A Grieving Mother Who Held Photos in the 'I Can Only Imagine' Video Now Asks: Do We Actually Long for Christ?
Nancy Guthrie appeared in the MercyMe music video holding portraits of two children she lost. Decades later, she's asking whether Christians have let the song's real subject — seeing Jesus — slip past them.
Wikimedia Commons
When a friend called to invite Nancy Guthrie, her husband, and their son to appear in a music video, the offer was not the kind anyone would want to accept. The video was to feature people holding photographs of deceased loved ones. Guthrie brought two large portraits — of her son Gabriel and her daughter Hope, each of whom had lived six months after being born with a rare metabolic disorder — and looked somberly into the camera. The song being filmed was 'I Can Only Imagine,' by a then-relatively unknown band called MercyMe.
That video went on to back one of the best-selling Christian singles ever recorded. 'I Can Only Imagine' has sold more than 2 million digital copies — the only song in the Christian music genre to go double platinum, according to Lifeway Research — crossed over to pop and country radio, and inspired a 2018 biopic that grossed $83 million. A sequel, centered on Christian singer Tim Timmons and the MercyMe song 'Even If,' is now in theaters.
But in a new essay published by Christianity Today, Guthrie turns the cultural moment into a pointed theological question. The song, she writes, is about the joy of beholding Jesus face to face. The video, she argues, suggested something different — that our longing for heaven is perhaps more about seeing deceased loved ones than about seeing Christ.
I have to give the video producers a bit of a break. How could anyone capture on video what it will be like when we finally see Jesus face to face? The song is exactly correct: for now, we can only imagine. But my question is 'Do we?' Is the promise of seeing Jesus face to face something we long for? Or has the difficulty of trying to envision it somehow sapped us of our desire?— Nancy Guthrie, author
Guthrie traces the theme of beholding God through Scripture — from Abraham, who received a promise and witnessed God pass through severed animals as a smoking firepot and flaming torch, to Moses, who asked to see God's glory and was shown only his back from a cleft in the rock, to David, who in Psalm 27 named gazing on the beauty of the Lord as the one thing he sought above protection from his enemies. Isaiah, she notes, saw the Lord 'high and exalted, seated on a throne' and wrote of a day when 'the glory of the Lord will be revealed, and all people will see it together.'
The New Testament, in her reading, brings that longing to a pivot point. When Jesus was transfigured on a mountain — his face shining like the sun — three disciples glimpsed the glory that had been veiled in flesh for 33 years. Then came the cross, the tomb, 40 days of resurrection appearances, and the ascension. 'A cloud hid him from their sight,' she writes, quoting Acts 1:9. For more than two millennia since, she argues, Christ has remained hidden from physical view.
For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face.— Paul, 1 Corinthians 13:12 (as quoted by Guthrie)
Guthrie's answer to her own question — how do believers behold Jesus now — is the Bible itself: in the shadows of the Old Testament and the substance of the New. The essay urges readers toward active, scriptural imagination of what seeing Christ will mean, rather than letting the difficulty of the vision drain the desire for it.
MercyMe frontman Bart Millard wrote 'I Can Only Imagine' alone on a tour bus at 2 a.m., composing the entire song in a matter of minutes after being struck by a phrase in a notebook. He has said the song was his way of coping with his father's death from cancer, choosing to focus on Christ rather than on loss. 'It was my way of coping,' Millard told World Vision. 'I'd rather be obsessed with that than an empty bedroom or him not being around.' The song was released on August 14, 2001 — 28 days before the September 11 attacks — and became a source of comfort for many Christians in the aftermath.
The music video that Guthrie appeared in was inspired by fans who brought photographs of deceased loved ones to MercyMe concerts, according to Lifeway Research. Several Christian music artists also appeared in the video holding images of people they had lost, including Michael Tait of dc Talk and Newsboys, Bob Herdman of Audio Adrenaline, and Tammy Trent.
The sequel film now in theaters, 'I Can Only Imagine 2,' centers on Tim Timmons, a Christian singer diagnosed with stage four cancer 25 years ago and given five years to live. He still has tumors on his liver today. Actor Milo Ventimiglia portrays Timmons, whose story intersects with Millard's own struggles at the height of MercyMe's arena-filling success.
My story isn't cancer; my story is finding joy through it. I think cancer is the dumbest story I know, but how we get through it is the beautiful story.— Tim Timmons, Christian singer
At the height of our career, when things seemed to be going great, is when we were struggling the most at home. I appreciate the fact that this movie tapped into that because it's real. If people can walk away saying … I'm not in this alone, then it's worth it.— Bart Millard, MercyMe lead singer
Guthrie's essay does not engage the sequel or the broader franchise. Her concern is narrower and more personal: that a song written as an act of grief-driven Christological focus has, in its cultural life, drifted toward something more comfortable — reunion with the dead — and that Christians may have followed it there without noticing.
Why it matters — Guthrie's essay — written from inside the cultural moment she critiques — raises a question that goes beyond one song: whether the Christian imagination of heaven has quietly recentered itself on human reunion rather than on the God the tradition says heaven is actually about.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The Christianity Today essay was published on October 14, 2026.
- Bart Millard's father died from cancer in 1991.
Reported by christianitytoday.com, maxm.news, telegraph.co.uk, research.lifeway.com, catholicregister.org
- Milo VentimigliaAmerican actor