China's economy stumbles into Q4 as retail sales, output and investment all disappoint
October data showed every major indicator missing forecasts, deepening concerns about weak domestic demand as export-led growth leaves China exposed to trade shocks.
China's economy entered the fourth quarter on a weaker footing than expected, with retail sales, industrial output and fixed-asset investment all missing forecasts in October — a sweep of disappointments that analysts at ING called 'a worrying start to Q4' and that deepens a pattern of sluggish domestic demand now in its fifth year.
Retail sales, the broadest gauge of consumer spending, rose just 0.4% year-on-year in October, falling short of market expectations of 0.8% and slowing sharply from a six-month high of 1.1% in September, according to official data. Industrial output expanded 4.8% from a year earlier, missing the 5.3% consensus forecast and decelerating from 5.5% in September. Fixed-asset investment — covering property, infrastructure and manufacturing — contracted 8.1% year-to-date through October, a steeper fall than the 7% decline analysts had projected and worse than the 7.2% recorded through September.
Three retail categories recorded double-digit year-on-year declines in October, according to ING. Gold and jewellery sales fell 28.7% as gold prices dropped. Auto sales slid 21.4%, as demand cooled after years of policy support pulled purchases forward and accelerated the shift to electric vehicles. Building and decoration materials fell 11.2%, weighed down by continued weakness in the property market.
The property sector remains a central drag. China's 70-city property price index recorded its 41st consecutive month of sequential declines in October, with new home prices down 0.15% month-on-month and used home prices down 0.24%, according to ING. The pace of monthly declines has slowed this year, offering what ING described as 'some rays of hope,' but the prolonged downturn continues to erode household wealth.
On the investment side, both private and public spending deteriorated. Private-led investment fell to -11.4% year-to-date, worsening from -10.4% through the first three quarters, while public-led investment dropped to -4.0% from -3.2%, according to ING. The bank said the September uptick in public investment 'was a blip rather than the start of a recovery.' Real estate investment contracted 21.6% year-to-date, infrastructure fell 5.1% and manufacturing declined 2.9%.
Industrial production was the relative bright spot, though even there the picture was uneven. High-tech manufacturing accelerated to 17.6% year-on-year growth, with semiconductor production up 21.9%, industrial robots up 26.0% and new-energy vehicle production up 17.1%, according to ING. But traditional sectors weakened: total vehicle production fell 7.7%, flat glass dropped 16.0%, steel products fell 5.1% and cement declined 1.3%.
The divergence between China's export performance and its domestic economy has grown more pronounced. Consumer inflation ticked down to 0.7% in October — its first deceleration after two straight months of increases — while exports surged 35.2%, more than expected, according to CNBC. China's trade surplus reached the $1 trillion threshold by October, the fastest it has ever hit that mark, and is on track to surpass last year's record $1.2 trillion full-year surplus.
That export strength has been heavily driven by global demand for AI-related technology and equipment, making it vulnerable to any pullback in that sector. Analysts at CNBC flagged renewed scrutiny of restricted chip flows to China following what was described as the 'Nvidia scandal' as an additional risk to the export outlook.
The market was already worried about a slowdown in the AI capital-spending cycle even before the Nvidia scandal that put flows of restricted chips to China under renewed scrutiny. Now the risk has become even more serious.— Zhiwei Zhang, President and Chief Economist, Pinpoint Asset Management
Trade tensions add a further layer of risk. Citi Research analysts warned that further trade restrictions from the European Union represent a critical downside risk for China's export engine heading into next year, according to CNBC. The bank said 'more EU trade measures targeting China look plausible,' though it noted Beijing is likely to be open to negotiating concessions such as import pledges and sector-specific deals.
Goldman Sachs expects China's economy to grow 4.6% in 2026, slowing from 5% in 2025 and easing further to 4.5% in 2027, according to CNBC. The bank cited soft domestic demand, abundant aggregate supply, easing commodity-price momentum and potential AI disruption risks as factors keeping inflation low, with consumer inflation projected at 0.8% this year and 0.5% in 2027. Despite the slowdown, Goldman said the projected growth rate still puts China on track to achieve Beijing's goal of doubling 2020 per capita income by 2035.
ING said restoring household confidence is 'essential to any effective policy response' and identified two main channels: stabilising asset prices and encouraging stronger wage growth. The bank warned that the trade-in subsidy policy, which had supported consumption earlier in the year, has now turned from a tailwind to a headwind, and that new methods to support consumption will be needed.
China's economy grew 4.5% year-on-year in the third quarter, bouncing from three-year lows.
Why it matters — China's domestic economy is increasingly unable to absorb the output its factories produce, and with export growth now dependent on AI-sector demand and vulnerable to new trade restrictions from the US and EU, the risk of a sharper slowdown in the world's second-largest economy is growing.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Goldman Sachs projects consumer inflation at 0.5% in 2027.
- exact release date November 16
- PMI contraction detail from Reuters
Reported by cnbc.com, reuters.com, think.ing.com