Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Politics

Three men freed from Florida's death row ask governor-elect Donalds to halt executions

As Florida stands on the verge of a new annual execution record, exonerated former death row prisoners want Byron Donalds to pause the process and review all 235 condemned cases — but his transition team says he's a 'staunch supporter' of capital punishment.

How does this story make you feel?

Gage Skidmore from Surprise, AZ, United States of America / Wikimedia Commons

Three men who each survived wrongful death sentences in Florida stood before cameras in Tallahassee on Thursday and asked the state's incoming governor a simple question: what if the next person executed is also innocent?

Herman Lindsey, Joaquín José Martínez, and Seth Penalver — all exonerated former death row prisoners and advocates with the group Witness to Innocence — held a press conference hosted by Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (FADP) to urge Governor-elect Byron Donalds to impose a moratorium on executions and order a review of all 235 cases currently on Florida's death row. The answer from his transition team was swift and discouraging: Donalds, a spokesperson told the Miami Herald, 'is a staunch supporter of the death penalty and will govern as such.'

The appeal comes as Florida is on the verge of setting a new annual execution record. The scheduled execution of convicted murderer Thomas Overton next Thursday will be the state's 20th this year, surpassing the 19 carried out in 2025. Both records belong to the tenure of outgoing Governor Ron DeSantis, who will have signed 50 death warrants by the time he leaves office in January — all but two of them carried out during his second term.

Florida holds a grim dual distinction: it leads the country in both executions and death row exonerations. Since capital punishment was reintroduced nationwide in 1976, 30 people have been exonerated from Florida's death row — the highest such number of any state, according to FADP.

Thirty men were convicted and sentenced to die, and those convictions were wrong. Each of us had to find a way to get someone to listen and look again. When you are the person facing execution, you cannot afford for everyone to assume that somebody else has already checked everything. You need someone who is willing to examine the evidence and take your questions seriously.— Seth Penalver, exonerated death row prisoner

Penalver spent 18 years in prison — 13 of them on death row — after being convicted of a triple homicide and armed robbery in 1994. He was acquitted in 2012. Martínez was sentenced to death in 1997 for a double murder and exonerated in 2001 after a court found that evidence against him had been fabricated by a relative of one of the victims who worked at the investigating sheriff's office, and that several informants had been promised rewards for false testimony. Lindsey was wrongfully convicted of the 1994 killing of a pawn shop owner and spent three years on death row before his exoneration in 2009.

It's easier to believe that a person that's exonerated, who is taken out of death row, got out because he was lucky than it is to believe that our system is failing. It's time to evolve; it's time to change. It's time we end the death penalty.— Joaquín José Martínez, exonerated death row prisoner

Lindsey, who also serves as executive director of Witness to Innocence, directed his appeal personally at the governor-elect, expressing hope that Donalds would approach the issue differently than DeSantis.

Mr Byron, you don't look like you are a person that is barbaric. I hope that you consider re-evaluating the death penalty before you use it, and investigate. It's not about him ending the death penalty, but I want to give him the knowledge and assist him to learn anything that he needed about the death penalty so he can make valid, right decisions.— Herman Lindsey, executive director of Witness to Innocence

The three men said they are seeking a roundtable discussion with Donalds and the state's new legislative leaders. As an alternative to the current pace of executions, they also called for increased state funding for public defender resources, mental health programs, and education, according to WCTV.

The US is not barbaric and Florida is not barbaric. It just needs to evolve, it just needs to grow. These past two years have just been horrible when it comes to executions, we need to change that. We need to put things into place so we are not putting people to death for things we failed to acknowledge.— Joaquín José Martínez, exonerated death row prisoner

Grace Hanna, executive director of FADP, framed the press conference as the opening of a longer conversation with the incoming administration.

Today, some of the people most impacted by Florida's broken death penalty, people who had been wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death, used their voices to reach our incoming governor and advocate for a pause in executions.— Grace Hanna, executive director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty

Donalds takes office in January. The men said they plan to continue working with lawmakers during the upcoming regular legislative session to push for measures that would help death row prisoners. A separate anti-death penalty activist has also called for a six-month moratorium beginning when Donalds assumes the governorship, according to the Florida Phoenix.

Why it matters — With Florida executing people at a record pace and 30 proven wrongful death sentences already on the books, the incoming governor's stance on capital punishment will determine whether that pace continues — or whether any of the 235 people now on death row get a second look.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • A separate anti-death penalty activist called for a six-month moratorium starting when Donalds takes office in January.
  • dek phrasing 'sets a new annual execution record' (changed to reflect that the record is imminent but not yet achieved)

Reported by theguardian.com, yahoo.com, tallahassee.com, washingtonpost.com, wctv.tv, floridaphoenix.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email