in Water Valley, Yalobusha County, about 20 miles from campus, with bank records showing visits on September 9 and September 11, according to Atlanta News First.
Charged in connection with the Puffs store sales are 51-year-old Yahya Mohamed Mosleh and his 18-year-old son, Islam Mohamed Mosleh, each facing one federal count of possession with intent to distribute a controlled substance. The case against them tightened considerably after investigators sent a confidential informant into Puffs on September 24 — three days after the students' deaths.
Court documents indicate that Yahya Mohamed Mosleh warned the confidential informant to be careful with the pills because people were dying from them.
According to court documents, Mosleh made the sale from a locked container, concealing it when other customers entered the store and completing it only after they left. The product he sold, court documents say, 'had been banned by local ordinance for more than 4 years' — Oxford has its own kratom ban in addition to state regulations. When agents subsequently executed a search warrant at Puffs, they found the same Smax Mango Breeze MGM-15 with identical packaging, ingredients, and a $39.99 price tag bearing a smudge on the first nine — matching packages found at both students' locations.
The search also recovered 500 units of kratom and kratom-like products, along with THC cartridges, gummies, pre-rolls, and other suspected THC substances, according to Action News 5.
At Friday's detention hearing, a federal judge ruled Yahya Mosleh must remain in custody, finding him to be a flight risk with ties to another country. Agent Easter testified that Mosleh had been in communication with the store's owner, Amer Alowdi, who was indicted by a state grand jury in Lafayette County for distribution of a controlled substance but absconded and is believed to be running the store remotely from Egypt, according to court documents. Islam Mosleh was granted release on a $20,000 unsecured bond with conditions including a curfew and location monitoring.
Kratom, derived from a tree native to Southeast Asia, is legal at the federal level but has been banned in eleven states and regulated in others, including Mississippi, which requires buyers to be 21 or older. The danger flagged by investigators centers on synthetic derivatives — products marketed as kratom but manufactured with compounds that can be, according to Agent Easter's affidavit, 'significantly stronger than morphine' and carry 'a high risk of severe addiction, overdose and death.' Atlanta News First reported that Mississippi doctors have renewed warnings that 'natural' labeling does not indicate safety, and that these products are sometimes called 'gas station heroin.'
The Lafayette County Metro Narcotics unit said the investigation remains active and additional charges are possible, according to The Guardian. Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves had previously said two state agencies were working to expedite the toxicology reports.
Why it matters — The case is the first to publicly link specific synthetic kratom compounds — now federally banned — to the deaths of two college students, and it raises urgent questions about the sale of Schedule 1 substances in ordinary retail stores near university campuses.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Hamilton died from a combined use of various substances including cough syrup; Strang died from inhalation asphyxiation
- The Smax Mango Breeze pills directly caused the two deaths
- Store owner Amer Alowdi is currently in Egypt running the store remotely
- verbatim quote marks around the clerk's warning to the informant
Reported by foxnews.com, actionnews5.com, atlantanewsfirst.com, theguardian.com
- Tate Reeves65th governor of Mississippi