SpaceX catches Starship's upper stage for the first time, completing half of a planned double recovery
Ship 42 returned from orbit and was snagged by Mechazilla's arms on Nov. 14 — but the Super Heavy booster malfunctioned and ended up in the Gulf of Mexico the night before.
A bullet-shaped spacecraft fell out of the clouds above South Texas on Saturday afternoon, flew horizontal until the last possible moment, then fired its engines and swept vertical — before settling, gently, into the waiting steel arms of its own launch tower. SpaceX had just caught a Starship returning from orbit, a feat that had never been done before.
That was the missing link. That was the holy grail of spaceflight, plummeting through fire to be snatched out of the air by steel. We caught a Starship, and now everything changes.— Dan Huot, SpaceX commentator
The catch of Ship 42 — the upper stage of SpaceX's Starship megarocket — occurred at 4:20 p.m. EST on Nov. 14, roughly 22.5 hours after Flight 15 lifted off from Starbase, SpaceX's facility near Boca Chica, Texas. The vehicle had completed 14 orbits and deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites before returning to the pad. As it descended, SpaceX employees streamed outside to watch, and the company's landing webcast played 'Baby Come Back' over the speakers.
The catch was only half of what SpaceX had set out to do. Flight 15 was designed to be the first mission to recover both stages of Starship at the launch tower — an unprecedented total recovery of an orbital rocket. That plan fell apart the night before, when the Super Heavy booster malfunctioned shortly after the 5:47 p.m. Eastern liftoff on Friday, Nov. 13.
Booster downrange abort.— Dan Huot, SpaceX commentator
Booster 22 — the first V3 Super Heavy to attempt a tower catch — was redirected toward the Gulf of Mexico, where it splashed down and its flight termination system activated. SpaceX's initial explanation for the abort pointed to a guidance, navigation and control problem. Engineer Kate Tice said preliminary findings suggested the boostback burn cut short after a low-fuel mass alarm triggered.
was slightly low on fuel— Elon Musk, SpaceX CEO
Musk said the fix involves more consistent Raptor V3.2 engines and a software change to cut the engines about a second earlier. Musk also stated that losing the booster would not affect SpaceX's schedule for high-volume, fully reusable flights.
The three previous booster catches — on Flights 5, 7, and 8 — had all involved V1 Super Heavy boosters, not the newer V3 version. The upper stage, by contrast, had never been caught before Saturday. It is a harder target: it flies higher, farther, and faster than the booster, and on Flight 15 it came all the way back from orbit. The tolerances at the tower left almost no room for error — the arms had only two nubs to grip, one on each side of the rocket, each extending roughly a foot outward.
No second stage of any launch system had returned to Earth in one piece since Space Shuttle Atlantis touched down on July 21, 2011, bringing NASA's shuttle program to a close. But where Atlantis had 15,000 feet of runway to slow to a halt, Ship 42 had to position itself precisely between the tower arms SpaceX calls 'Mechazilla.'
Seven of Starship's previous 14 flights ended with the upper stage either exploding in flight or breaking apart during reentry. Eight others performed controlled landings into the Indian and Pacific Oceans. Only one of those splashdowns saw the vehicle survive intact: Flight 13, in which the upper stage toppled into the Indian Ocean, did not sink, and was eventually recovered and transported back to Starbase.
Flight 15 also had operational objectives beyond the catch attempt. Ship 42 deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites — the same number as Flight 14, which on Sept. 28 became the first Starship mission to reach orbit and deploy an operational payload. Three of the satellites on Flight 15 were fitted with cameras to inspect Ship 42's heat shield during reentry; those images, combined with ground-based cameras, confirmed the vehicle was in good shape for its landing attempt.
The stakes behind the catch go well beyond a single test flight. SpaceX says the ability to catch and quickly reuse both stages is essential to the launch cadence it needs to build its planned megaconstellations. The company is also under contract with NASA to use Starship as the Artemis lunar lander. At Starbase, SpaceX currently has five Starships in an advanced state of development and the components for a dozen more. The factory can manufacture an upper stage every three weeks and was sized to eventually produce one every three days.
This is so incredible to see. One of the most incredible and historic engineering feats of all time has just happened right in front of our eyes.— Jessie Anderson, SpaceX
SpaceX will almost certainly attempt the double catch again on the next Starship flight, which will not be far off. The company's longer-term ambition — flying Starship hundreds, then thousands of times per year — depends on making what happened Saturday routine.
Why it matters — Catching a Starship returning from orbit closes the last major gap in SpaceX's plan for a fully reusable rocket — a system it needs to build giant satellite networks, cut launch costs, and eventually carry NASA astronauts to the Moon.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- SpaceX plans a Starmind AI data-center constellation of one million spacecraft in low Earth orbit.
Sources differ on Cause of Booster 22's abort: SpaceX initially described it as a guidance, navigation and control issue. (thetechportal.com) vs Engineer Kate Tice later said early indications were that the boostback burn ended early on a low-fuel mass alarm. (thetechportal.com) vs Elon Musk said the booster 'was slightly low on fuel' due to engine underperformance. (pcmag.com)
Reported by pbs.org, space.com, arstechnica.com, pcmag.com, thetechportal.com
- Elon MuskAmerican businessman (born 1971)