Back pain affects 600 million people — here's what actually causes it and what helps
Stress, sitting 'up straight', and an unusually active weekend are among the real culprits behind the world's leading cause of disability — and most of what you've been told about fixing it is wrong.
Lower back pain is the leading cause of disability worldwide, affecting around 600 million people right now — a number the World Health Organization projects will exceed 800 million by 2050 as populations grow and age. Yet much of what people believe about its causes, and how to fix it, turns out to be wrong.
The triggers are more varied and counterintuitive than most people expect. Stress. Sitting too still. Even trying too hard to sit up straight. Clinicians speaking to The Guardian identified a pattern: patients rarely connect their pain to its actual cause, and the remedies they reach for — MRI scans, surgery, enforcing 'correct' posture — often don't help and can sometimes make things worse.
The most overlooked trigger may be the previous day. Osteopath and naturopath Hannah Whitcombe says it is very common to wake up with back pain without any injury — and the mattress is rarely to blame.
People often overlook what they did the day before. An unusually active day can leave muscles and joints feeling sore the following morning, but the opposite can be true too — sitting at a desk or simply being less active. So if you wake up with a painful back, don't just look at the eight hours you spent in bed, think about the previous 16.— Hannah Whitcombe, osteopath and naturopath
Musculoskeletal physiotherapist and clinical researcher Mindy Cairns sees a seasonal version of the same pattern: patients whose backs flare in summer after sleeping in multiple hotel beds across a fortnight, or who spent five hours jet-washing the patio and never made the connection.
Both extremes of activity are problematic. Physiotherapist and author Antony Bush says office workers can accumulate 12 hours of sitting per day once work, commuting, and evening screen time are counted — 'double what we know gives people back pain,' according to The Guardian. According to a 2021 study cited by Hinge Health, people who sit for extended periods face a 42% greater likelihood of developing lower back pain. Repetitive loading, which affects athletes such as rowers and gymnasts, represents the opposite hazard and can equally overtax the back. Bush told The Guardian that in his experience, half of back pain cases have several contributing causes.
A new wrinkle from research: physical activities like lifting, bending, and squatting were associated with an increased risk of low back pain flares within 24 hours — but sitting was linked to a reduced short-term risk, according to a study led by Pradeep Suri, MD, of the VA Puget Sound Health Care System, published in JAMA Network Open. Crucially, none of the activities were associated with worse functional outcomes at one-year follow-up, leading the researchers to conclude that people with low back pain can generally engage in these activities without fear of long-term harm, according to Medscape.
The posture advice most people grew up with — sit up straight — is more complicated than it sounds. Bush argues that a rigidly held 'correct' posture can itself cause back pain, particularly if it is not a person's natural resting position. London osteopath Anisha Joshi, whose clients include Rita Ora and Nick Grimshaw, still cautions against a heavy slouch, but agrees that a very upright, fixed posture creates tension in certain muscles, especially when held for hours without a break.
Posture is generally most helpful when it's relaxed and adaptable, rather than forced or held in one 'correct' position for hours at a time.— Anisha Joshi, osteopath
Yale Medicine physiatrist Eric K. Holder, MD, takes a more structured view, recommending 'neutral spine alignment' — where major joints are stacked on top of each other — as the target, combined with regular breaks and ergonomic workstation setup. He emphasises that maintaining good posture and muscular stability cannot be achieved passively in modern society and requires consistent, active effort.
On lifting, Bush goes further than most clinicians. According to The Guardian, Bush argued that rounding the back while lifting — rather than using the standard straight-back, bent-knees method — 'isn't as dangerous as it's made out to be,' adding that reviews have found no evidence that one lifting technique prevents back pain. Yale Medicine's Dr. Holder, by contrast, recommends bending at the knees, keeping the item close to the body, and avoiding twisting — a more conventional approach. Both agree that building strength matters more than any single 'correct' form.
Perhaps the most underappreciated cause is stress. Kent-based osteopath Emma Hayward says that when stress persists over time, it triggers contractions in the back's connective tissue that can eventually become fibrosed — 'sticky and tethered,' in her words — leaving the body moving less efficiently and vulnerable to acute episodes even from minor strains.
