King Tides, El Niño and Thanksgiving Storms Set Up Major Coastal Flood Threat Coast to Coast
Tides half a foot higher than October's damaging floods, supercharged by record-warm seas and a powerful El Niño, are converging with multiple storms along both U.S. coasts during Thanksgiving week.
Kirk Miller raised his entire bayfront home in Corte Madera, California, by four feet a few years ago. It wasn't enough. For more than a month, water from San Francisco Bay has crept into his Mariner Cove neighborhood several times a week, flowing around homes and into the street. Now, with Thanksgiving king tides days away, he has organized his neighbors and the town to line a stretch of 14 properties with flood barriers, plastic sheeting and sandbags — a makeshift wall aimed at blocking tides up to eight feet. He is nervous it won't be tall enough.
We're all aware that if we don't work together, then it's not effective. I equate it to screen doors on a submarine. If you have 10 screen doors and you close nine, you might as well stay home.— Kirk Miller, Mariner Cove resident, Corte Madera
Miller's predicament is a ground-level preview of what forecasters are warning could be a damaging week for coastal communities from California to New England and Florida. King tides — the highest astronomical tides of the year — are expected to peak around Thanksgiving, and this year they arrive on top of record-warm ocean water, a powerful El Niño, and multiple storms bearing down on both coasts simultaneously.
Along the West Coast, the coming tides will be roughly half a foot higher than October's already damaging king tides, according to physical oceanographer Greg Dusek. In October, those tides produced record flood levels in Southern California, flooding roads and buildings in Los Angeles and San Diego, and eating away at beachfront properties. In the San Francisco Bay Area, tides already ran about two feet above predicted levels earlier this week, according to NOAA data cited by KQED. Next Wednesday, tides in San Francisco are expected to peak just above seven feet — but what is actually felt on the ground could run one to four feet higher because of wind, rain, El Niño-driven temporary sea-level rise, and waves, including a potential atmospheric river that same week.
That would potentially put us up to 9 feet.— Roger Gass, meteorologist, National Weather Service Bay Area office
Gass said forecasters are considering issuing a 'long-duration coastal flood advisory' for next week, though he said it is still too early to confirm. The National Weather Service offices in Los Angeles and Eureka, California, have already warned of potential record-breaking coastal flooding from Tuesday through Thanksgiving along stretches of the coast, according to weather.com.
In California, tides will be about half a foot higher than the highest in October. This means that even if El Niño doesn't increase water levels further, there will be significant flooding along the California coast.— Greg Dusek, physical oceanographer
The reason sea levels are so elevated comes down to several threats stacking on top of each other, scientists say. Human-caused global warming has already added between four and nine inches to sea levels over the past century, depending on location, meaning all tides now start from a permanently higher baseline. On top of that, this year's El Niño — which NOAA's Climate Prediction Center gives a 60 percent chance of becoming 'historic' — has driven warm ocean water toward the Pacific Coast in large blobs called Kelvin waves. Those waves have strengthened a marine heat wave already in place along California, pushing ocean temperatures more than 10 degrees Fahrenheit above average in places like San Diego, Santa Barbara and Monterey Bay, according to climate scientist Daniel Swain. That extra warmth causes thermal expansion, adding another six to 20 inches to sea levels depending on location, according to Scientific American. 'We've never seen water levels this high' in San Diego, said Mark Merrifield, a University of California, San Diego, oceanographer.
This is the strongest El Niño on record, and it is fueled by warmer seas than we have ever seen. Climate change is most definitely strengthening this El Niño.— Michael Beck, director, Center for Coastal Climate Resilience, UC Santa Cruz
King tides themselves are not unusual — they occur when Earth, the moon and the sun align and the moon is near its closest point to Earth, producing the year's highest predicted astronomical tides. What makes this year different is everything underneath them. Climate scientist Daniel Swain, with UC Agriculture and Natural Resources, said the elevated seas and king tides are '100% guaranteed.' The uncertainty is how much storms and big waves will add on top.
These are all places that could see major highways, and even neighborhoods, underwater. Don't be surprised if you can't drive on Highway 101 for multiple consecutive days.— Daniel Swain, climate scientist, UC Agriculture and Natural Resources
Swain is particularly concerned about bayside Marin, San Francisco and San Mateo counties, and parts of the East Bay including the island city of Alameda. He singled out San Rafael in Marin County, where much of the downtown and Canal neighborhood sit below sea level with a makeshift array of flood protections along the tidally influenced San Rafael Creek — and where his own family lives.
It is an irony not lost on me, though, that San Rafael is probably one of the most sea-level-rise-vulnerable parts of the Bay Area and arguably even of California.— Daniel Swain, climate scientist, UC Agriculture and Natural Resources
The flooding threat is not limited to California. King tide flooding is also a concern along stretches of the Oregon and Washington coasts, according to weather.com. On the East Coast, NOAA's monthly high tide flood outlook forecasts at least minor coastal tidal flooding at high tide for multiple days Thanksgiving week along much of the coast from Florida to Maine. In South Florida, October's king tides produced a record-long 10-day streak of moderate flooding at Virginia Key, near Miami — the highest water levels there outside of Hurricanes Irma or Wilma. Dusek predicted the highest tides in the Southeast during Thanksgiving week will be similar to what occurred in October.
On both coasts, storms arriving during the week will push additional water toward shore, compounding the tidal peaks. Battering waves accompanying those storms could worsen damage to coastal structures and accelerate beach erosion. Any rainfall will add further to high water levels.
Coastal flooding is going to be a big problem — a very, very big problem.— Daniel Swain, climate scientist, UC Agriculture and Natural Resources
Thanksgiving week is not the only window of concern. King tides are forecast to return the week of Christmas — when they are expected to be even higher than this week — and again around January 21 to 22. Scientific American reports that 80 percent of coastal erosion in California occurs during El Niño winters, according to Christina Richardson, a UC Santa Cruz coastal hydrologist. For those facing the coming tides, Richardson advises ensuring backup power for sump pumps, obtaining sandbags where communities are distributing them, and understanding the specific risks at their location — whether directly on the beach or further up an estuary.
I don't think we're gonna be able to manage all the risk out of this one. I really think that there's gonna be significant, fairly widespread flooding during at least some of these windows.— Daniel Swain, climate scientist, UC Agriculture and Natural Resources
Scientists are also framing this winter as a preview. Whatever damage occurs, Richardson says, it will serve as 'a preview of what's ahead of us,' with further climate-driven sea-level rise still to come. Swain echoed that: the potential flooding next week is 'a very big deal,' he said, because the Bay Area and California are not prepared for this level of sea-level rise — and it offers a glimpse of what could happen on a daily basis by mid-century.
Why it matters — Millions of people living or traveling along both U.S. coasts face a convergence of record ocean conditions and storms during one of the year's busiest travel weeks — and scientists warn this is a preview of conditions that could become routine by mid-century.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Forecasters are considering issuing a 'long-duration coastal flood advisory' for the Bay Area next week.
- An atmospheric river could arrive in the Bay Area during the same week as the Thanksgiving king tide peak.
- This El Niño could be the strongest such event in the past 1,000 years.
Reported by weather.com, scientificamerican.com, kqed.org