Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Sports

NCAA sues Ohio governor, calling his fifth-year eligibility order an unconstitutional 'hall pass'

Three days after Gov. Mike DeWine signed an executive order letting Ohio schools ignore the NCAA's new eligibility rule, the governing body filed a federal lawsuit — a move its president called an 'extraordinary step.'

How does this story make you feel?

The NCAA filed a federal lawsuit Friday against Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine, three days after he signed an executive order allowing the state's public and private universities to let athletes who graduated from high school in 2022 play a fifth year of college sports — in direct defiance of the organization's new eligibility rule.

The 41-page complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, argues DeWine's order violates the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution by giving Ohio schools an unfair competitive advantage over out-of-state rivals, infringes the First Amendment by shielding schools that break NCAA rules while remaining members, and exceeds the governor's authority under Ohio state law. The NCAA is seeking both declaratory and injunctive relief.

This Complaint seeks to halt a misguided attempt to give Ohio colleges and universities an unfair, unprecedented and unwarranted competitive advantage in stadiums and arenas throughout the country. College sports, like all sports, depend on participants following the rules. [DeWine] is attempting to give Ohio institutions a hall pass to break the rules.— NCAA, court filing

NCAA President Charlie Baker, writing to member schools, described the lawsuit as an 'extraordinary step' made necessary by DeWine's order. Baker had already pushed back on the order the day it was signed, arguing that a single elected official cannot unilaterally rewrite eligibility rules for the benefit of his own state's schools.

One elected official seeking to make their own rules for their own schools' advantage is a terrible way to run athletic competitions.— Charlie Baker, NCAA President

According to CBS Sports, this is the first time in collegiate sports history that the NCAA has filed a lawsuit against a sitting state governor — though the organization has done so before. The Boston Globe noted the NCAA won a case in the early 1990s against then-Nevada Gov. Bob Miller in a dispute over a state law that sought to compel the NCAA to extend greater due process protections during enforcement proceedings.

The eligibility rule at the center of the dispute was passed in June. Known as the 'five-for-five' or age-based model, it grants a fifth year of eligibility to a new class of athletes but excludes those from the high school Class of 2022 who have already played four seasons. The NCAA has said the decision was a difficult tradeoff — extending the benefit to the Class of 2022 would displace incoming recruits who have been waiting for their opportunity to compete.

A two-term Republican and former state attorney general barred by term limits from seeking re-election this fall, DeWine cast his order as a question of fairness. "When the rules change, fairness has to remain part of the equation," he said in a statement. "We want Ohio's student-athletes to have the same opportunity as student-athletes in other states," he added. His office declined to comment on the litigation after the lawsuit was filed.

Lt. Gov. Jim Tressel, who won championships as a coach at Ohio State and Youngstown State, also backed the order. All eight of Ohio's Division I programs — among them No. 4 Ohio State of the Big Ten, Cincinnati of the Big 12, and six Mid-American Conference schools — stayed publicly silent on DeWine's order, though CBS Sports reported all eight reportedly backed it.

The lawsuit lands in the middle of an already chaotic legal landscape. Multiple state and federal courts have been issuing conflicting rulings on the eligibility question. While the NCAA has prevailed in Kentucky, Ohio, and Arizona, defeats in other jurisdictions have set off additional rounds of litigation. In the federal case Wisne v. NCAA, a lower-court judge initially granted all 2022 Class athletes a fifth year; an appeals court blocked that ruling, and a three-judge panel of the U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver heard arguments but did not immediately rule.

In Ohio specifically, the state Supreme Court has said it will weigh in on the legality of DeWine's executive order. As part of that process, it paused an appeals court ruling that had declared the Class of 2022 athletes ineligible, and ordered both sides to file briefs by Monday in the case of basketball player Filip Borovicanin, who played in an exhibition game against Tennessee on Thursday night after DeWine's order temporarily restored his eligibility. Baker said the NCAA does not believe the Ohio Supreme Court's action declared those players immediately eligible to compete.

A separate case in Louisiana involves basketball player RJ Luis, who was granted eligibility by a court but has not been placed on LSU's roster. The Southeastern Conference has sued LSU in an attempt to force the school to comply with its own policy barring Luis from playing.

From a coach's standpoint, every time the NCAA says something, we all shrug our shoulders and say, 'Is that going to stand up? Is that a rule?' We don't think there are rules right now. That's why we want guardrails, we want Congress to act, we want the chaos to end. Because nobody knows what the crap is going on. No one.— Pat Kelsey, Louisville basketball coach
This whole thing has become comical.— Danny White, Athletic Director, University of Tennessee

The NCAA and Baker have repeatedly called on Congress to pass the Protect College Sports Act, a bipartisan bill that has already cleared the Senate and would establish federal guardrails limiting the kinds of lawsuits that have destabilized eligibility rules. The bill's fate in the House remains uncertain. Baker wrote that "Congress must pass the PCSA as soon as possible," calling the situation "precisely" the reason for urgency.

The situation echoes California's 2019 move to allow name, image and likeness compensation through state law — a decision other states rapidly followed, ultimately forcing the NCAA to permit NIL payments nationwide. Attorneys representing athletes in the Ohio case have already suggested other governors could sign similar orders, and sources told OutKick that additional executive orders from other states could come as soon as next week.

Why it matters — With the college sports season already underway, the lawsuit could determine whether a patchwork of state executive orders and court rulings — rather than a single national standard — ends up deciding which athletes can play and for which schools.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Other governors could sign similar executive orders as soon as next week.
  • All eight Ohio Division I programs backed DeWine's executive order.

Sources differ on Whether the Ohio Supreme Court's order in Borovicanin reinstated player eligibility: The Ohio Supreme Court's stay of the mandate did not reinstate the injunction; players are not immediately eligible. (ncaa.org) vs Borovicanin played in an exhibition game after DeWine's order, suggesting his school read the situation as restoring eligibility. (bostonglobe.com)

Reported by yahoo.com, foxnews.com, cbssports.com, ncaa.org, bostonglobe.com, nytimes.com, foxsports.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email