Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Technology

Australia's 'algorithm off switch' bill lands in parliament — but critics say it flips too late

The Digital Duty of Care bill gives Australians aged 16+ the right to ditch algorithmically recommended feeds — but experts and campaigners warn the default still favours Big Tech.

How does this story make you feel?

Australia has introduced legislation to parliament requiring social media platforms to give users a genuine choice to turn off algorithmically recommended content — a reform the government is branding 'My Feed, My Way.' But the bill's arrival has been met with an immediate and pointed question: what good is an off switch for an algorithm that has already done its work?

Communications Minister Anika Wells introduced the Digital Duty of Care bill to the Federal Parliament, telling the National Press Club that the legislation would 'shift the burden from the shoulders of victims to the companies that are creating the environments where harms occur.' Under the bill, platforms such as Meta and TikTok must inform users aged 16 and over that they may opt out of algorithm-driven feeds in favour of seeing only content from accounts they actively follow, generally arranged in chronological order. Platforms face fines of up to A$109.2 million for non-compliance, and would have 12 months from enactment to make the necessary changes.

Australia's digital duty of care will set basic safety standards for the online services we use every day, just like we have in every other industry.— Anika Wells, Communications Minister

The bill goes beyond the algorithm opt-out. Platforms — including online games, apps and AI chatbots — would be required to shield users under 18 from a defined list of harmful content: pornography; material that promotes or encourages eating disorders; misogynistic content; content glorifying crime or life-endangering stunts; and content causing serious mental health distress, including abuse and bullying. The eSafety Commissioner gains new powers to issue removal notices to platforms, which must also document what steps they have taken to address online harms. A specific carve-out for professional news material was added to the final bill after an earlier draft drew concern that public-interest journalism could be inadvertently caught by content-removal provisions.

At the United Nations General Assembly, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is expected to highlight the plans. He has framed the legislation in blunt terms of power.

This is not about giving government control, it is about giving people control. We're taking power from big global tech companies and giving it to ordinary Australians.— Anthony Albanese, Prime Minister

The government has also built specific anti-evasion requirements into the opt-out design, responding directly to what happened in Europe. Three years ago, after the EU required platforms to offer an opt-out feed, Meta placed the option deep within its menus and reverted to the algorithmic feed each time a user closed the app — conduct that, according to the Sydney Morning Herald, prompted a lawsuit in the Netherlands and a regulatory investigation in Ireland. Wells said the Australian bill requires companies to keep the user's choice in place every time the app is opened, not make the non-algorithmic feed harder to navigate, and make the opt-out tool easy to use and prominently available.

Wells said the principles will address some of the malicious compliance that the companies have participated in overseas.

Yet the bill's central design choice — opt-out rather than opt-in — is where its most substantive critics focus. Consent campaigner Chanel Contos, founder of Teach Us Consent, has spent months arguing for the opposite approach: making the default feed chronological, with users required to actively choose the algorithmic version. To illustrate the practical problem underpinning her argument, the SMH ran a real experiment in which a fake profile for a 17-year-old boy was served manosphere content on TikTok within 13 minutes. By the time a user sees the off switch, the algorithm may have already shaped what they follow.

Contos described the scenario of a 16-year-old boy who, after a year of algorithmically recommended gym content, hustle culture and misogynistic material, now follows 40 such accounts. Under 'My Feed, My Way,' he opts out — and still sees those 40 accounts in a row. In the SMH's framing, the algorithm has already won before he's seen the off switch. At the National Press Club, Contos cited research finding that men who hold the attitudes promoted by manosphere content are 17 times more likely to have hit a partner.

This reform sends the right message to Big Tech. You cannot introduce harmful features into our digital lives without asking for our consent first.— Chanel Contos, founder, Teach Us Consent

A second blind spot identified by critics is advertising. Recommendation systems and ad-targeting systems are separate. Because the bill as drafted says nothing about how paid content is ranked or targeted, a user who opts out of a personalised content feed can still be profiled and sold to advertisers. The EU barred personalised advertising to users aged 13 to 17; Australia's draft does not address that issue, according to the SMH.

Tech policy researchers have also pushed back on the framing of the reform itself. In Tech Policy Press, analysts made the case that there is no single algorithm that can be switched on or off — that platforms deploy algorithmic systems across content moderation, spam detection, search ranking, advertising and safety, not just feed recommendations. Even a chronological feed does not remove algorithmic mediation, since rules still govern which content from a potentially vast pool of material is included, excluded and ordered. The researchers pointed to YouTube's long-running experiment optimising its recommender system specifically for the wellbeing of minors as an example of what algorithmic design oriented toward user benefit — rather than engagement maximisation — can look like.

Rather than responding directly to Wells' announcement, Meta said there was no single 'algorithm' that could simply be switched off; the company argued its ranking systems serve useful purposes such as detecting abuse and demoting low-quality content, and it pointed to Instagram's existing 'Following' and 'Favourites' feeds. DIGI, the lobby group representing Meta, Snapchat and Google, said it 'supports an approach that gives people meaningful choice and control over the content they see, while managing safety risks.'

The bill's parliamentary path is uncertain. The Labor government needs either the Greens or the Coalition to pass it through the Senate. The Greens communications spokesperson Sarah Hanson-Young supports the direction but wants a lower threshold for harm and penalties calculated as a percentage of global revenue rather than a fixed cap. She also warned that an opt-out model gives tech companies room to manoeuvre, saying: 'They've got a lot of money, and we know that big tech will be looking for every crack, every possible workaround.' The Greens want the algorithm off by default. The opposition Liberals and Nationals have flagged opposition, with Opposition Leader Angus Taylor calling the bill 'a blank cheque for political censorship.' The Nationals leader Matt Canavan said the government should focus on making the existing under-16 social media ban work instead. Wells said she is negotiating in good faith with the Greens and is considering their request to allow individuals to sue platforms for harm they have experienced. If the Greens come on board, the bill could pass before the end of the year, after which a 12-month transition period would begin.

There is a global reckoning coming for big tech. And it started here in Australia, with the introduction of our world-leading social media minimum age laws.— Anika Wells, Communications Minister

Why it matters — The bill would be the first law to require social media platforms to offer Australians a genuine, persistent choice over whether an algorithm shapes what they see — but its design and scope will determine whether it changes user experience in practice or becomes another workaround for platforms to navigate.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Expert research showed the under-16 social media ban put in place in Australia in December is only partly effective.
  • exact bill title including '2026'
  • framing of Wells statement on malicious compliance as a direct quote

Sources differ on Whether an opt-out or opt-in default is the right design for the algorithm switch: Opt-out is sufficient if anti-evasion rules are enforced; government's chosen approach. (nine.com.au) vs Opt-in (algorithm off by default) is needed to protect users before the algorithm shapes their behaviour; Greens and Chanel Contos position. (theguardian.com) vs Neither option addresses the core problem, which is what algorithms are optimised for, not their existence. (techpolicy.press)

Sources differ on Whether a single 'algorithm' can meaningfully be switched off: Platforms use multiple algorithmic systems for safety, moderation, ads and ranking — a simple on/off switch misrepresents how they work. (techpolicy.press) vs Meta says there is no single algorithm that can simply be switched off and that its ranking systems serve safety functions. (smh.com.au) vs The government frames the opt-out as a meaningful transfer of control to users. (theguardian.com)

Reported by com.au, nine.com.au, mumbrella.com.au, nytimes.com, theguardian.com, smh.com.au, techpolicy.press, minister.infrastructure.gov.au

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email