Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Sports

J.J. McCarthy wins first Giants start, puts New York alone atop NFC East at bye

Acquired from Minnesota just four weeks ago as a third-stringer, the 23-year-old went 20-of-28 for 252 yards in an overtime win at Houston that lifted New York to 4-2-1.

How does this story make you feel?

Four weeks after arriving in New York as a third-string afterthought, J.J. McCarthy walked into NRG Stadium — the same building where he won a national title at Michigan — and did exactly what the Giants needed: won a football game. The overtime victory over the Houston Texans on Sunday sent New York into its bye week at 4-2-1 and in sole possession of first place in the NFC East, a position that looked improbable when franchise quarterback Jaxson Dart tore up his knee seven snaps into Week 2.

McCarthy finished 20-of-28 for 252 yards without a touchdown pass, but the Giants didn't need him to throw touchdowns. Cam Skattebo rushed for a career-best 124 yards — including a 42-yard burst in overtime — and scored. Devin Singletary scored from 30 yards out to end the game. Tyrone Tracy added a rushing touchdown before leaving with a hamstring injury. Jameis Winston, the quarterback McCarthy replaced, scored on a Tush Push. Four Giants ran for touchdowns in the same game for the first time since Dec. 3, 1950, according to Fox Sports.

It just wasn't even a question to me. Just was an obvious choice just for the circumstances that we were in and all things considered.— John Harbaugh, Giants head coach

That candor stood in contrast to Harbaugh's public framing a week earlier, when he described an open debate between Winston and McCarthy for the starting job. The debate, it turns out, was largely settled the moment the Giants sent a 2027 fifth-round pick to the Minnesota Vikings for McCarthy on Sept. 28. Winston's two interceptions and general inaccuracy in a 34-27 loss to the Saints the previous Sunday — a game in which the Giants fell into a 34-10 hole — gave Harbaugh the opening he needed to make the move official.

The deeper issue was never just Winston's arm. It was his legs — or lack thereof. The Giants built their offense around Dart's dual-threat ability, and the shift to the immobile Winston stripped out the quarterback-run elements that were central to that identity. Winston's lumbering pocket movement contributed to 15 sacks in five games as starter, the fifth-most in the NFL over that span, according to NFL.com. The Giants averaged just 92.8 rushing yards per game in those five games without Dart, ranking 22nd in the league over that stretch, compared to 165 yards — including 54 from Dart himself — in their season-opening win over Dallas.

We haven't been able to go down the roads we wanted to go down in terms of the types of elements that we wanted to use to run the football. Some of the read plays and some of the different things you can do moving the quarterback around, those are definitely things that are part of that equation.— John Harbaugh, Giants head coach

McCarthy's 28-yard scramble to ignite the final drive against New Orleans the week before — when he entered with 11:25 left and the Giants trailing by 24 — was a preview of what the coaching staff had been installing even while he was still learning the playbook. The coaches had already built quarterback-run packages for McCarthy and wedged him into the previous two games to run zone reads and throw short passes before fully handing him the offense against the Saints, where he threw for 243 yards in limited time and drove the Giants to the Houston 14-yard line before the game ended.

Football is football. At the end of the day, there's a lot of similar concepts in every single scheme in the NFL and even going back to college.— J.J. McCarthy, Giants quarterback
All that matters is getting that victory. You want to perform well. You want to execute well. It's one of those things where if the running backs are getting their touches and getting their touchdowns, I'm as happy as I can be.— J.J. McCarthy, Giants quarterback

McCarthy credited Winston, third-stringer Jake Haener, the injured Dart, and the coaching staff for preparing him. Harbaugh, meanwhile, called the plan to start McCarthy going forward — not a week-to-week audition. The Giants wouldn't have traded for him, Harbaugh reasoned, if they only wanted a backup for Winston. Harbaugh had called McCarthy 'the very best quarterback you could get' at the time of the trade, according to NFL.com.

The bye arrives at a useful moment. Left tackle Andrew Thomas has been playing through a groin injury, right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor through a calf injury, and safety Jevon Holland and cornerback Greg Newsome both missed the Houston game with concussions. Kicker Dominic Zvada, who started the season 9-for-9, has now missed five of his last nine attempts — tied for the most misses in the league — though Harbaugh said the Giants are not working out replacements. On the positive side, cornerback Deonte Banks held Texans receiver Nico Collins to one catch for four yards, a performance Harbaugh singled out specifically.

The Giants return from the bye to visit Philadelphia on Nov. 8. McCarthy will face a full game's worth of scrutiny from the start, without the luxury of entering a blowout with nothing to lose. But for now, a team that lost its franchise quarterback in the second week of the season sits alone at the top of its division.

Why it matters — A team that lost its franchise quarterback in Week 2 has found a potential long-term answer at the position just in time to protect first place in one of the NFL's most competitive divisions.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Winston received a two-year, $13 million extension a week before the season started
  • Tyrone Tracy had been in Harbaugh's doghouse for a series of preseason mistakes before Sunday's game
  • Skattebo had zero carries against New Orleans as punishment for fumbling at Washington

Reported by wsj.com, nfl.com, foxsports.com, newsylist.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email