Giants pull two-pick offer for Jonathan Taylor, leaving Colts with no second-round bid on table
New York withdrew a second- and fifth-round package 'a couple weeks ago,' and with the deadline hours away, Indianapolis may have no choice but to keep its star running back.
The New York Giants have pulled a trade offer of a second-round pick and a fifth-round pick for Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor, Fox NFL insider Jay Glazer reported Sunday — leaving the Colts without the best package they had received and, with Tuesday's deadline approaching, increasingly likely to keep their star running back.
Unless the Colts come down from it, I don't see that happening for Jonathan Taylor. And I don't think they have as much interest as they initially thought.— Jay Glazer, Fox NFL insider
Glazer said the Giants floated the offer 'a couple weeks ago' but have since stepped back. NFL insider Jordan Schultz added critical context: the Giants were the only team to include a second-round pick in any offer to the Colts, meaning Indianapolis no longer has that benchmark on the table.
Sources: The belief around the NFL is that the Colts will likely end up keeping RB Jonathan Taylor unless they receive an offer too good to turn down. The Giants were the only team to offer a 2nd-round pick plus additional compensation to this point.— Jordan Schultz, NFL insider
The Giants' need at running back had made them a natural fit. All four backs they used this season — Cam Skattebo, Devin Singletary, Tyrone Tracy Jr., and the since-released Najee Harris — failed to establish themselves as the clear starter, the New York Post reported. Singletary got the nod against the Eagles after Skattebo sat out Sunday with a hamstring injury and Tracy landed on injured reserve with a hamstring problem of his own.
The Giants' draft capital situation complicates any revised offer. They retain a second-round pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, but a fifth-round selection was sent to the Vikings as part of the deal to land quarterback J.J. McCarthy, according to the New York Post.
Taylor, 26, is under contract through the end of the 2028 season. Through eight games this season he has rushed for 610 yards and eight touchdowns at 4.1 yards per carry, the lowest average of his career, per the New York Post. The Colts, who have already traded offensive lineman Quenton Nelson to the Seahawks and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to the 49ers, had been widely seen as sellers ahead of the deadline.
The stakes were visible at Lucas Oil Stadium on Sunday. As Taylor warmed up before the Colts' loss to the Dallas Cowboys, the stadium's two large video boards played a montage of his career highlights — a moment that, according to the Associated Press, felt like it could be a farewell. Taylor himself, speaking shortly after the defeat, indicated he was aware that Sunday's game might have been his final one at home in Indianapolis.
At this point, the hay is in the barn now. We're preparing for the Dallas Cowboys. We got a home game. After last week, nothing else matters. We just gotta give these fans a win.— Jonathan Taylor, Colts running back
Other teams reported to have interest include the Vikings, Packers, and Broncos, according to NFL on Prime reporter James Palmer. But with none of them having matched the Giants' second-round offer, and the Giants now out, Sporting News noted that it would take a team 'really upping their offer' to get a deal done before Tuesday's deadline.
Why it matters — With the Giants' offer — the only second-round bid on the table — now withdrawn and the deadline hours away, Taylor is likely to remain a Colt unless a new suitor emerges with a better package.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- It is unclear what draft year the picks in the Giants' offer were for
- exact 4 p.m. ET deadline time (not specified in sources)
- verbatim Taylor quote (paraphrased to match source wording)
Reported by yahoo.com, giantswire.usatoday.com, nypost.com, sportingnews.com
- Quenton NelsonAmerican football player (born 1996)
- DeForest BucknerAmerican football player (born 1994)