Texas man executed for beheading his three children in 2003, hours after Oklahoma puts man to death
John Allen Rubio, 46, was pronounced dead in Huntsville on Thursday evening — the 37th U.S. execution this year — for the killings that so shook Brownsville the apartment where they happened was torn down and replaced with a park.
At 6:47 p.m. Thursday, John Allen Rubio was declared dead at the Texas State Penitentiary in Huntsville — 21 minutes after a lethal dose of the sedative pentobarbital began flowing — bringing to a close a case that had haunted the border city of Brownsville for nearly 23 years. He was 46. Hours earlier and hundreds of miles north, Oklahoma executed 73-year-old James Pavatt for the 2001 murder of his girlfriend's estranged husband. The two deaths on a single day pushed the U.S. to 36 and 37 executions for the year, putting the country on pace to exceed 40 for a second consecutive year.
Rubio was convicted of fatally stabbing and beheading three young children in a squalid, windowless Brownsville apartment on March 11, 2003: three-year-old Julissa Quesada, 14-month-old John E. Rubio, and two-month-old Mary Jane Rubio. The killings were carried out alongside his common-law wife, Angela Camacho, who pleaded guilty and is serving a life sentence. Court records show that the two older children were not Rubio's biological offspring, though he had raised them as his own.
The crimes shook Brownsville so deeply that the apartment building was later demolished. The land was turned into a park and community garden, according to the Associated Press.
Before the injection began, a spiritual adviser prayed over Rubio briefly. He then delivered a final statement in which he thanked friends and family and expressed love for Camacho.
I want to say I'm sorry to my wife's family. I can't change the past but I can tell you my life is going to be over. But that's not going to make you happy.— John Allen Rubio, condemned man
I'm going to be with my kids in a little bit. I'm ready to go to heaven to be with my lord and savior.— John Allen Rubio, condemned man
Three breaths followed the drug's onset, after which Rubio produced what the Guardian described as a snoring sound. All movement then ceased, and a physician pronounced him dead.
Rubio's path to execution wound through two trials. An appeals court overturned his first capital murder conviction, ruling that statements from Camacho had been improperly admitted as evidence. At his second trial, he entered the same insanity plea as before, having asserted at various points that the children were possessed and that he was "the chosen one" destined to save the world. Prosecution experts disputed the conclusion reached by defense experts, who had determined that Rubio suffered from paranoid schizophrenia. Juries convicted him both times.
Defense attorneys also argued that Rubio's childhood — marked by violence at home, what they described as 'toxic' parents, drug use, and prostitution — had damaged him developmentally, according to the Associated Press.
Oklahoma juries found Pavatt guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder in the death of Rob Andrew, a 39-year-old advertising executive. Rob Andrew's wife, Brenda Andrew, was having an affair with Pavatt, who had worshipped at the same church as the Andrew family. Several weeks before the shooting, Rob Andrew went to police with concerns that someone wanted him dead, after the brake lines on his car were found to have been cut. After the shooting, Brenda Andrew told police that masked intruders had shot her in the arm and killed her husband. Pavatt and Brenda Andrew then fled to Mexico with her two children and were arrested three months later while re-entering the United States, according to the Guardian.
Brenda Andrew was convicted at a separate trial and remains the only woman currently on Oklahoma's death row. Pavatt declined to offer any final statement, shaking his head when given the opportunity. While a chaplain read aloud from the Bible, Pavatt's lips appeared to move, though whatever he was saying could not be heard.
Thursday's double execution came amid a period of heightened national attention on capital punishment. In September, a Tennessee execution of Christa Pike was reported to have failed. California Governor Gavin Newsom declared on November 5 that he intended to commute hundreds of death sentences before his term ends in January — a move that experts told the Guardian could rank as the largest mass clemency in American history. Also on Thursday, Richard Glossip — a former Oklahoma death row inmate who had come within hours of execution on three separate occasions and walked out of prison on bond in May after nearly 30 years — entered a guilty plea to a lesser charge of being an accessory in a 1997 murder and is set to be sentenced in December.
Why it matters — Two executions on a single day push the U.S. toward its second consecutive year above 40 executions, even as California moves toward the largest mass clemency in American history — a split that reflects a deepening national divide over capital punishment.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The pace of U.S. executions this year is being driven primarily by Florida.
Reported by theguardian.com, gephardtdaily.com, foxnews.com
- Gavin Newsom40th governor of California since 2019
- Christa PikeAmerican murderer (born 1976)