Data centers get the blame for rising electricity bills. The real culprits are more complicated.
Political ads in Ohio and Texas point to data centers as the cause of soaring electricity prices — but researchers say natural gas, aging infrastructure, and inflation are doing far more damage.
Tens of millions of dollars in political ads this election cycle have told Americans a simple story: data centers moved in, and your electricity bill went up. It is a message with genuine emotional force — and, according to researchers and economists who study electricity markets, a significant oversimplification.
No one asked for that data center to be built here, and no one here is getting a damn thing from it except higher electric bills.— Ad paid for by Sherrod Brown, Democratic Senate candidate in Ohio
A similar message appeared in a Texas Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico ad accusing his Republican opponent of backing data centers that caused 'skyrocketing utility bills' — both spots reflecting a broader political consensus that has hardened around the facilities powering the AI boom. Recent surveys found a majority of Americans would not support a nearby data center, and the top reason cited was rising electricity prices, according to factcheck.org. But the data tell a more complicated story.
Meanwhile, national average retail electricity prices rose 29% between 2019 and 2025 — but just 3% after adjusting for inflation, according to a July report from the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
To date, except for in the PJM market, load growth and data centers in particular as a sub-sector of load growth, have not been a principal driver of price increases in electric markets around the country.— Douglas J. Arent, global fellow at the Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy
According to Arent, speaking to factcheck.org, the primary forces behind higher bills are increases in fuel prices — natural gas in particular — along with the expense of overhauling and upgrading grid infrastructure. Natural gas prices delivered to electric generators climbed 36% in 2025 from their 2024 low, and LBNL identified higher gas prices as a factor behind retail price increases in 21 states, according to nextmsc.com. In 2023 alone, utilities put $27.7 billion into transmission and $50.9 billion into distribution, and by the end of 2025, 1,312 gigawatts of generation capacity sat waiting in interconnection queues.
Inflation has compounded the problem. Equipment and labor costs have soared with supply chain constraints and, more recently, tariffs. According to nextmsc.com's reading of LBNL data, the divergence between a 5.3% nominal and a 2.6% real rise in electricity prices in 2025 suggests that general inflation accounts for roughly half of that year's increase. Weather extremes added further strain: from January through August 2026, cooling degree days ran 21% above normal, ERCOT logged a record hourly peak of 91.1 gigawatts on July 22, and SPP hit a record 57.9 gigawatts on July 27, according to nextmsc.com.
The politics has certainly grown much larger than the data and the facts on this one.— Douglas J. Arent, global fellow at the Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy
The picture is not uniformly reassuring for data center defenders, however. The one region where the evidence is clearest that data centers have pushed prices up is also the largest: PJM Interconnection, which serves more than 65 million people across the Midwest and mid-Atlantic. According to factcheck.org, a July report by LBNL and economic consulting firm the Brattle Group concluded that surging demand, including from large data centers, played a role in driving 'significant' price increases across the PJM region in 2025.
State-level data underscore how local conditions matter as much as national trends. In July 2026, Ohio saw prices rise 15.2% and Maryland 14.8% year-over-year, while Connecticut fell 12.4% and New Mexico fell 8.3%, according to EIA data analyzed by nextmsc.com. California's average revenue per kilowatt-hour was 3.4 times North Dakota's. Experts told factcheck.org that Texas — where political ads have most loudly targeted data centers — would not be expected to see large data-center-driven price increases in the same way, partly because the state is rapidly deploying new low-cost wind and solar power.
At the state level, LBNL's own data indicate that rising demand — driven in part by data centers — has in some cases coincided with falling electricity prices. North Dakota, New Mexico, and Nebraska each significantly grew their electricity load between 2019 and 2025 while reducing inflation-adjusted prices, according to factcheck.org.
Data centers can put either upward or downward pressure on electricity prices. It depends on how much it costs to serve the new demand, whether utilities can use existing infrastructure more efficiently, and who ultimately pays for any required investments.— Jacquelyn Pless, energy economist at the University of Toronto
The debate has drawn in the Trump administration. Department of Energy Secretary Chris Wright has argued that data centers are 'a massive force to reduce the price of electricity,' citing cases where their arrival was accompanied by multi-year rate freezes. A DOE spokesperson told factcheck.org that 'energy subtraction policies' — closures of coal and natural gas plants and state clean energy mandates — are responsible for rising prices, not data centers. Factcheck.org found Wright is correct in principle that data centers can bring prices down, but noted he omits data, including from his own agency, showing the opposite is also happening in some regions.
For residential customers, the price story is particularly acute. Residential customers account for 40.9% of kilowatt-hours sold but roughly 49.9% of implied revenue because their price per kilowatt-hour is the highest of the large sectors, according to nextmsc.com's analysis of EIA data. At 14.99 cents per kilowatt-hour across all sectors in July 2026 — a 4.4% jump from July 2025 — prices outpaced the 1.9% gain in retail sales, indicating that what people pay per unit of electricity is climbing faster than how much they use. For a hypothetical household using 1,000 kilowatt-hours in a month, that translates to roughly $8.55 more than the prior July, according to nextmsc.com.
LBNL estimates U.S. data centers used 176 terawatt-hours in 2023, or 4.4% of U.S. electricity, up from 76 TWh in 2018. Its 2030 reference case projects 649 TWh, or 11.8% of national consumption. As that share grows, the question of who pays for the grid investments needed to support it — and how regulators structure those costs — will determine whether data centers become a larger factor in household bills than they are today.
Why it matters — With electricity prices rising and data center construction accelerating, voters and policymakers need an accurate picture of what is actually driving their bills — and what policy levers would actually help.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- An MIT analysis estimated a 2.1% rise in average residential electricity prices attributable to data centers from 2010 to 2024.
- Tens of millions of dollars have been spent on ads making claims about data centers and electricity prices this election cycle.
- Harvard and University of Pennsylvania study claim (4% of rate increases)
- MIT analysis claim (2.1% residential price rise 2010-2024)
Sources differ on Whether data centers raise or lower electricity prices: Data centers are 'a massive force to reduce the price of electricity and stop the price rises,' and rate freezes have accompanied their arrival in many places. (DOE Secretary Chris Wright, via factcheck.org) vs In the PJM region, data center demand contributed to 'significant' price increases in 2025; effects vary by region and market structure. (LBNL/Brattle Group report, via factcheck.org)
Reported by washingtonpost.com, nextmsc.com, factcheck.org
- Sherrod BrownAmerican politician and educator (born 1952)
- James TalaricoAmerican politician (born 1989)
- Chris WrightUnited States Secretary of Energy (born 1965)