Winston silences critics and earns Giants' QB job — at least for now
Dismissed as washed up, Jameis Winston has the Giants alone atop the NFC East at 3-1-1, with coach John Harbaugh publicly backing him as starter and a strong second-half performance against Washington making the case.
When Jameis Winston signed with the New Orleans Saints in 2020 to back up Drew Brees, he never stopped believing he would be a full-time NFL starter again. 'I dreamt of it,' he said Wednesday. 'And now it's here.' Six years later, Winston is the starting quarterback of the first-place New York Giants — and, increasingly, the argument for keeping him there is getting harder to dismiss.
Winston stepped into the Giants' starting role after rookie Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury following Week 2. New York has gone 2-0-1 in his full starts, sitting alone atop the NFC East at 3-1-1 heading into Sunday's home game against the New Orleans Saints.
The most compelling exhibit came against Washington, where Winston trailed by 14 points and looked shaky in the first half — completing just 43.8% of his passes — before catching fire. He finished 33 of 54 for 326 yards and three touchdowns, completing 75% of his throws in the second half, according to SI. The game ended in a 27-27 tie after Washington burned its timeouts in overtime, but Winston had done his part.
I thought he was amazing in the second half. First half, he wasn't. He'd be the first to tell you that, but that's on everybody. I tell the guys, nothing good is all one person. We're all responsible for all the good, and we're all responsible for all the bad.— John Harbaugh, Giants head coach
SI reports that no Giants quarterback had thrown for 300-plus yards and three touchdowns while also rushing for at least 25 yards in the same game since 1950 — a feat Winston achieved against Washington. The last time a Giants signal-caller reached three or more touchdown passes in the second half before Winston was Eli Manning, on Sept. 24, 2017.
The improvement has not come in a vacuum. A key driver has been the emergence of tight end Isaiah Likely, who signed a three-year contract with the Giants this offseason after five seasons in Baltimore. Likely's 33 catches rank sixth in the NFL and he is tied for fourth with four touchdown receptions heading into Week 6 — both totals second among tight ends behind Arizona's Trey McBride, according to Newsday. He caught 11 passes for two touchdowns in the Washington tie, tying his career high in receptions.
In that game, man, Isaiah Likely, he was so unguardable. It was so easy to see and I'm happy that we were able to connect, him getting in the end zone.— Jameis Winston, Giants quarterback
Likely and wide receiver Malik Nabers have combined for 62.6% of Winston's targets, per Newsday. Nabers has 17 catches for 232 yards and two touchdowns over the past two weeks alone, after managing just 12 catches for 96 yards in his first three games returning from a torn ACL, according to Fox Sports.
The chemistry between Winston and Likely took time. Likely had spent most of training camp working with Dart, and the two acknowledged they were 'fighting like heck' to get on the same page. Newsday quoted Likely as saying, 'Me and Jax had early mornings, long nights, and that's just the same mantra I'm having with Jameis. I feel like we're taking strides.'
Former Ravens coach John Harbaugh, who coached Likely for all five of his Baltimore seasons, has seen the potential all along. Newsday quoted Harbaugh as saying, 'He made all these plays in college, but it just looked different.' Harbaugh went on to praise Likely's elusiveness against man and zone coverage, his feel for the game, his hands, and what he called an amazing catch radius. In Baltimore, Likely was the secondary option behind Mark Andrews. In New York, he is the No. 1 tight end.
The arrival of J.J. McCarthy — acquired from the Minnesota Vikings for a fifth-round pick — had fueled speculation that Winston's days as starter were numbered. McCarthy took five snaps in a package role against Washington. But Harbaugh has not wavered publicly on Winston, and Winston himself has not wavered privately.
I always focus on what my heart desires, and I say this over and over again, I desire to be the New York Football Giants Super Bowl-winning quarterback.— Jameis Winston, Giants quarterback
According to SI, Winston has handled the McCarthy chatter 'with aplomb,' joking publicly about what fans call 'the Jameis Winston experience' — a reference to his boom-or-bust reputation — while continuing to put in the work. SI observed that the side of Winston's work ethic unseen by those outside the building — his daily effort and openness to improvement — goes unnoticed by the public.
Harbaugh acknowledged the early awkwardness was structural as much as personal. Speaking to Fox Sports, he said the difficulty stemmed from stepping into an offense designed around a different quarterback. Harbaugh added that Winston pushed through the discomfort, maintained his confidence and composure, and found ways to win. He said the team is now beginning to adjust the game plan toward plays that suit Winston's strengths, with more relevant reps coming his way.
His opponents this week know what's coming. A scouting report that also serves as a character reference came from Saints defensive end Carl Granderson, who spent four seasons as Winston's teammate in New Orleans.
He's a leader. He's going to bring the energy. He's going to make sure the offense is ready to play. He's the hype man of their team, so we've just got to be ready to get after them and have even more energy than he's bringing.— Carl Granderson, Saints defensive end
The Saints come in at 1-4 after losing three straight, while the Giants are favored by the game's circumstances if not the oddsmakers — New Orleans is listed as 1.5-point favorites, according to Fox Sports. New York has won its first three home games; the last time the Giants won their first four home games was 2008, per Fox Sports.
One concern remains: turnovers. According to Fox Sports, Winston and running backs Cam Skattebo, Tyrone Tracy and Najee Harris have each coughed up a fumble, leaving New York with four lost fumbles — a total only five teams in the league have exceeded. Winston's interception rate has also been inconsistent. But since throwing his second pick against Arizona in Week 4, he has thrown four touchdowns in 1.5 games, per Newsday.
Why it matters — With the Giants in first place and a credible QB controversy brewing around J.J. McCarthy, Winston's performance over the next few weeks will determine whether New York is a genuine NFC East contender or a team waiting to hand the keys to its next option.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Harbaugh has publicly backed Winston as starter 'as long as I can see into the future'
Reported by yahoo.com, newsday.com, si.com, fantasyteamadvice.com, foxsports.com, newsylist.com
- Eli ManningAmerican football player (born 1981)
- Drew BreesAmerican football player and television analyst (born 1979)