Misiorowski and Schlittler sweep Cy Young Awards unanimously, a feat unseen since 2022
The Brewers' Jacob Misiorowski and the Yankees' Cam Schlittler each claimed all 30 first-place votes on Wednesday, capping seasons so dominant they rank among the rarest in modern baseball history.
On the same Wednesday in November, baseball writers handed every single one of their first-place votes to two pitchers — one in each league — for only the third time since the Cy Young Award began. Jacob Misiorowski of the Milwaukee Brewers took the National League honor, and Cam Schlittler of the New York Yankees claimed the American League's, each collecting all 30 ballots from the Baseball Writers' Association of America.
The last time both leagues produced unanimous winners in the same year was 2022, when Justin Verlander and Sandy Alcantara swept their respective votes, according to CBS Sports. What makes 2026 rarer still: Misiorowski posted an ERA+ of 232 and Schlittler an ERA+ of 215 — and, per CBS Sports, only six seasons in all of modern baseball history (since 1900) have produced even two pitchers with a 200 ERA+ or better. This is just the third time both came from different leagues.
Misiorowski, 24, finished the regular season with a 1.80 ERA — the best mark for any starter in baseball — along with 252 strikeouts across 30 starts and a 0.80 WHIP, according to Fox News. The Brewers won 103 games and, ultimately, the franchise's first-ever World Series title, making Misiorowski the first pitcher since Randy Johnson in 2001 to win both a Cy Young and a World Series ring in the same season, per Fox News. He became the fourth Brewers pitcher to win the award, joining Corbin Burnes (2021), Pete Vuckovich (1982), and Rollie Fingers (1981).
The 6-foot-7 right-hander, nicknamed 'The Miz,' averaged 100.6 mph on his fastball and threw more than 1,000 pitches at that speed or faster during the season, according to Fox News. In June, a pitch against Pete Crow-Armstrong of the Chicago Cubs registered 105.5 mph — the fastest pitch ever thrown by a starter in the Statcast era. His ERA+ of 232 led all of baseball.
In the American League, Schlittler's numbers were nearly as eye-catching. The 25-year-old went 14-6 with a 1.95 ERA — the AL's best — striking out 239 batters across 33 starts and 193.2 innings. He gave up one run or fewer in 21 of those 33 outings and posted a 1.16 ERA over 17 road starts, according to Fox News. His ERA+ of 215 led the American League.
Schlittler's rise is one of the more unlikely stories in the sport. A seventh-round draft pick out of Northeastern University and a Massachusetts native who grew up a Boston Red Sox fan, he came up through the Yankees' minor league system after mechanical adjustments helped push his velocity from the low 90s to the upper 90s, with flashes of triple digits, per Fox News. In his first full season, he outpitched a rotation that included Gerrit Cole — the Yankees' most recent Cy Young winner, in 2023 — Carlos Rodon, and Max Fried.
Former Yankees ace Roger Clemens announced Schlittler's win live on MLB Network, according to Yahoo. Misiorowski also appeared on MLB Network to receive his award. The runners-up in the NL were Philadelphia Phillies left-hander Cristopher Sanchez and Atlanta Braves veteran Chris Sale; in the AL, Toronto Blue Jays starter Dylan Cease and Cleveland Guardians pitcher Parker Messick finished second and third, per Fox News.
CBS Sports noted that Misiorowski and Schlittler each struck out more than 30 percent of opposing batters this season. Their combination of a 200+ ERA+ and age 25 or younger has not been seen since 1905, when Christy Mathewson (age 24) and Ed Reulbach (age 22) achieved the mark. The last comparable pairing from different leagues was Clemens and Pedro Martinez in 1997.
Also announced Wednesday: San Diego Padres closer Mason Miller and Toronto Blue Jays closer Louis Varland won the inaugural Reliever of the Year award for their respective leagues, according to Fox News.
Why it matters — Two pitchers posting a 200+ ERA+ in the same season — each under 26 years old — is something baseball has not seen since 1905, and their unanimous sweeps signal a potential era of dominance from two of the sport's youngest aces.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Misiorowski's Cy Young win was announced on November 11–12, 2026.
- Misiorowski finished with a 16-5 win-loss record.
- Misiorowski pitched 174⅔ innings across his 30 starts.
Reported by yahoo.com, foxnews.com, cbssports.com, mlb.com, baseball.realgm.com, reuters.com
- Randy JohnsonAmerican Hall of Fame baseball pitcher (born 1963)
- Inspectah DeckAmerican rapper and producer (born 1970)
- Roger ClemensAmerican baseball player
- Justin VerlanderAmerican baseball pitcher (born 1983)
- Christy MathewsonAmerican Major League baseball player, manager (1880-1925)
- Pedro MartinezDominican-American Hall of Fame baseball pitcher