I very rarely see low back pain in my clinic without the person also having experienced some significant life stressor at the same time. Stress essentially turns up the volume of pain.— Emma Hayward, osteopath
Bush reinforces this with a striking claim about prediction, telling The Guardian: 'We can tell who's going to get chronic pain better from psychometric testing than we can from MRI.' This has direct implications for how back pain is investigated.
MRI scans are frequently sought by people in pain, but the evidence for their routine use is weak. According to Bush, a study placed two groups of back-pain sufferers in an identical situation: both received MRI results showing disc protrusions, tears, and facet wear, all of which were characterised as normal age-related changes. Researchers then told one group that their results fell within the normal range, while the other group received no such explanation. Those left without an explanation reported worsening pain, and their scores on both psychological and physical measures declined. Neil O'Connell, a physiotherapist who helped develop the 2016 NICE clinical guideline on lower back pain, draws a similar conclusion, telling The Guardian that scan findings 'are like wrinkles on the face' — a view reflected in international clinical guidelines, which advise against routine imaging for back pain.
Harvard Health notes that in many cases doctors cannot identify a single specific cause for back pain, and that up to 20% of people with new back pain develop chronic symptoms. Harvard adds the encouraging note that back pain typically clears up on its own over time, and that when symptoms linger, surgery is usually not required for effective treatment.
For new low back pain, Harvard recommends starting with heat or cold, staying as active as tolerable, and if needed, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug such as ibuprofen or naproxen, or a muscle relaxant — though it notes these have only modest and temporary benefits. For chronic pain lasting 12 weeks or more, exercise, cognitive behavioural therapy, and approaches such as yoga, tai chi, and progressive relaxation are recommended. Harvard advises that opioids should generally be avoided in cases of chronic low back pain.
Hinge Health physical therapist Heather Broach, PT, DPT, frames the core principle simply, saying that prolonged sitting alone does not make back pain inevitable, but that remaining locked in any single position — whether sitting, standing, or otherwise — leaves the back in need of movement. Penn State University researchers cited by Hinge Health found that switching positions every 15 minutes could relieve lower back pain from sitting. A 2018 review published in the journal Ergonomics found that sit-stand workstations may help reduce lower back pain.
Back pain is a part of the undulating highway of being a human being and you can't speed up the rate of healing.— Antony Bush, physiotherapist and author of The Back Fix
The consensus across clinicians is that movement — varied, regular, and not obsessively 'correct' — is the most reliable tool available. Dr. Holder recommends Pilates, yoga, and tai chi for posture and alignment, plus floor exercises such as planks and bridges for core strength, and the 150 weekly minutes of moderate to vigorous physical activity recommended by federal guidelines. Bush wants patients to resist an 'I'm broken' mindset and treat back pain as a manageable, if frustrating, part of human life — not a structural catastrophe requiring a scan to decode.
Why it matters — Back pain is the world's leading cause of disability and affects most people at some point — understanding its real causes and the limits of common remedies can prevent unnecessary suffering, wasted investigations, and ineffective treatment.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- In Antony Bush's experience, half of back pain cases have several contributing causes.
- Bush states psychometric testing predicts chronic pain better than MRI.
Sources differ on Correct lifting technique for back pain prevention: Lifting with a rounded back and straight legs is not as dangerous as commonly believed; no evidence one technique prevents back pain. (theguardian.com (Antony Bush)) vs Always bend at the knees, not the waist; keep the item close to the body and avoid twisting. (yalemedicine.org (Dr. Eric K. Holder))
Sources differ on Whether sitting increases or decreases short-term back pain risk: Prolonged sitting associated with 42% higher risk of developing lower back pain. (hingehealth.com) vs Sitting was linked to a reduced short-term risk of low back pain flares compared to lifting and bending, in a JAMA Network Open study. (medscape.com)
Reported by theguardian.com, health.harvard.edu, medscape.com, yalemedicine.org, hingehealth.com
- Rita OraEnglish-Albanian singer and actress