DOJ demands California block 20,000 ballots; state AG calls it 'weaponizing the law'
With the November 3 midterms days away, the Trump administration is suing California to stop counting votes from a list of suspected noncitizens — a list state officials say is riddled with errors.
Less than two weeks before California's November 3 midterm elections, the Trump administration sent state election officials a thumb drive — hand-scrawled password on a sticky note — containing the names of roughly 20,000 people it called 'likely noncitizens' registered to vote, and gave them 48 hours to validate the list and set those ballots aside. California declined. Now the two sides are headed to a federal appeals court.
The Justice Department responded by suing California in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, seeking a temporary restraining order to immediately block those ballots from being counted. In its court filing, the DOJ charged that California election officials were "knowingly aiding noncitizens who want to illegally vote" and described its earlier 48-hour deadline as a "modest request." An appeals court is scheduled to take up the matter on Tuesday.
It is once again the United States Department of Justice politicizing and weaponizing the law to attack its enemies, and it is completely improper.— Rob Bonta, California Attorney General
Bonta has also challenged the evidentiary basis of the federal demands. At a recent press conference he said the Justice Department provided no explanation for why the flagged individuals were considered ineligible.
All they provided was a list of people and nothing about why they're purportedly ineligible. If they have such information, we would be happy to review it, but they've provided none.— Rob Bonta, California Attorney General
On Monday, the administration moved to show the court it had grounds to act: federal prosecutors announced charges against 28 people from across California for illegally registering to vote or casting ballots in federal elections. Eleven had been arrested by Monday morning; the other 17, authorities said, 'will be in custody in the near future,' according to the Los Angeles Times. All 28 are lawful permanent residents — people with legal status in the United States but who are not citizens authorized to vote. None are undocumented immigrants.
This Department of Justice will not look the other way while non-citizens vote in federal elections. Unfortunately, the same can't be said for California and L.A. County.— Trent McCotter, Acting Deputy Attorney General
State and local officials said the 28 arrests, far from proving widespread fraud, actually undercut the federal case. Attorney General Bonta's office said the 28 individuals charged amount to "a tiny fraction" of California's 23 million registered voters, and that the administration had yet to produce "evidence of widespread voter fraud, even if the allegations are true," the Los Angeles Times reported. David Becker, executive director of the nonpartisan Center for Election Innovation & Research, calculated that the 28 charged represent ".0001% of California voters" and argued that bringing charges against that number of people just days after flagging 20,000 "raises serious questions as to whether DOJ has any evidence at all supporting their claims on the other 19,900+," according to the Times.
The administration's own numbers have shifted dramatically. In July, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin wrote to California Secretary of State Shirley Weber asserting the state may have more than 190,000 noncitizen voters on its rolls. The number was subsequently reduced to 20,000 — a figure the DOJ now describes as "the floor," adding that its review is "ongoing." Los Angeles officials said this week that a "high percentage" of individuals on the list were born in the United States, and Governor Gavin Newsom said the DOJ sent counties lists of people who "NEVER voted — and voters from the WRONG COUNTY."
Trump's DOJ is so desperate to invent 'widespread voter fraud,' it sent California counties lists of people who NEVER voted – and voters from the WRONG COUNTY. Absolute clown show!— Gavin Newsom, California Governor
The pattern has played out before. A similar situation unfolded in Nevada, the Los Angeles Times reported, where federal officials initially flagged more than 15,000 people as potential noncitizen voters, yet state officials determined that all 185 individuals the Justice Department specifically identified as potential noncitizens were, in fact, citizens. UCLA School of Law's Rick Hasen, who directs the Safeguarding Democracy Project, posted online Monday that the federal government's data for identifying purported noncitizens are "unreliable," and warned that the DOJ's demands could result in "disenfranchising thousands of voters" — with "the lion's share" of those affected likely to be eligible voters, the Times reported.
The DOJ has also acknowledged the scale of the problem it claims to have found may be beyond its capacity to prosecute. In a filing submitted before the lawsuit, the department stated that prosecuting the full number of individuals its investigators had flagged was not realistic, saying "It is not practicable or feasible for the Federal Government to prosecute thousands, let alone tens of thousands, of individuals that two federal investigative offices have identified as likely noncitizens," according to Democracy Docket. The DOJ has separately refused to share the methodology behind its list, and California is one of 30 states — 29 others have also declined — that have refused to hand over unredacted voter rolls containing Social Security numbers, driver's license numbers and birthdates. Every lawsuit the DOJ has brought in an effort to compel states to turn over that information has ended in defeat, Democracy Docket reported.
These arrests are being used to paint a picture of widespread voter fraud when we know that is not the case. California has laws in place to protect the integrity of our elections, and L.A. County is fully abiding by them.— Janice Hahn, Los Angeles County Supervisor
The DOJ, in its court filing, cited the Monday arrests as additional reason for a judge to intervene before the election and segregate the flagged ballots — even while simultaneously acknowledging in the same filing that all those charged are permanent residents whose citizenship status would still need to be determined by the court. Pro-voting groups represented by the Elias Law Group have asked the court to be added as intervenor-defendants in the case, according to Democracy Docket.
Today's arrests prove what we have been saying. California is mailing ballots to noncitizens, and they are refusing to comply with federal law, which makes it a crime for noncitizens to vote. The voting rights of American citizens must be protected.— Bill Essayli, First Assistant U.S. Attorney
The appeals court hearing on Tuesday will determine whether California must comply with the federal demand before Election Day on November 3.
Why it matters — A federal court ruling before November 3 could determine whether tens of thousands of California ballots are counted in the midterms — and set a precedent for how aggressively the federal government can intervene in state elections on short notice.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- A 'high percentage' of individuals on the 20,000-name list were born in the United States.
- Governor Newsom said the DOJ sent counties lists of people who never voted and voters from the wrong county.
Sources differ on Scale of noncitizen voting in California: More than 190,000 noncitizens may be on California voter rolls (latimes.com (attributed to DHS Secretary Mullin, July letter)) vs ~20,000 'likely noncitizens' identified; DOJ calls this 'the floor' (democracydocket.com, latimes.com (DOJ court filings)) vs 28 people charged — '.0001% of California voters' — with no evidence of widespread fraud (latimes.com (California AG Bonta's office; Center for Election Innovation & Research))
Reported by yahoo.com, democracydocket.com, latimes.com
- Gavin Newsom40th governor of California since 2019
- Markwayne MullinAmerican politician (born 1977)