Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Talarico debates Texas voters on CNN as Paxton skips — and early voting is days away

The Democratic Senate nominee faced a mixed crowd of Republicans, independents and Democrats in Fort Worth, casting himself as a moderate willing to break with his own party while Paxton declined every debate invitation.

How does this story make you feel?

With early voting just four days away, James Talarico sat across a table from skeptical Republicans, independents and Democrats in Fort Worth on Wednesday night — debating them one by one in a CNN and Jubilee town hall that his opponent, Ken Paxton, declined to attend. The 90-minute forum was Talarico's first major public appearance after more than a week off the campaign trail, and he used it to make the case that a Democrat can win Texas by refusing to act like one.

The audience of roughly 60 Texans — about 20 each from the Democratic, Republican and independent camps — grilled Talarico on abortion, faith, immigration, energy, the national debt, antisemitism and transgender surgeries for minors. Paxton, the Republican attorney general and nominee, was invited by CNN to participate but did not respond, host Erin Burnett told viewers at the outset. Talarico has now extended five debate invitations to Paxton through TV networks including Fox News; none has been accepted, according to the Texas Tribune.

I'm a proud Texas Democrat, but I already have a religion and I already have a sports team. So, I have no problem sharing hard truths with my party if it's what's best for Texas.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

The race is genuinely close. A Marist University poll released Wednesday showed Talarico leading Paxton narrowly, with 8 percent of Republican voters backing the Democrat, according to the Texas Tribune. Democrats have not won a U.S. Senate seat in Texas since the late 1980s, and flipping the seat would be a significant step toward the four-seat net gain the party needs to claim the Senate majority, according to CNN.

Talarico opened by addressing the disinformation campaign that surrounded his flu-related absence. Conservative influencers, amplified by Paxton and President Donald Trump, had falsely claimed he was receiving treatment at a mental health facility in Ohio. Talarico, who said he had never been to Ohio, called it an example of what he termed the 'rage economy.'

False claims got millions of views online and this is an example of what I call the 'rage economy.' Billionaires who own these platforms get rich. We all get angry and nobody's life gets any better. Conspiracy theories don't put food on the table, put gas in the tank, or improve our communities.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

The sharpest exchanges came on abortion and faith. Jodi Hunt, a self-described single-issue Catholic voter, asked Talarico how she could trust him to protect 'the most innocent among us.' Talarico described the Bible as silent on abortion; Hunt countered by quoting 'Thou shalt not kill.' Talarico did not try to win the argument — he tried to find a different one.

We may have different, moral conclusions when it comes to this particular ethical question, but we actually have the same public policy goal.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

He framed abortion as a public health problem rather than a culture war, arguing that sex education, access to contraception and universal healthcare — policies he said the Catholic Church has championed — demonstrably reduce the number of abortions. A Catholic professor who opened the forum as a single-issue voter on the issue of life had pressed him along similar lines, and Talarico offered her the same framework.

On faith itself, a devout small business owner challenged Talarico over a 2021 remark in which he described God as nonbinary. Talarico acknowledged the comment was 'provocative' and said he wanted to 'come clean,' but defended the underlying theology — that God cannot be defined through human categories — citing the late Pope Benedict and, in an unusual pairing, 'the late Charlie Kirk.' He added that he was receptive to feedback from Christians and affirmed, when asked directly, that he believes the Bible is the authoritative word of God.

Yes, I was doing it maybe in an annoying way. I can admit that.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

Talarico spent much of the night walking a line between his legislative record and the more centrist image he is projecting in the general election. He said he supports voter ID 'as long as it is fair,' called the national debt 'an emergency,' endorsed an 'all of the above' energy strategy that explicitly includes oil and gas, and declared himself 'a border security Democrat' who criticized the Biden administration's handling of the southern border. He flatly rejected abolishing Immigration and Customs Enforcement — a position he had expressed more ambiguously in a January primary debate — while arguing that under the Trump administration ICE had become a 'secret police force.'

Joe Biden failed us during his administration by not securing the border. … But now we've seen under this administration a different kind of extremism.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

On the economy, Talarico described himself as a capitalist who opposes 'crony capitalism' that 'taxes work more than it taxes wealth.' He said a 2020 comment in which he called capitalism an 'oppressive system' — made at a Sierra Club event — was a reference to that crony variety, not capitalism itself. Republicans have pushed back on several of his repositioned stances, noting for instance that he introduced a bill in the Texas Legislature that would have required the state to cut carbon emissions to 50 percent of 1990 levels by 2030.

On the deficit, Talarico pointed to closing 'billionaire tax loopholes,' ending what he called the 'disastrous war in Iran' — which he said costs $1 billion a day — and, in a line he acknowledged many Democrats won't say, cutting government inefficiency. He also reaffirmed his opposition to transgender surgeries for minors, a position he had stated in a recent Fox News interview.

Talarico closed with his most direct attack on Paxton, accusing him of increasing his net worth by $27 million, owning 15 homes, and taking bribes from wealthy special interests including half a million dollars from data center companies. Paxton, who was impeached by the Texas Legislature in 2023 on allegations including bribery and abuse of public trust and later acquitted, has also faced the recent leak of audio recordings from a closed-door meeting in which he was critical of his own party and campaign leaders in Washington. His wife of nearly four decades, Angela Paxton, filed for divorce in 2025 on 'biblical grounds,' citing adultery, according to the Guardian.

We have an opportunity in this race not just to defeat the most corrupt politician in Texas; we have an opportunity to defeat this entire corrupt system.— James Talarico, Texas Democratic Senate nominee

Republicans were unmoved. Chris Gustafson, a spokesperson for the Senate Leadership Fund, the Senate GOP-aligned super PAC, said Talarico 'couldn't defend his record of supporting the far-left's extreme agenda at the expense of Texas working families.' Paxton launched a new ad Wednesday touting his record of suing city governments over property taxes, pharmaceutical companies and Big Tech. Democratic strategist Paul Begala, speaking on CNN's post-town hall panel, offered a different read: 'This was a heat-seeking missile at Republican voters who supported John Cornyn but don't like Ken Paxton.'

Why it matters — Texas hasn't sent a Democrat to the U.S. Senate in nearly four decades, but a close race with early voting imminent means the outcome could help determine which party controls the Senate.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Talarico said 'the late Charlie Kirk' made a similar theological argument about God transcending human categories.
  • Paxton's net worth increased by $27 million, he owns 15 homes, and took $500,000 from data center companies.
  • The war in Iran costs $1 billion a day.
  • exact 47-45 poll margin

Sources differ on Talarico's consistency on energy and climate policy: Talarico says he has remained consistent throughout his career in supporting an 'all of the above' energy approach. (texastribune.org) vs Republicans note Talarico introduced a Texas Legislature bill that would have required cutting carbon emissions to 50% of 1990 levels by 2030 and 10% by 2050. (texastribune.org)

Sources differ on Talarico's position on ICE: Talarico at the town hall said he does not support abolishing ICE and never has. (cnn.com) vs In a January 2026 primary debate, Talarico said it was 'time to tear down this secret police force and replace it with an agency that actually is going to focus on public safety,' referring to ICE. (cnn.com)

Reported by theguardian.com, thehill.com, cnn.com, texastribune.org, dallasnews.com, washingtonexaminer.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email