Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Your Money

Record $1.29T in US credit card debt — yet debt-free earners are the ones getting rejected

As Americans collectively owe more on credit cards than ever before, bank algorithms are turning away six-figure earners whose crime is never borrowing in the first place.

How does this story make you feel?

American credit card debt has hit a record $1.29 trillion — and yet some of the people least likely to add to that pile are the ones banks are turning away. Six-figure earners with zero debt and solid savings are finding themselves turned down on the spot by automated lending systems when they seek ordinary credit cards, auto loans, or home mortgages.

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York reported that card balances rose $22 billion in the third quarter — a 1.7% increase from the prior quarter and 4.2% higher than a year earlier. Total household debt climbed to $19.1 trillion. Yet the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau estimates roughly 25 million adults have credit files too thin or too stale to generate a standard score, according to Fox Business — and the algorithms banks rely on can read that silence as risk.

The core problem is structural: income does not factor into a credit score. A person who earns $150,000 a year but hasn't opened a credit account in years looks, on paper, like an unknown quantity to a lender's algorithm — not a responsible saver.

The algorithms are looking for movement. They want to see what you've actually been doing. So the interesting thing about credit is that income is never a factor into the score itself. And so you might have this incredible income, but you might not have a credit score that supports exactly who you are as a person.— Micah Smith, credit repair specialist and founder of Micah LLC

Smith described walking into a car dealership as a debt-free young adult and being denied financing — told she needed a co-signer because lenders 'couldn't see who she was on paper,' according to Fox Business. A 2025 consumer study by PYMNTS Intelligence and the Federal Reserve found that credit anxiety and surprise loan denials have spread well beyond low-income households, now hitting people who earn more than $100,000 a year, largely because their credit files are thin and their borrowing history lacks variety.

According to Fox Business, the denials can shut out applicants seeking entry-level cards from major issuers such as Chase or Capital One, along with auto financing and home loans. Landlords, co-ops, and small business financing can also be affected.

Is corporate America penalizing people who live debt-free? I would say they're not penalizing them, but they are not prioritizing them because we're not the ones making them money. When you think about the credit score in general, the whole purpose, it's a product, and so it's out there for banks to make money. And if we're not going to be their customer, then yes, they're not going to prioritize us.— Jade Warshaw, co-host of The Ramsey Show

Warshaw pointed out that Fair, Isaac and Company — the forerunner of FICO — was established in 1956 by Bill Fair and Earl Isaac for the purpose of assessing credit risk, not gauging personal wealth. She argued that decades of financial marketing have led Americans to conflate a high credit score with genuine financial health.

As American consumers, we've allowed the credit score to confuse being profitable for banks with us being actually financially good with money, and it's not the same thing. Being profitable with banks by having a good credit score does not equal being a financially responsible adult and actually having wealth and being good with money.— Jade Warshaw, co-host of The Ramsey Show

The two experts offer different prescriptions. Warshaw, reflecting the philosophy popularized by Dave Ramsey, advises consumers to cut up their credit cards entirely — warning that cards act as a 'gateway drug' into broader consumer debt. She pointed to the $1.29 trillion balance as evidence that most people who claim to pay off their cards monthly are not doing so consistently.

Smith takes a more pragmatic view: voluntarily becoming 'invisible' in a digital economy creates expensive, everyday roadblocks. She told Fox Business, 'You will not be able to run a business on cash alone. It doesn't exist.' She also cautioned against 'buy now, pay later' platforms, warning that some now report to credit bureaus — and that opening multiple short-term installment loans can drag down the 'average age of credit,' making a file look erratic rather than responsible.

Every time you open something, it's going to take your overall length of history backwards. It's opened up as an installment loan — you open it, pay it off and it closes. So having those opened up often could suppress your scores pretty substantially.— Micah Smith, credit repair specialist and founder of Micah LLC

The broader debt picture shows mounting stress elsewhere in the system. Overall household delinquency rose to 5.0% at the end of September, up from 4.7% three months earlier, according to the New York Fed. The share of student loan balances at least 90 days behind on payments climbed from 10.6% to 10.9%. Auto loan and mortgage delinquencies also increased. Credit cards were an exception — the share of card balances moving into early delinquency actually fell slightly from the second quarter. New York Fed researchers said pandemic-era cards given to borrowers with lower incomes and weaker credit scores are now exhibiting higher levels of distress, whereas cards issued from early 2023 onward have gone predominantly to borrowers with stronger scores.

The New York Fed is scheduled to release its next household debt report, which will cover the fourth quarter, in February.

Why it matters — The same credit infrastructure that tracks $1.29 trillion in American borrowing can lock out debt-free, high-earning consumers from mortgages, car loans, and basic credit cards — revealing that the system rewards participation in debt, not avoidance of it.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Jade Warshaw and her husband paid off $460,000 in debt
  • Micah Smith funded more than $9,000 in Las Vegas travel expenses entirely through accumulated credit card points and cash back
  • third quarter of 2026 (year not specified in sources)

Reported by stockanalysis.com, foxbusiness.com

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email