House Democrats introduce bill to put 10-year expiration on deportation orders for non-criminal immigrants
The 'Protect Our Neighbors Act,' inspired by the deportation of a 73-year-old grandmother, would also open a path to a green card for those whose orders lapse.
House Democrats introduced legislation Thursday that would, for the first time, put an expiration date on final orders of removal — the deportation orders that currently hang over roughly 1.6 million people in the United States with no time limit and no automatic off-ramp, regardless of how long they have lived here without incident.
California Rep. Lateefah Simon has introduced legislation dubbed the 'Protect Our Neighbors Act' that would automatically void a final removal order a decade after it was issued, as long as the person has remained continuously in the United States and carries no criminal convictions. Anyone whose order lapses under those terms would gain access to a path toward lawful permanent residency. Co-sponsors are California Democratic Reps. John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren, and Juan Vargas.
The direct inspiration for the legislation was Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old seamstress who had spent nearly three decades living in the San Francisco Bay Area. In September 2025, Kaur was detained during a routine check-in with Immigration and Customs Enforcement — the kind of appointment she had been keeping for over 13 years — and deported to India within days. ICE said an immigration judge had ordered her removed in 2005, but that order had never been enforced across all those years. She had held a valid work permit.
The pain we still feel today remains with the knowledge that Harjit is one of thousands who've experienced the same situation. We thank the members of Congress for their continued advocacy, and we hope that some good could come from Harjit's story with this bill and others like it.— Kaur family, statement
Garamendi, who worked on Kaur's case while she was detained, dedicated his guest seat at Trump's State of the Union address in February to her — and left it empty in protest after she was deported.
President Trump promised to go after the 'worst of the worst' in his immigration policy. Yet his administration has repeatedly decided to cruelly deport residents who have been working, paying taxes, and raising families in their communities for decades.— Rep. John Garamendi, statement
When an immigration judge or immigration authorities determine that a noncitizen must leave the United States or face deportation, the result is a final order of removal. Such an order takes effect once all administrative appeals have been exhausted or the window to appeal has closed. Under current law there is no expiration on such orders, leaving individuals in indefinite legal vulnerability even after decades of residence without a criminal record. While a final order gives ICE the legal authority to deport someone, deportation does not happen automatically — it can be delayed or suspended through government deferrals, stays of removal, ongoing litigation, or other circumstances.
The bill would still allow an immigration judge to renew an order after it has expired, but doing so would require 'clear and convincing evidence' that a significant cause — one unrelated to administrative or funding delays — explained why the original order was never carried out, and that renewal is in the public interest based on new evidence.
If you have deportation orders that have been in place for over 10 years, and you continue to do everything right, those deportation orders need to be again turned off, and you need to be able to be in line with other folks to get your green card to continue being a hardworking resident of these communities and hopefully a citizen.— Rep. Lateefah Simon, D-CA
During Trump's second administration, the Department of Homeland Security and ICE have broadened enforcement actions targeting people with final removal orders, including deportations carried out to third countries. According to ABC News, individuals who had been regularly attending mandatory immigration check-ins are now confronting a heightened risk of detention and deportation.
The bill is being introduced during the lame-duck session and is considered unlikely to advance before the end of the year. But Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress in the November midterm elections and will formally take office in January, giving the bill a clearer path to the floor in 2027. Simon told ABC News she has spoken to Democratic leadership about the legislation and expressed optimism about bipartisan support.
President Trump said in a CBS News '60 Minutes' interview that he would 'love to do something on immigration' with Democrats, though his openness to a deal does not mean he would back this specific measure. According to CiberCuba, Trump also acknowledged his deportation policy may have been 'too harsh,' but subsequently clarified there would be no amnesty.
Why it matters — For the estimated 1.6 million people in the U.S. living under open-ended deportation orders — many of them long-term residents with no criminal record — this bill represents the first legislative attempt to set a legal clock on their vulnerability and offer a route to permanent status.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Of the 42,000-plus Cubans with final deportation orders, at least 29,000 have criminal records.
- Trump acknowledged his deportation policy may have been 'too harsh' but subsequently clarified there would be no amnesty.
Reported by abcnews.com, en.cibercuba.com
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- Zoe LofgrenAmerican politician
- John GaramendiU.S. Representative from California
- Juan VargasAmerican politician