Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

DOJ sues California after state refuses 48-hour demand to vet 20,000 alleged noncitizen voters

The Justice Department filed a federal lawsuit Thursday after California declined to review a list of more than 20,000 suspected noncitizen voters in under two days — a task the DOJ later admitted even it could not complete before Election Day.

How does this story make you feel?

After California declined to examine a federal list of more than 20,000 people the government alleges are noncitizens who received mail ballots before the November 3 election, the Justice Department filed suit Thursday — even as the same court filing conceded that vetting that many individuals before Election Day would overwhelm even federal investigators.

Acting Deputy Attorney General R. Trent McCotter sent letters Tuesday to California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan, directing them to examine the list within 48 hours, set aside returned ballots from anyone named on it, pause signature verification and tabulation of those ballots, and hold back any unsent ballots pending citizenship confirmation. The deadline expired Thursday morning at 9 a.m. PDT.

If you cannot implement this process by then, given the ongoing federal election, the United States will have no choice but to seek emergency relief.— R. Trent McCotter, Acting Deputy Attorney General

The DOJ made good on its threat, filing suit in federal court Thursday and disclosing for the first time that the list comprised more than 20,000 names. Federal officials are asking a judge to bar California from tallying mail ballots cast by anyone on the list until their citizenship has been confirmed.

But the lawsuit contained a striking admission. According to Democracy Docket, the DOJ wrote in its own complaint: "It is not practicable or feasible for the United States to investigate before the 2026 election concludes thousands, let alone tens of thousands, of individuals" identified as likely noncitizens — effectively conceding that the task it had just imposed on California in 48 hours was one the federal government itself could not complete in the same timeframe.

More remarkable still, despite failing to send the list of alleged non-citizens to my office, you demand that we request transmittal of the list, review and confirm the citizenship status of each of the approximately 20,000 individuals on the list on the eve of an election and within a mere 48 hours. This is an emergency of the DOJ's creation.— Shirley Weber, California Secretary of State

The math underscores Weber's point. According to Democracy Docket, even with a full 48 hours, reviewing 20,000 names would require processing roughly 417 voters every hour around the clock — or about 1,250 names per hour over two standard eight-hour workdays. The available time was even shorter: Los Angeles County said the materials did not arrive until the afternoon of October 13, leaving fewer hours still before the Thursday 9 a.m. deadline.

The list arrived on a USB drive whose handwritten password was included on an attached note. County officials chose not to open the drive, citing conflicts with their established data privacy and information-security protocols. County Registrar Dean Logan said any action affecting a voter's eligibility must rest on "verifiable information, not assertions of unconfirmed data matching," according to Democracy Docket.

The DOJ's lawsuit now portrays that refusal as evidence of unwillingness to cooperate, accusing Logan of demonstrating "a total lack of commitment" to election integrity and asserting that California "failed" to conduct the requested review. The complaint contends that California will be "knowingly" facilitating unlawful voting if it goes on processing those ballots without additional citizenship verification.

Verifying citizenship is not a simple database lookup. According to Democracy Docket, the DOJ's own complaint lays out a multi-step federal process that draws on records from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, third-party software, alien registration numbers, naturalization records, State Department files, Social Security Administration data, supervisor review, and further investigation by Homeland Security Investigations — and even after all of that, the government characterizes the people on its list as only "likely" noncitizens, not conclusively ineligible voters.

The confrontation is the latest in months of friction between the Trump administration and California over voter rolls. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin wrote to California officials in July asserting that the state had noncitizens on its voter rolls — an allegation Weber described as "still unsubstantiated" in her Wednesday statement. The DOJ has also sued 30 states that refused to hand over nonpublic voter data including Social Security numbers and dates of birth, losing 26 of those cases without winning one, according to Reuters.

In July of this year, President Trump and DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin made (still) unsubstantiated claims that California had 190,000 noncitizens on its voter rolls. Given the many high-profile examples of states purging U.S. citizens from their voter rolls based on DHS/SAVE data, SOS immediately requested written information about their methodology and data sources to back up their claims. They refused and provided California with nothing.— Shirley Weber, California Secretary of State

The administration's voter-roll scrutiny gained a legal foothold in late September, when the Supreme Court issued an emergency order allowing states to use a Department of Homeland Security program called SAVE — Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements — to verify voter eligibility. That order suspended a federal judge's June ruling, which had found the updated version of SAVE violated Americans' privacy rights and risked wrongful removal of eligible voters from the rolls.

Reuters reported that multiple studies have found voting by noncitizens to be rare. Software glitches and clerical errors may have placed more than 30,000 noncitizens on state voter rolls since 2000, but experts told Reuters those figures were far too small relative to the country's 170 million registered voters to swing any election.

California could prove consequential in deciding control of the U.S. House of Representatives, particularly after the state's voters approved a new congressional map that heavily favors Democrats. The case is now before a federal judge, with state officials citing privacy, legal, and verification concerns as it proceeds.

Why it matters — With the November 3 midterms days away and House control potentially hinging on California, a federal judge must now decide whether to block the counting of more than 20,000 mail ballots — a ruling that could set a precedent for how far the federal government can go in pressuring states to act on unverified voter lists under election-time deadlines.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • The Trump administration claimed California had 190,000 noncitizens on its voter rolls.

Sources differ on Whether California's failure to access the USB drive reflects unwillingness to cooperate or legitimate security and legal concerns: DOJ lawsuit accuses LA County Registrar Logan of showing 'a total lack of commitment' to election integrity by refusing to access the drive (democracydocket.com) vs LA County said accessing the drive would conflict with established data privacy and information-security protocols; Logan said eligibility actions must rest on 'verifiable information, not assertions of unconfirmed data matching' (democracydocket.com)

Reported by foxnews.com, sfchronicle.com, yahoo.com, washingtonpost.com, democracydocket.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email