Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
U.S.

Arizona joins Nevada's lawsuit to block federal Colorado River cuts that spare Upper Basin states

Governor Katie Hobbs intervened in Nevada's suit Friday, arguing the Interior Department's plan dumps up to 3 million acre-feet in cuts on three states while letting four others off the hook entirely.

How does this story make you feel?

Ken Lund from Reno, Nevada, USA / Wikimedia Commons

Arizona drew a legal line in the sand Friday, intervening in Nevada's federal lawsuit against the Department of the Interior over Colorado River water cuts that could strip the state of 760,000 acre-feet of water a year — roughly 27 percent of its full Colorado River allocation — while requiring nothing from the four Upper Basin states upstream.

We are drawing a line in the sand. I am taking this legal action alongside Nevada because the federal government refuses to hold the Upper Basin accountable for the water deliveries they owe Arizona, and is threatening to force draconian cuts that go well beyond the Lower Basin Agreement.— Katie Hobbs, Arizona Governor

The Interior Department released its Record of Decision on August 21, setting operating guidelines for 2027 and 2028 while states return to the table to negotiate a longer, decade-scale solution. Under those guidelines, the three Lower Basin states — Arizona, California and Nevada — could collectively face cuts of up to 3 million acre-feet per year. The four Upper Basin states — Utah, Colorado, New Mexico and Wyoming — face only voluntary conservation goals, with no mandatory reductions.

Even within the Lower Basin, the burden falls unevenly. Arizona is expected to absorb 61 percent of the cuts, California 35 percent and Nevada just 4 percent, according to the Deseret News. For Arizona, that means the Central Arizona Project — the canal system delivering Colorado River water to the Phoenix and Tucson areas — faces a 50 percent cut under the federal plan, according to azfamily.com.

Such reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project as well as many of our on-river communities. It would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement. Arizona believes that taking its action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users.— Tom Buschatzke, Director, Arizona Department of Water Resources

Arizona's move is formally a motion to intervene in the existing Nevada complaint rather than a new lawsuit. The Nevada suit — brought by the Colorado River Commission of Nevada and the Southern Nevada Water Authority — asks a court to halt implementation of the federal decision until its "legal and technical shortcomings are resolved," according to the Deseret News. Arizona's intervention means the state can shape any legal outcome and challenge what it calls the federal plan's failure to require Upper Basin deliveries to Lake Mead.

Intervention in the Nevada lawsuit is necessary at this time for Arizona to protect its legal rights to Colorado River water while preserving a path forward to achieving a collaborative outcome with California and Nevada to protect the Colorado River system.— Tom Buschatzke, Director, Arizona Department of Water Resources

Central to Arizona's legal argument is the claim that the federal government is ignoring what it calls the "law of the river" — the body of compacts, court decisions and federal statutes governing the Colorado — by failing to enforce Upper Basin delivery obligations to Lake Mead. Buschatzke told the Deseret News that Arizona and the Upper Basin states have not yet begun negotiations since the August decision was released.

The backdrop is a river system under severe strain. Lake Mead, which straddles Arizona and Nevada, has dropped about 30 percent in a single year, according to the Deseret News. Lake Powell, sitting between Utah and Arizona, is losing 3 to 4 feet a month and risks losing the ability to generate electricity. Both reservoirs have fallen to historically low levels due to overuse and a changing climate, according to The Guardian. The worst-case scenario — reservoirs dropping so low the river can no longer flow downstream, a condition known as deadpool — has driven the urgency behind years of negotiations that repeatedly missed consensus deadlines before the federal government stepped in.

The states had been trying to reach their own agreement. A Lower Basin deal struck in May between Arizona, California and Nevada committed the three states to conserve more than 3.2 million acre-feet combined through 2028 — a voluntary pact that Arizona says the federal plan effectively overrides. Without that agreement, Hobbs said Arizona faced a 77 percent cut to its Colorado River water, which she called "devastating." The Interior Department did not adopt the Lower Basin Agreement when it released its plan in August, according to azfamily.com.

Arizona has always been willing to do our part to protect the Colorado River, but we will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses.— Katie Hobbs, Arizona Governor

California has not joined the litigation. Hobbs told azfamily.com the lawsuit "will protect this Lower Basin agreement, but also it pushes back on the parts of the Record of Decision that we don't like." Buschatzke framed the legal action as a way to keep Arizona at the negotiating table regardless of how the court case develops: "Things may start moving in court on that Nevada complaint, and we have to have a seat at that table to be able to give Arizona's viewpoint," he told the Deseret News. An Interior Department spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment, according to The Guardian.

Why it matters — If the federal cuts hold without legal challenge, Arizona's main water delivery system serving millions of Phoenix and Tucson residents could lose half its Colorado River supply within two years — a scale of reduction that state officials say would devastate farms, businesses and communities across the state.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Some experts say the 1922 Colorado River Compact was based on flawed math and there was never 18 million acre-feet of water to divide in the first place.

Reported by theguardian.com, deseret.com, azgovernor.gov, azfamily.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email