Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Your Money

Two teachers with pensions asked if they could skip saving. Experts said no.

A couple in their late 40s with full teacher pensions and Social Security on the way thought they had retirement covered. Financial experts found four gaps their plan doesn't close.

How does this story make you feel?

They have pensions. They have Social Security coming. They plan to work part-time to bridge the gap. On paper, two teachers in their late 40s — who wrote to Kiplinger's Wealth Wise column — looked like they had retirement figured out without ever opening a 403(b). Experts reviewed their plan and found it full of holes.

The couple, whose names were not published, are both teachers eligible to retire in their mid-to-late 50s with a full pension worth a little more than 50% of their salaries, plus state-paid health benefits. They plan to work part-time until 65, then collect Social Security. They have saved nothing for retirement and asked whether they should start. The answer from every expert consulted: yes, even if modestly.

I would not skip saving. A pension is a strong base, but this plan has gaps that savings can fill.— Hans Goldstein, EA, founder and executive director, Retirement Literacy Foundation

The couple's position is genuinely enviable. Only 14% of private-sector workers have access to a traditional defined benefit plan, according to a March 2026 Bureau of Labor Statistics report cited by Kiplinger, compared with 86% of state and local government workers. The median state and local government pension paid $2,078 a month in 2024 — meaning this couple, with two pensions, could expect more than $4,100 a month in today's dollars before Social Security.

That income floor is real and valuable. As Bonfire Financial explains it, a pension functions similarly to a very large bond: it provides predictable monthly income for life, shifting investment risk away from the retiree. Someone needing $80,000 a year in retirement without a pension might need roughly $2 million invested under the traditional 4% withdrawal rule. A $60,000 annual pension collapses that requirement dramatically — the portfolio only needs to generate the remaining gap, not the whole amount.

But the experts identified four specific vulnerabilities in a pension-only plan.

The first is inflation. Not every pension includes a cost-of-living adjustment, and even Social Security's annual COLA has not kept pace with what retirees actually spend. The Senior Citizens League, an advocacy group, says Social Security benefits have lost 13.7% of their buying power over the past decade because COLAs have been too small, according to Kiplinger. Healthcare, food, housing, and travel costs can all rise significantly over a 20- or 30-year retirement, and a fixed pension check buys less of all of them each year.

The second is Social Security's uncertain future. The program's Trustees have reported that, without reforms, benefits could be cut by 22% as early as the fourth quarter of 2032, according to Kiplinger. Congress has never allowed a broad benefit cut to take effect, but it now has only a few years to act — and building a retirement plan that assumes full benefits is a risk.

Retirement rarely goes as planned, so having little to no savings can make it difficult for you to enjoy a long retirement. Chances are, your expenses will increase over time, health challenges will arise, taxes will rise, long-term care will be needed, etc.— JB Beckett, founder, Beckett Financial Group

The third gap is the income bridge. The couple plans to retire in their mid-to-late 50s, but full Social Security benefits don't arrive until age 67. Claiming at 62 instead cuts the benefit by about 30%, Goldstein warns. Part-time work may not fully cover the difference, and a 403(b) balance — even a modest one — can serve as a bridge to delay claiming and protect the larger lifetime benefit.

The fourth is tax efficiency. Because pension income will already fill the lower tax brackets, Goldstein recommends Roth contributions specifically. Roth accounts grow tax-free and withdrawals are tax-free, providing flexibility that pre-tax pension income cannot. Peak Retirement Planning's Joe Schmitz similarly flags that retirees with pensions often face higher taxes than expected, and that strategies like Roth conversions and income timing can prevent an otherwise strong financial position from becoming inefficient.

None of this means the couple needs to overhaul their finances. Goldstein's prescription is modest: even 5% of pay, ideally in a Roth 403(b), buys meaningful flexibility. There is also a practical tax benefit to staying in the employer's plan: if they leave teaching in or after the year they turn 55, withdrawals from that plan avoid the 10% early distribution penalty that normally applies before age 59½.

For workers closer to retirement, the math still favors saving. How to Money, responding to a 61-year-old public-sector worker in a similar position, calculated that maxing out a Roth IRA — $7,000 a year, plus a $1,000 catch-up contribution for those over 55 — over seven years produces at least $56,000 before any investment growth. The podcast hosts also noted that pensions, particularly from private employers, can be reduced or eliminated, though they acknowledged the listener's public pension appeared secure.

The broader reframe from Bonfire Financial and Peak Retirement Planning is that pension holders are comparing themselves to the wrong benchmark. The standard $1 million retirement target was built for people without guaranteed income. For someone whose pension and Social Security already cover essential expenses, the investment portfolio becomes a supplement — for inflation protection, discretionary spending, long-term care, and legacy — not the primary engine. That is a different and more manageable goal, but it is still a goal that requires some saving to reach.

It's a great thing to have a pension. But we also don't think that a generous pension mitigates the need to invest.— How to Money hosts

Why it matters — Millions of public-sector workers with pensions face the same temptation to skip personal savings — and the same hidden risks if they do.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • The Social Security Fairness Act has already been signed into law, repealing the Windfall Elimination Provision and Government Pension Offset.

Reported by kiplinger.com, money.ca, investopedia.com, howtomoney.com, safemoney.com, peakretirementplanning.com, bonfirefinancial.com

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email