Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
World

Ukraine's critical gaps: what happens if the US walks away entirely

Kyiv has reduced its reliance on Washington, but analysts say the remaining dependence — in missile early warning, Starlink, and air defense — is concentrated exactly where it hurts most.

How does this story make you feel?

A single disruption to a satellite communications service this week made the stakes concrete: a Ukrainian drone unit lost control of an aircraft mid-flight, unable to destroy a Russian weapons outpost, after access to Starshield — the military version of SpaceX's Starlink — was throttled. It was a small operational failure with a large strategic message: Ukraine's dependence on the United States, though reduced since 2022, is now concentrated in the areas it can least afford to lose.

The disruption came as President Donald Trump demanded Ukraine halt strikes on Russian oil facilities and called on President Volodymyr Zelensky to step down. Many observers regard the Starshield restriction as payback after Zelensky objected to Trump's lifting of sanctions on Russian diesel imports — a decision Trump described as a way to keep domestic prices stable ahead of US midterm elections.

We will not, in any way, lose our independent country. Yes, we will have huge problems with how to push Putin to diplomatic way of ending this war, to negotiations. This is the problem.— Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukrainian President

Speaking to journalist Piers Morgan, Zelensky confirmed Ukraine could 'of course' win the war, but acknowledged that doing so without American support on Kyiv's side would be 'difficult.' He said a way out could only be found through negotiations, and that pushing Putin toward talks was significantly harder without Washington's weight behind Ukraine.

I think his advisors are wrong. I don't know who is pushing him not to the right side. This is not the right side of history.— Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukrainian President

Zelensky also said he felt 'betrayed' after Trump announced an energy 'truce' and struck a deal with Putin on diesel fuel — and noted that despite Trump's announcement of an energy ceasefire on October 11, Russia has continued striking Ukraine's civilian energy infrastructure.

The Wall Street Journal's accounting of Ukraine's vulnerabilities, reported Thursday, is stark. Developed across decades of Cold War rivalry with the Soviet Union, the US ballistic missile early warning system identifies heat signatures at the moment of launch and follows missiles through a worldwide radar network. It is essential both for targeting incoming Russian missiles and for issuing civilian evacuation alerts. European allies have stepped up satellite and aerial intelligence, but the Journal reported that the precision and coverage falls clearly short of what the US network provides. There is no substitute.

Ukraine's air defense against ballistic missiles is almost entirely dependent on the Patriot system, manufactured by US defense contractor Lockheed Martin. Patriot interceptor missiles are reported to be running low, and while the Franco-Italian SAMP/T NG system made by Eurosam is being transferred to Ukraine, analysts say it cannot immediately close the gap. As for the F-16 fighter jets Ukraine received from European countries, their continued operation depends on American spare parts, software updates, and weapons systems — meaning a full US cutoff would render them combat-ineffective.

According to the Journal, Europe and Canada are working on satellite communications systems with capabilities comparable to Starlink's, though the earliest those systems could be deployed in the field is 2028.

Ukraine has not been passive. Rather than relying on a single source, its intelligence services have assembled their own picture of Russian infrastructure by combining allied intelligence with data from their own drones, human sources, and closed-circuit television footage obtained by hacking into Russian networks. According to the Journal, a European military official said US technology and intelligence had supplied precise targeting data — altitude information included — enabling Ukraine to sharpen its strike planning, and that details about vulnerabilities in Russia's air defense network had proven especially useful for guiding drones and missiles past interception.

The remaining dependence is concentrated in critical areas — and that is the problem.— Franz-Stefan Gady, military analyst and head of Gady Consulting

The Vienna-based Gady conceded that, compared with the opening phase of the war in 2022, Ukraine had made real progress in reducing its dependence on the United States — yet he argued that the remaining dependence being concentrated in the most critical systems was exactly what made the present situation so perilous.

On Thursday, Zelensky was in Brussels for bilateral meetings with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, French President Emmanuel Macron, Belgian Prime Minister Bart De Wever, and Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen. A further round of talks with a large number of EU leaders is set for Friday. The flurry of diplomacy is widely interpreted as an attempt to draw greater military and financial commitment from Europe at a time when relations with Washington are under strain.

Why it matters — The specific systems Ukraine cannot replace — missile early warning, Starlink, Patriot air defense — are the same ones now being used as leverage by Washington, meaning the gap between political pressure and battlefield consequence has never been narrower.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • The Starshield throttling is widely seen as retaliation for Zelensky's pushback against Trump lifting sanctions on Russian diesel imports.
  • Ukraine's Patriot interceptor missiles are running low.

Reported by thehill.com, firstpost.com, news.liga.net, biz.heraldcorp.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email