Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Politics

Sullivan and Peltola trade personal attacks in toss-up Alaska Senate debate

The incumbent Republican and his Democratic challenger clashed over the Iran war, soaring energy costs, and each other's records in a race that could tip Senate control.

How does this story make you feel?

Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan and Democratic challenger Mary Peltola came close to getting their microphones cut off Thursday night as they traded accusations of lying, personal misconduct, and political hypocrisy in an hourlong Alaska Senate debate that could help determine which party controls the chamber in November.

The debate, hosted by Alaska Public Media, KTOO, and Alaska's News Source, covered the ongoing U.S. military conflict in Iran, rising energy and consumer prices, healthcare, and oil policy — but the sharpest exchanges were personal. NBC News rates the race a toss-up, and Democrats have identified the seat as one of five potential pickup opportunities despite Donald Trump carrying Alaska by double digits in 2024.

The Iran war threaded through nearly every exchange. The eight-month-old conflict has disrupted oil and gas shipments through the Strait of Hormuz, and Peltola argued that disruption is the direct cause of Alaskans' pain at the pump. Sullivan acknowledged that 'energy costs from this war are too high,' but said the solution was more domestic Alaskan energy production, not ending the conflict on unfavorable terms.

The largest state sponsor of terrorism should not have nuclear weapons. But it needs to end soon. The energy costs from this war are too high.— Dan Sullivan, Republican incumbent

Peltola pressed Sullivan on his voting record, noting he has voted against War Powers Act resolutions to end or limit U.S. military involvement in Iran, according to the Alaska Dispatch News. She said the conflict shows no sign of resolution.

There does not appear to be a peace deal on the horizon, and I think it's so important that our military be removed and protected.— Mary Peltola, Democratic challenger

When a reporter asked Sullivan directly what Congress could do to quickly end the war, he did not offer a specific answer, according to ADN. 'We need to open the Strait of Hormuz, make sure Iran does not get a nuclear weapon,' he said.

The personal attacks began within minutes. Sullivan accused Peltola of voting against pay raises for troops 'because she wanted more transgender surgeries' for them. Peltola called that a lie and said she had voted for troop pay raises multiple times, explaining that one 'no' vote was cast because the defense bill contained language that would have blocked soldiers from accessing healthcare if stationed in states that restricted women's reproductive care. Two of her sons, she said, had served in the military.

Dan, you should be ashamed of yourself for propagating these lies.— Mary Peltola, Democratic challenger

Sullivan then turned to Peltola's post-congressional career, criticizing her for pursuing lobbying work after losing Alaska's at-large House seat to Republican Nick Begich in early 2025.

Mary, you're walking through the revolving door so much you must be getting dizzy up here.— Dan Sullivan, Republican incumbent

Peltola countered by pointing to Sullivan's rising net worth over his 12 years in the Senate.

Dan's been in D.C. for 12 years and has gotten richer every single one of those years.— Mary Peltola, Democratic challenger

Sullivan escalated further, citing a recent New York Times report on turmoil in Peltola's congressional office, including allegations of angry outbursts, offensive language, and staff departures.

Twenty-five staffers quit on Mary Peltola because she abused them physically and emotionally, and then she slanders every other group, African Americans, special needs individuals. It is a character flaw on my opponent.— Dan Sullivan, Republican incumbent

Asked directly about the Times reporting, Peltola declined to engage with the specifics.

I don't think this election is about me on my worst day.— Mary Peltola, Democratic challenger

She called the stories 'allegations' and 'mass exaggerations of the truth,' according to NBC News.

Tension also surfaced over debate conduct. Sullivan questioned whether Peltola had received the questions in advance after watching her read from prepared notes. Moderator Lori Townsend of Alaska Public Media said neither candidate had been given questions beforehand. Sullivan accepted that answer but told reporters afterward, 'You can't cue card your way to the U.S. Senate,' according to ADN.

On a question about the Trump administration's announcement that it would allow Russian diesel fuel onto the global market, Sullivan broke with the White House — a move other Republicans in competitive races have also made in recent debates, according to NBC News.

I just led the effort on a Russia sanctions act that passed the Congress, so I'm opposed to that.— Dan Sullivan, Republican incumbent

Sullivan also distanced himself from the Pentagon's since-withdrawn plan to livestream the execution of convicted terrorist Nidal Hasan, saying doing so would 'create more terrorists.'

On energy, Sullivan touted his record of expanding resource development in Alaska, including drilling opportunities in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. Peltola said she has been 'a strong supporter of drilling in Alaska' and pointed to her role in helping advance ConocoPhillips' Willow oil field project under former President Joe Biden.

The money gap in this race runs in Peltola's favor. Her campaign has reported $32.6 million in total receipts, including roughly $29 million from individuals and $3.3 million from political committees, with $3.2 million cash on hand. Sullivan's campaign reported $13.9 million in total receipts — $6.9 million from individuals and $6.5 million from political committees — with about $5 million cash on hand, according to ADN. Outside groups have added millions more in independent expenditures for both sides.

Despite the financial disadvantage, Sullivan enters November with structural advantages. Alaska last sent a Democrat to the Senate in 2008, when Mark Begich defeated incumbent Republican Ted Stevens. Trump carried the state by double digits in 2024. But Peltola finished ahead of Sullivan by eight points in August's all-party primary, with 49.5% of the vote to his 41.4%. A second candidate named Dan Sullivan — who has denied being a deliberate ploy to confuse voters — received 2.5% and will appear on the November ballot but did not participate in Thursday's debate.

The debate is one of the final major events before the November election. Trump visited Wasilla days earlier to rally for Sullivan, and Vice President JD Vance visited Fairbanks earlier this month — yet Trump's name was largely absent from Thursday's debate floor, a departure from the tone of other high-profile Senate contests this cycle, according to NBC News.

Why it matters — The Alaska Senate race is a toss-up that could determine which party controls the Senate, making this debate a window into the arguments that will drive one of the most closely watched elections of the 2026 midterms.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Twenty-five staffers quit Peltola's congressional office due to physical and emotional abuse, and she made offensive remarks about African Americans and special needs individuals.
  • Peltola received the debate questions in advance.
  • specific statewide gas price of $4.94 per gallon
  • exact count of 14 votes against War Powers resolutions
  • specific November 3 election date

Sources differ on Peltola's votes on troop pay raises: Peltola voted against pay raises for troops to prioritize transgender surgeries. (adn.com (Sullivan's claim)) vs Peltola voted for troop pay raises multiple times; one 'no' vote was cast because the bill contained language restricting soldier healthcare in certain states. (adn.com (Peltola's response))

Sources differ on Peltola's record on Alaska energy development: Peltola voted against producing more Alaskan energy while in Congress. (adn.com (Sullivan's claim)) vs Peltola has been a strong supporter of drilling in Alaska and helped advance the Willow oil field project. (adn.com (Peltola's claim))

Reported by nbcnews.com, adn.com, thecentersquare.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email