Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Jackson tells Collins 'shut up' as Maine Senate debate finale turns personal

A protester's outburst over AI data centers set off the sharpest exchange yet in a race that could decide Senate control — and exposed just how raw the campaign has become.

How does this story make you feel?

The final debate between Republican Sen. Susan Collins and Democratic challenger Troy Jackson ended the way it had been heading for weeks: with the two candidates sounding, in the words of one account, like children arguing on a playground. When a protester stood up in the Husson University theater in Bangor on Thursday night and began shouting about AI data centers, Collins turned it into an accusation. Jackson turned that into an insult. And the race to determine one of the handful of Senate seats that will decide the majority got a little uglier.

About 20 minutes into the debate — the fourth and final meeting between the two candidates over two weeks, and the first held before a live audience of roughly 200 people — a young man rose and shouted about concerns over data centers. As security escorted him out, he added, "Thirty years for what?" — a reference to Collins' tenure in the Senate.

So this is obviously one of Troy's supporters.— Sen. Susan Collins
Oh, shut up. I don't even know that kid.— Troy Jackson
Oh, right.— Sen. Susan Collins

The Maine GOP posted on social media after the debate that Jackson's "shut up" comment was "unacceptable behavior." Jackson's campaign declined to comment on the exchange, according to the Seattle Times.

The moment crystallized the central tension of a race that has grown increasingly bitter. Jackson has spent four debates trying to fuse Collins to President Donald Trump, arguing that her independence is cosmetic. Collins has spent those same debates arguing that her seniority and bipartisan record make her irreplaceable for Maine.

I voted against my own party more often than any other senator on either side of the aisle. That is not something that Troy could ever say. He's going to be an automatic vote for the Democratic position, no matter what.— Sen. Susan Collins
The reality is that 100% of the time, when Donald Trump needs her, Susan Collins is going to be there. That has happened time and time again.— Troy Jackson

The sharpest test of Collins' independence came when a moderator asked her to name a time she had opposed Trump and it changed the outcome. She pointed to her effort to block Pete Hegseth's confirmation as Defense Secretary, saying she had organized Republican colleagues to vote no.

At one point, I had organized people to vote against Secretary Hegseth. As you undoubtedly have read, at the very last minute one of our Republicans changed his mind. Otherwise he would've been defeated for that job.— Sen. Susan Collins

Collins was referring to Sen. Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who later called his decision to vote for Hegseth the "biggest regret of my career," according to Axios. The moderator's response was blunt: "So that didn't change the outcome."

Collins also noted she voted against Trump's "big, beautiful" tax and spending law — though she acknowledged she did vote to allow the measure to proceed on the floor — and said she has voted nine times against the president on the Iran war. Jackson argued those were "managed votes" cast only when Collins already knew the outcome was decided, according to the Seattle Times.

The debate also turned personal on money and class. Jackson has made his refusal to accept corporate PAC donations a centerpiece of his campaign. Collins used her one direct question to press him on ads run in coordination with the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, which does accept corporate PAC money. Jackson said he does not control those ads, and while he acknowledged his campaign has received money from billionaires, he said it is powered by small-dollar donors.

That is accurate. But I haven't made any deals like Senator Collins has with those billionaires. I don't owe them any votes. I am going to tax those billionaires when I get to the US Senate. So, if they want to give me money during this campaign, I guess that's up to them.— Troy Jackson

Jackson then pressed Collins directly on whether her criticism of his qualifications reflected a broader attitude toward working-class voters.

Is it just me that you look down on, or is it working-class people overall?— Troy Jackson
Troy, I do not look down on you or on anyone. I grew up in Caribou. My first job was picking potatoes.— Sen. Susan Collins

The fundraising gap between the two candidates has narrowed dramatically. Jackson, a former state Senate president and logger who did not become the Democratic nominee until late July, raised $20.4 million in the third quarter — nearly four times Collins' $5.2 million haul over the same period, according to NBC News. Collins entered the quarter with a significant overall advantage, having raised more than $18 million by the end of June.

The race is rated a toss-up by the Fox News Power Rankings, the Cook Political Report, Inside Elections, and Sabato's Crystal Ball, according to Fox News. Collins, the only Republican senator seeking re-election in a state Trump lost in 2024, has a history of outperforming polls — six years ago she trailed Democratic challenger Sara Gideon before winning re-election by nearly nine points.

The overarching question the debate series left unanswered is how much Trump's standing in Maine will shape the November result. Trump has never won the state, and his approval ratings there have continued to fall, according to NBC News. Jackson is betting that dynamic dominates; Collins is betting her record of independence gives enough voters a reason to split their ticket.

Why it matters — Maine is one of a handful of Senate races that will determine which party controls the chamber, and the Collins-Jackson contest is rated a toss-up by every major forecaster.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Jackson campaigned alongside Sen. Bernie Sanders last weekend to build enthusiasm for his campaign.
  • Jackson has faced questions about ties to the Democratic Socialists of America and did not directly confirm or deny membership when pressed by debate moderators.

Sources differ on Whether Jackson's votes against Trump are genuine acts of independence: Collins says she is the most bipartisan senator and has broken with Trump on major votes including his tax law and the Iran war (nbcnews.com) vs Jackson says Collins' dissenting votes are 'managed votes' cast only when the outcome is already decided, and that Trump gets her vote 100% of the time when he truly needs it (seattletimes.com)

Reported by axios.com, nbcnews.com, foxnews.com, cnn.com, dailywire.com, seattletimes.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email