Texas Supreme Court halts deposition into anonymous group behind 4 million trans mailers
The state's highest court stepped in 15 minutes before questioning was set to begin, shielding the identity of whoever sent millions of mailers impersonating a Texas transgender rights group.
Fifteen minutes before a scheduled deposition was set to begin Friday, the Texas Supreme Court issued an emergency order blocking it — halting what could have been the most direct path yet to identifying who sent an estimated 3.6 to 4.2 million mailers across Texas purporting to support transgender students, but which a forgery investigation suggests were designed to inflame conservative voters ahead of the November midterms.
The deposition targeted the Texas Transgender Student Union (TTSU), LLC — a Wyoming-registered entity listed as the sender of the mailers — and had been ordered by Travis County District Judge Jan Soifer earlier in the week. Lawyers for TTSU objected and filed an emergency motion with the Supreme Court late Thursday. The court granted the stay without explaining its reasoning, according to the Texas Tribune.
The mailers, which arrived in Texas homes in mid-October, included the logo, photos, and contact information of the Transgender Education Network of Texas (TENT) — used without permission. They were addressed to 'students' of Texas households and encouraged them to speak with a 'safe adult' or advocacy groups if their parents did not support their gender identity. The backlash that followed was directed largely at TENT, not TTSU.
The messages and mailers have caused widespread confusion and death threats for the people connected to TENT.— Mimi Marziani, attorney for TENT
Marziani told a Travis County judge earlier this week that TENT had been forced to deactivate its website, suspend programming, retain legal counsel, and hire security as a result. She estimated the mailer campaign would have cost far more than TENT's entire annual budget of $1 million, and said whoever was responsible was 'flouting Texas law and going to great lengths to shield themselves from public scrutiny,' according to CBS News.
TTSU was incorporated in Wyoming in September and had an address linked to a Houston-area post office box. Its attorney, Chris Hilton — a former aide in Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's office who also represented Paxton during his 2023 impeachment trial — argued before Judge Soifer that the mailers were constitutionally protected speech and had nothing to do with the election, noting they mentioned no candidate or party.
The First Amendment protects speech 365 days a year – especially in an election year.— Chris Hilton, attorney for TTSU
Hilton attributed a return address on the mailers that was nearly identical to TENT's own street address to a printer's typo. He also revealed during the hearing that beyond representing TTSU, he separately represents unnamed clients of InfoBip, the wireless provider that transmitted unsolicited text messages referencing TENT's website — a disclosure that prompted TENT's attorney to note Hilton appeared to have several 'mystery clients' who did not want to be named.
Friday's blocked deposition was the second ordered by Judge Soifer. The first had already produced a significant lead: it revealed that the text messages sent statewide before the mailers arrived were sent on behalf of the 'Republican Women Caucus Fund' and an individual named John Braun. Both denied involvement with the texts or mailers. A Republican Washington state senator named John Braun, whose campaign shares a treasurer with the caucus fund, also denied involvement in a statement to The Texas Observer, according to the Texas Tribune.
West Texas District Attorney Sarah Stogner opened a forgery investigation into the mailers last week, saying the pamphlets appeared designed to motivate conservative voters ahead of the November 3 midterm elections. Marziani said TENT is cooperating with that investigation.
Despite the Supreme Court's stay, Marziani said TENT now believes it has gathered enough information to sue some of those responsible, though she declined to provide specifics before any litigation is filed. TENT has until 10 a.m. Monday to respond to TTSU's emergency motion before the Texas Supreme Court.
TENT believes the texts and mailers — sent less than a week apart — originated from the same entity, though Marziani acknowledged there is currently no evidence directly linking the two campaigns.
Why it matters — The identity of whoever funded and organized a multi-million-piece mailer campaign impersonating a real civil rights group — and potentially coordinated it with political operatives — remains hidden behind a series of anonymous entities and a Supreme Court order, with a forgery investigation and likely lawsuits still ahead.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- TENT believes the text messages and mailers originated from the same entity.
- The return address on the mailers, nearly identical to TENT's address, was the result of a printer's typo.
Sources differ on Purpose of the mailers: Designed to impersonate TENT, cause confusion, and motivate conservative voters ahead of the midterms — potentially constituting forgery. (texastribune.org) vs Constitutionally protected speech with no connection to the election; did not mention any candidate or party. (cbsnews.com)
Reported by texastribune.org, cbsnews.com
- Ken PaxtonCandidate for US Senate