Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
World

Netanyahu vows Iran government change days before election — but analysts say Israel lacks a strategy to deliver it

Israel's prime minister has ordered target lists drawn up and aircraft flying near Iran's borders, but his own security chiefs doubt the goal is achievable — and experts say politics, not military logic, may be driving the push.

How does this story make you feel?

With Israeli elections six days away and polls showing his coalition likely to lose, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has told the country's military and intelligence services that their primary objective is the overthrow of Iran's government — a goal his own security establishment believes cannot be achieved from the outside.

Speaking to IDF officer graduates on October 21, Netanyahu declared that Iran was again developing nuclear weapons and that there was "only one way to remove this threat once and for all." He has since ordered intelligence officials to prepare new target lists for strikes in Iran, and large numbers of Israeli aircraft have been flying close to Iran's borders, according to Hindustan Times.

Overthrow the regime in Iran. And that is my directive to the IDF, the Mossad and the security branches.— Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli Prime Minister

The rhetoric marks a notable shift. During Israel's earlier wars with Iran — in June 2025 and again in a campaign launched on February 28 this year — the official Israeli aim was to "create the conditions" for the government's fall, a formulation that left room for ambiguity. Netanyahu's new language removes that ambiguity, even as analysts and his own security chiefs say the military means to achieve it do not exist.

Israel's intelligence community does not accept that Iran has restarted its nuclear programme, nor that any imminent threat currently justifies going to war, according to Hindustan Times. The generals do not trust Netanyahu's motives. The fact that IDF chief Lieutenant-General Eyal Zamir was excluded from the meeting between Netanyahu and visiting Pentagon chief Pete Hegseth has deepened those suspicions.

Netanyahu himself acknowledged the limits of airpower as recently as March, saying publicly: "You can't do it only from the air. There has to be a ground component, as well" — without explaining what that would involve.

Analysts who spoke to Al Jazeera were blunt about the gap between the stated goal and available tools. Israel can strike Iran — that much is not in dispute. Urban Coningham, a research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, said Israel's offensive weapons stockpiles and aerial refuelling capabilities give it a substantial advantage.

Israel could again establish air superiority and strike Iranian targets.— Urban Coningham, Research Fellow, Royal United Services Institute

But striking and overthrowing are different things. Caglar Kurc, an assistant professor at Abdullah Gul University in Kayseri, Turkiye, told Al Jazeera that bombing could degrade Iran's military without eliminating its ability to fight back.

Airpower can degrade military capabilities but cannot fully destroy offensive capabilities. Well-hidden systems would survive.— Caglar Kurc, Assistant Professor, Abdullah Gul University

Overthrowing the government, Kurc said, would require a willingness to deploy ground troops and remain in place for years — a commitment neither Israel nor the United States has shown any sign of making. Coningham was equally sceptical that covert methods or proxy forces could fill the gap. He described intelligence assets as "use and burn," noting that deploying them risks exposing networks that Iranian security services will then investigate and dismantle. Kurdish armed groups, which the Trump administration was said to be discussing arming in March according to CNN, lack the military capability to take on the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, Coningham said — and that discussion never progressed.

Iran, meanwhile, has already survived two rounds of attacks and retains the means to retaliate — against Israel and against Gulf neighbours hosting US military assets. Sidharth Kaushal, a senior research fellow at RUSI, told Al Jazeera that Iran likely retains sizeable missile stockpiles, and that its antiship missile stocks in particular remain large because they are comparatively easy to manufacture and Iran has brought much of that production in-house. Iran's southern mountains provide natural shelter from air attack.

The actual antiship missile stockpiles likely remain large, both because they are comparatively easy to make, and Iran has in-housed much of the production of older Chinese ASCMs, and Iran's southern mountains provide natural shelters against air attack.— Sidharth Kaushal, Senior Research Fellow, Royal United Services Institute

Coningham added that sustaining Israel's defences in a prolonged exchange would be increasingly difficult, as previous rounds have drawn down interceptor stocks. The financial asymmetry compounds the problem: Israel intercepts cheap Iranian drones with far more expensive defensive weapons, a mismatch that favours Iran in any extended campaign.

The political picture around Netanyahu is as complicated as the military one. The most significant constraint on any Israeli action remains Donald Trump. Since announcing the first ceasefire with Iran on April 8, Trump has repeatedly rebuffed Netanyahu's requests to resume strikes. The Financial Times reported this week that an Israeli proposal for renewed strikes had failed to secure Trump's approval, though the report suggested disagreement about timing rather than a permanent veto, according to Al Jazeera.

Trump's tone shifted noticeably on October 18, when he publicly endorsed Netanyahu, calling him a "Great Warrior Prime Minister" and warning that if Iran did not change course, America would "soon finish the job." He added that if Israel were led by anyone other than Netanyahu, America would have to act alone — and said he was not inclined to do so. The following day, Hegseth visited an airbase in southern Israel where American warplanes are operating and met Netanyahu in secret, according to Hindustan Times.

Even if Trump is now leaning toward action, America's Gulf allies are pushing back hard. They have been informed that the US administration is preparing another round of strikes after the November 3 midterm elections. America has quietly withdrawn personnel from embassies and military bases in Saudi Arabia and other Gulf countries. Iran has threatened a more destructive round of attacks on Gulf infrastructure if the war resumes, and even hawkish Gulf leaders fear the fighting would last far longer than Trump's stated expectation of three days. Saudi Arabia, already struggling to repel Houthi attacks, is particularly worried its air defences would be overwhelmed.

Which brings the analysis back to Netanyahu's domestic situation. Hindustan Times reports that the prospect of losing the October 27 election may itself be accelerating his calculations. Strikes on Iran would draw Iranian retaliation in the form of missiles on Israeli cities — which could disrupt his rivals' attempts to form a new coalition and pressure opposition leaders to join a national unity government with him. Even if he loses, he is likely to remain as caretaker prime minister for weeks or months if opponents cannot quickly form a government. But security professionals and opposition leaders may argue he lacks the authority to launch a major offensive in that role.

According to The Economist's poll tracker cited by Hindustan Times, Yashar — a centre-right party led by former general Gadi Eisenkot — is on track to win 22 Knesset seats, with Netanyahu's Likud at 21. His ruling coalition looks unlikely to secure a majority. The election is on October 27.

Why it matters — Whether Netanyahu orders new strikes on Iran in the coming weeks could be determined less by military strategy than by an election he is expected to lose — with consequences for the wider Middle East, US midterm politics, and Gulf security.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • The Trump administration is preparing another round of strikes on Iran after the November 3 US midterm elections
  • Trump publicly ruled out strikes on October 25 while weighing a deal, amid Qatari mediation efforts
  • Netanyahu's manoeuvres near Iran's borders are intended to provoke Iran into striking first, giving him a pretext for war

Sources differ on Whether Iran has restarted its nuclear weapons programme: Netanyahu told IDF graduates on Oct 21 that Iran is again developing nuclear weapons (hindustantimes.com) vs Israel's intelligence community does not accept that Iran has restarted its nuclear programme (hindustantimes.com)

Reported by hindustantimes.com, aljazeera.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email