Montana Democratic Party chair quits, endorses independent over her own party's Senate nominee
Shannon O'Brien resigned effective immediately Monday, citing deep divisions over the Senate race and calling Democratic nominee Alani Bankhead unable to beat the Republican frontrunner.
The chair of the Montana Democratic Party resigned Monday and endorsed the independent Senate candidate over her own party's nominee, a dramatic public rupture that exposed months of internal warfare just weeks before Election Day.
Shannon O'Brien, who has served as state party chair since 2025, announced her resignation effective immediately in an op-ed published by MS NOW, then endorsed independent Seth Bodnar — a military veteran and former University of Montana president — over Democratic nominee Alani Bankhead.
The Montana Democratic Party is more divided than ever not because of our values but because of the race for the U.S. Senate.— Shannon O'Brien, outgoing Montana Democratic Party chair
The four-way race also includes Republican Kurt Alme, whom political analysts identify as the frontrunner, and Libertarian Kyle Austin. The candidates debated in Bozeman on Sunday, one day before O'Brien's announcement.
O'Brien framed her decision as a strategic imperative: she told the Daily Montanan she became convinced Bodnar is the only candidate capable of defeating Alme, and that keeping Bankhead as the left-of-center standard-bearer would hand the seat to the Republican.
Bankhead does not have the momentum, resources or will to win this race. For no apparent reason, she came out of the gate mudslinging at Bodnar, a decent human being, seemingly ignoring the Republican and her ideological opposite.— Shannon O'Brien, outgoing Montana Democratic Party chair
O'Brien also raised questions about Bankhead's commitment to abortion rights, support for working people, and views on poverty — issues she said will matter acutely because the next senator will likely vote on a Supreme Court nominee.
A central grievance in O'Brien's op-ed was the role of a conservative PAC in Bankhead's primary victory. More Jobs, Less Government — the same committee that spent $22 million backing Republican Sen. Tim Sheehy two years earlier — spent $700,000 promoting Bankhead and attacking her Democratic primary opponent Reilly Neill ahead of the June primary.
Democrats should ask themselves why Republicans so badly wanted her on the ballot.— Shannon O'Brien, outgoing Montana Democratic Party chair
O'Brien also wrote that Bankhead had not sought common ground with party leaders and had refused advice from experienced figures across the state, adding: 'She hasn't returned my calls since June.'
Bankhead's campaign fired back hard, framing O'Brien's resignation not as a sudden break but as the culmination of a months-long effort to undermine the party's chosen nominee.
Shannon didn't switch sides today. She's been working against the Democratic nominee since the summer. This summer she got a legal opinion, without a vote of her own board, on whether the party could refuse to replace me if I quit, and her own board members wanted her performance reviewed for it. Now she's using her exit to campaign for a man who never ran in our primary. Montana Democrats chose their nominee, and Montanans are voting right now.— Alani Bankhead, Democratic Senate nominee
The legal opinion episode, first reported by Montana Free Press in August, became a flashpoint: O'Brien shared an analysis of the party's options if Bankhead withdrew, the document leaked onto social media, and some Bankhead supporters at an unofficial board meeting called for O'Brien's removal. Campaign spokesperson Kaight Meyers argued that any call O'Brien placed to Bankhead amounted to contact with "a nominee she was working to remove from the ballot." A campaign spokesperson added that the record demonstrates Bankhead did communicate with the party in June and July.
Bankhead's campaign website describes her position on abortion as pro-choice, stating it 'distinguishes between matters of personal faith and the role of the government.' According to Bankhead, the sole "advice" she received from "the party's old guard" was to step aside — something she characterized as "a pressure campaign, not advice."
O'Brien is far from alone among prominent Montana Democrats in backing Bodnar. Her op-ed listed former Gov. Steve Bullock, former Sens. Jon Tester and Max Baucus, former state party executive director Nancy Keenan, and Carol and Whitney Williams among those who have already endorsed the independent. Former superintendent of public instruction Denise Juneau and her mother, former state lawmaker Carol Juneau, also publicly backed Bodnar last week, according to the Daily Montanan.
I'm deeply grateful to Shannon for her courage, and for her lifetime of service to Montana. Montanans of every political stripe are coming together in this race because they know what's at stake, and they're ready to send an independent senator to Washington who answers only to them.— Seth Bodnar, independent Senate candidate
The Montana Democratic Party moved quickly to project stability. It confirmed that Vice Chair Bruce Knutson of Helena has assumed the chairmanship effective immediately, and issued a statement saying the party's work 'continues with focus and determination.'
Our strength has never rested with one person.— Bruce Knutson, new Montana Democratic Party chair
O'Brien, for her part, insisted her move was not an abandonment of Democratic candidates more broadly. She said she still supports Democrats running for the state legislature and urged undecided Democratic voters to see a Bodnar vote as compatible with their values.
Maybe I have the opportunity to communicate to them that 'It's OK. You can be a good Democrat and you can vote for an independent who will fight for our values.'— Shannon O'Brien, outgoing Montana Democratic Party chair
Why it matters — With Republican Kurt Alme identified as the frontrunner, the defection of the state Democratic Party's own chair to an independent candidate could reshape which voters — and how many — consolidate behind Bodnar as the main alternative before ballots are counted.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Bankhead has not returned O'Brien's calls since June.
- There are 'real questions' about Bankhead's commitment to protecting abortion rights.
Sources differ on Whether O'Brien was already working against Bankhead before Monday's resignation: O'Brien says she resigned Monday and made the decision after months of failed outreach to Bankhead. (ms.now) vs Bankhead says O'Brien 'didn't switch sides today' and has been working against her since summer, citing the legal opinion obtained without a board vote. (montanafreepress.org)
Sources differ on Whether Bankhead communicated with O'Brien and the party after the primary: O'Brien says Bankhead has not returned her calls since June. (dailymontanan.com) vs Bankhead's campaign says the record shows she communicated with the party in June and July. (dailymontanan.com)
Reported by thehill.com, dailymontanan.com, montanafreepress.org, ms.now
- Jon TesterAmerican politician and farmer (born 1956)
- Max BaucusAmerican politician (born 1941)
- Steve BullockAmerican politician, lawyer, and the 24th Governor of Montana